Reproducibility of tract segmentation between sessions using an unsupervised modelling-based approach

Jonathan D. Clayden, Amos J. Storkey, Susana Muñoz Maniega, Mark E. BastinNeuroImage 2009 · DOI · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces an unsupervised, model-based approach to segmenting white matter tracts in diffusion MRI data. By optimizing seed point placement and leveraging an Expectation-Maximization algorithm, the method achieves high reproducibility, comparable to manual methods but with greater automation and efficiency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Diffusion MRI (dMRI) is a powerful tool for studying white matter integrity in the brain, which is crucial for understanding various neurological conditions. However, accurately segmenting these white matter tracts is a significant challenge. Previous methods often relied on manual region-of-interest (ROI) placement, which is time-consuming and subjective, or less sophisticated automated techniques. Ensuring that these segmentation methods are reproducible, both within a single subject across different scanning sessions and between different subjects, is critical for reliable group-level analysis in clinical studies. This paper aims to address this by developing a more automated and reproducible tract segmentation method.

Methods

The core of this work is an "unsupervised neighbourhood tractography" (NT) approach. Unlike previous NT methods that required a "training" phase with pre-defined examples, this new method is fully unsupervised. It uses a probabilistic model to optimize the placement of seed points for fiber tracking.

Here's a breakdown of the key steps:

  • Reference Tracts: Standardized B-spline curves representing the typical trajectory of specific white matter fasciculi (e.g., cingulum bundles, corticospinal tracts) are created from a white matter atlas. These serve as a guide for segmentation.
  • Candidate Tract Generation: For each individual brain volume, a set of candidate tracts is generated by seeding the tractography algorithm within a small neighborhood around the transformed reference tract's seed point.
  • Matching Phase: An Expectation-Maximization (EM) algorithm is employed to assess the similarity between candidate tracts and the reference tract. This algorithm automatically determines the most likely seed point that generates a tract closely matching the reference, without requiring manual intervention or prior training data.
  • Segmentation Phase: Once the best matching seed point is identified, the tractography algorithm is run again from that point to generate the final segmented tract.
  • Variance Components Analysis: A random effects model is used to separate within-subject (test-retest) and between-subject variances for quantitative measures like fractional anisotropy (FA) and mean diffusivity (MD) within the segmented tracts.

Datasets

The study used dMRI data from eight healthy, right-handed volunteer subjects (four male, four female) who underwent scanning on three separate occasions over two months. The data was acquired using a GE Signa LX 1.5 T clinical system. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing dMRI protocols and analysis pipelines were adapted.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unsupervised Tract Segmentation: The development of a fully unsupervised method for optimizing seed point placement is a significant advancement, reducing the need for manual intervention and prior training data.
  • EM Algorithm for Robust Matching: The use of an Expectation-Maximization algorithm allows for a robust probabilistic model-based approach to tract similarity assessment, providing a "goodness-of-match" measure.
  • Efficient Use of Data: The unsupervised approach makes more efficient use of available data compared to previous supervised methods.
  • Tract-Specific Signatures: The study demonstrates that different white matter tracts have distinct quantitative signatures (FA and MD values), forming distinct clusters in a scatter plot, which is important for tract-specific analysis.
  • Streamline Reduction Impact: The research shows that reducing the number of streamlines used for tract matching has a minimal impact on the correlation of log-likelihoods, suggesting that calculation times can be substantially reduced without significantly compromising results.

Key Results

  • Reproducibility: The method achieved test-retest coefficients of variation (CVs) for FA similar to those reported for landmark-guided single seed points (3.9-7.4% range compared to 5.0-7.1%).
  • Between-Subject Variance: The intersubject CVs were comparable to those obtained with constraint-based multiple ROI methods (3.8-9.2% for FA).
  • Efficiency: The study demonstrated that reducing the number of streamlines from 5000 to 1000 could reduce calculation time from approximately 4 hours to 1 hour per brain volume with minimal loss in correlation.
  • Tract Specificity: Figure 5 clearly shows distinct clusters for cingulum bundles, genu, and pyramidal tracts in an FA-MD scatter plot, indicating that these measures are specific to each tract.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Comparison with Other Methods: While the authors compare their results to previous studies, a direct comparison using the exact same data set is not possible.
  • Crossing Fibers: The current tractography algorithm (BEDPOST/Probtrack) cannot resolve multiple fiber orientations within a voxel, leading to some visible aberrant branching pathways. The authors suggest that more advanced algorithms capable of resolving crossing fibers would likely improve results.
  • Thresholding Arbitrariness: The use of a fixed threshold (1% of total streamlines) for segmentation is acknowledged as arbitrary. Future work could explore using the tract shape model itself to identify and remove outlying streamlines, obviating the need for a voxelwise threshold.
  • Pathology and Registration: The paper notes that while the method is adaptable to nonlinear registration for pathology, perfect registration is not a theoretical requirement. Extensive exploration of the method's performance in diseased cohorts is left for future work.
  • Streamline Reduction Generalization: The impact of reducing streamlines is tract- and data-dependent, and algorithms capable of resolving crossing fibers might further reduce this impact.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{clayden2009reproducibility,
  author = {Jonathan D. Clayden and Amos J. Storkey and Susana Muñoz Maniega and Mark E. Bastin},
  title = {{Reproducibility of tract segmentation between sessions using an unsupervised modelling-based approach}},
  journal = {NeuroImage},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1016/j.neuroimage.2008.12.010},
}
Figure