Resampling-Based Confidence Regions and Multiple Tests for a Correlated Random Vector

Sylvain Arlot, Gilles Blanchard, Étienne RoquainCOLT 2007 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces novel, non-asymptotic methods for constructing confidence regions for the mean of a random vector with unknown dependence structure. These methods leverage resampling techniques and offer improved performance over traditional approaches like Bonferroni correction, especially when dealing with correlated data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The core problem this paper tackles is the construction of reliable confidence regions for the mean of a random vector, particularly when the vector's components are correlated and their dependence structure is unknown. Traditional methods often rely on asymptotic assumptions or strong distributional assumptions (like Gaussianity) that may not hold in practice. Furthermore, when these confidence regions are used for multiple hypothesis testing (e.g., testing if each component of the mean is less than or equal to zero), controlling the family-wise error rate becomes crucial. Existing methods like the Bonferroni correction can be overly conservative, especially with correlated data, leading to reduced power. The authors aim to provide non-asymptotic guarantees for confidence regions that are more accurate and applicable to a broader range of scenarios.

Methods

The paper proposes two main approaches for constructing these confidence regions:

  1. Concentration Method: This approach uses a data-dependent threshold derived from a weighted bootstrap procedure. It leverages concentration inequalities to bound the deviation of the estimated mean from the true mean. A key advantage is its generality, allowing for a wide class of resampling weights.
  2. Resampled Quantile Method: This method directly estimates the quantiles of the distribution of a resampled statistic. While more restrictive in terms of the resampling weights (specifically using Rademacher weights), it is shown to be more accurate in practice. This approach is inspired by the idea of using resampled quantiles to approximate the true quantiles of the statistic of interest.

Both methods aim for non-asymptotic control of the confidence level, meaning the guarantees hold for any fixed sample size, not just in the limit.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and uses simulated data for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Non-asymptotic Guarantees are Achievable: The paper demonstrates that it's possible to derive rigorous, non-asymptotic confidence intervals for the mean of correlated random vectors, even without knowing the exact dependence structure. This is a significant theoretical contribution.
  • Resampling as a Powerful Tool: Both concentration and quantile-based resampling methods prove effective. The weighted bootstrap is central to both, allowing for data-driven threshold selection.
  • Trade-off Between Generality and Accuracy: The concentration method is more general in terms of applicable resampling weights, while the resampled quantile method, though restricted to Rademacher weights, yields more accurate confidence regions in simulations.
  • Improved Performance for Correlated Data: The proposed methods significantly outperform the Bonferroni procedure when the coordinates of the random vector are sufficiently correlated. This highlights the limitations of methods that ignore or poorly handle dependence.
  • "Stabilization" of Resampled Quantities: The paper points out that resampled quantities in the quantile approach tend to concentrate around their expectation at a fast rate (n⁻¹), making them almost deterministic and thus reliable for constructing confidence intervals.

Key Results

  • The paper provides theoretical results (Theorems 2.1, Corollaries 2.2, Propositions 2.4, 2.6, 2.8, 3.1, Corollary 3.3) establishing non-asymptotic confidence regions for the mean of Gaussian and symmetrically distributed random vectors.
  • Simulations (Section 4) show that the proposed confidence regions are smaller than Bonferroni thresholds when correlations are strong, leading to increased power in multiple testing scenarios.
  • The "compound" threshold (Corollary 2.2) offers a flexible approach that can adapt to the Bonferroni threshold when necessary, providing a safety net.
  • The resampled quantile method generally leads to tighter confidence regions compared to the concentration method, especially for correlated data.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Distributional Assumptions: While the methods are designed to be general, some results rely on assumptions like Gaussianity (GA) or symmetric bounded distributions (SA, BA). The paper acknowledges that for full generality, further assumptions might be needed, and the "trailing term" in some bounds might require additional regularity assumptions on the data distribution beyond symmetry.
  • Choice of Resampling Weights: The paper discusses the trade-off between accuracy and computational complexity when choosing resampling weights (Table 2). While it provides guidance, the "best" choice can depend on the specific application and sample size.
  • Computational Cost: Exact computation of some resampling estimates can be time-consuming for large datasets. The paper suggests Monte Carlo simulations as a practical alternative.
  • Open Issues: The paper identifies the need for additional regularity assumptions on data distributions to obtain fully self-contained bounds in certain cases, which remains an interesting open research question. Future work could explore these additional assumptions and their impact on confidence region construction. The paper also notes that the quantile threshold has a larger standard deviation than the concentration threshold, suggesting further investigation into variance reduction for quantile-based methods.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study generalized bootstrapped confidence regions for the mean of a random vector whose coordinates have an unknown dependence structure, with a non-asymptotic control of the confidence level. The random vector is supposed to be either Gaussian or to have a symmetric bounded distribution. We consider two approaches, the first based on a concentration principle and the second on a direct boostrapped quantile. The first one allows us to deal with a very large class of resampling weights while our results for the second are restricted to Rademacher weights. However, the second method seems more accurate in practice. Our results are motivated by multiple testing problems, and we show on simulations that our procedures are better than the Bonferroni procedure (union bound) as soon as the observed vector has sufficiently correlated coordinates.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{arlot2007resampling,
  author = {Sylvain Arlot and Gilles Blanchard and Étienne Roquain},
  title = {{Resampling-Based Confidence Regions and Multiple Tests for a Correlated Random Vector}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Learning Theory},
  year = {2007},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=pGnJL6R-opZ},
}
Figure