Research and Characteristic Analysis of A New Type of Dual Winding Electromagnetic Brake

Tongliang Liu, Shida SunInternational Journal of Mechanical and Electrical Engineering 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a new Double-Winding Electromagnetic Brake (DWEB) designed to overcome the overheating and performance degradation common in traditional single-winding brakes. By using two parallel coils, the design achieves higher power density and better thermal stability, though the study reveals significant performance shifts as the device reaches its operating temperature.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In industrial automation and heavy machinery, "power loss brakes" are a safety staple: they use springs to apply braking force by default and require an electromagnetic coil to be energized to release the brake.

The problem arises during long-term continuous operation. To keep the brake released, the coil must stay powered on, leading to significant heat buildup. In traditional single-winding electromagnetic brakes (SWEB), this heat causes the coil's resistance to rise, which reduces the electromagnetic force and can eventually lead to insulation failure or short circuits. The authors aim to solve this by introducing a dual-winding structure that improves power density and reliability.

Methods

The authors employed a multi-step analytical and simulation-based approach:

  • Equivalent Magnetic Circuit Method (EMCM): They modeled the brake as an "E-type" electromagnet and used Kirchhoff’s laws for magnetism to calculate flux and reluctance across different parts of the stator, armature, and air gaps.
  • Single-Variable Simulation: Using a simulation model, they isolated and optimized four key parameters: maximum air gap length, the area ratio of the inner and outer yokes, armature thickness, and the number of coil turns.
  • Magneto-Thermal Coupling Analysis: This is the "real-world" test. They simulated how the magnetic performance changes as the device heats up from room temperature to its steady-state operating temperature.

Datasets

As this is a mechanical engineering design paper, it does not use traditional "datasets" like a machine learning paper. Instead, the study relies on:

  • Physical Material Properties: Magnetization curves for low-carbon steel (used for the stator and armature).
  • Simulation Models: Custom-built models of the DWEB structure with specific dimensions (e.g., 300mm outer diameter, 170V rated voltage).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Parallel Efficiency: By connecting the inner and outer coils in parallel in the same direction, the total impedance of the circuit decreases. This allows for higher power density and a stronger electromagnetic force within the same physical volume compared to a single-winding design.
  • The "Middle Yoke" Effect: In an E-type core with two coils, the magnetic flux generated by the inner and outer coils actually opposes each other in the middle section of the stator. This results in a lower total flux in that specific area, which the authors found has a negligible impact on the overall braking force but is a critical detail for accurate modeling.
  • Optimization Sweet Spots:
    • Yoke Ratio: An area ratio of 1.1:1 (inner to outer) was found to be the peak for electromagnetic force.
  • Armature Thickness: Increasing thickness reduces magnetic reluctance (good for force) but increases the time it takes for the brake to close (bad for sensitivity). They settled on 16mm as the ideal balance.

Key Results

The study provides a clear picture of how heat affects performance (comparing "Normal" vs. "Working" temperatures):

  • Force & Power: As the coil heats up, resistance increases and current drops. This leads to an 18.5% decrease in total ampere-turns and power, and a 15.2% decrease in rated electromagnetic force (from 10,016N down to 8,495N).
  • Response Time: Temperature rise significantly slows down the "release" phase. The release time increased by 39.7% (from 0.68s to 0.95s), while the closing time shortened by 19.3% (from 0.62s to 0.50s).
  • Thermal Gradient: The inner coil runs significantly hotter (106.2°C) than the outer coil (82.8°C) due to its smaller volume and higher thermal load.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation is that the results are based entirely on theoretical calculations and simulations. While the magneto-thermal coupling provides a sophisticated look at performance, the paper does not include data from a physical prototype.

Future work would likely involve:

  1. Experimental Validation: Building a physical DWEB to verify the simulation results.
  2. Active Cooling: Exploring heat dissipation structures to further mitigate the 15-40% performance swings observed during the temperature rise.
  3. Material Science: Testing different ferromagnetic materials to see if the "middle yoke" flux cancellation can be further minimized.

Summary updated

Abstract

Taking the electromagnetic brake as the research object, a new structure of double-winding electromagnetic brake is proposed in view of the serious temperature rise phenomenon of traditional single-winding electromagnetic brake, the high requirement of insulation level and the obvious decrease of electromagnetic force. The equivalent magnetic circuit method is used to analyze and calculate the magnetic field, and the simulation model of the new brake is constructed, and the influence of different parameters on the braking characteristics of the double-winding electromagnetic brake is analyzed by the single-variable method, and the influence curves of each parameter on the electromagnetic force and response time are obtained. At the same time, the magnetic-thermal coupling analysis of the double-winding electromagnetic brake is carried out, and the results show that the total ampere-turns and power of the double-winding electromagnetic brake decreases by 15.3% in the same proportion, the rated electromagnetic force decreases by 22.9%, the release time grows by 23.7%, and the closure time is shortened by 14.6%.
BibTeX
@article{liu2024research,
  author = {Tongliang Liu and Shida Sun},
  title = {{Research and Characteristic Analysis of A New Type of Dual Winding Electromagnetic Brake}},
  journal = {International Journal of Mechanical and Electrical Engineering},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.62051/ijmee.v2n2.13},
}

Loading related content...

Figure