TL;DR
This paper explores using geometric transformations, inspired by knowledge graph embeddings, to represent syntactic relationships in natural language. They demonstrate that these lighter-weight models can effectively capture syntax for improved word and phrase representations, outperforming traditional methods in certain tasks.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Traditional distributional semantic models (DSMs) that incorporate syntactic information often suffer from a large number of parameters and data sparsity. While some models have attempted to address this, they often rely on linear transformations to encode syntactic relations, which can be limiting. The authors aim to leverage the success of geometric transformations (GTs) from the knowledge graph literature, which have shown promise in efficiently encoding complex relationships, to improve syntactic representations in DSMs and enhance compositional semantics.
Methods
The core of this work is adapting geometric transformations (GTs) commonly used in knowledge graph embedding models to represent syntactic graphs (SyGs). Specifically, they investigate models like MuRE, RotE, RefE, and AttE, which employ transformations such as rotation, reflection, and attention. These models are used to learn embeddings for words and syntactic relations. The paper also proposes three novel syntax-aware composition strategies: syn-Rh (root as head), syn-Rt (root as tail), and syn-BiD (bidirectional), which combine representations based on syntactic structure. These are compared against a simple additive baseline.
Datasets
- Training:
- WN18RR: A knowledge graph dataset.
- text8: A corpus parsed into syntactic graphs.
- Evaluation:
- Word Similarity: SimLex, MEN, WS_s, WS_r (from WordSim353).
- Composition: Mitchell and Lapata (ML10) dataset, which includes pairs of two-token phrases and human similarity judgments, categorized by syntactic relation (adjective-nouns, verb-objects, noun-nouns).
Key Insights and Ideas
- GTs for Syntax: Geometric transformations, proven effective for knowledge graphs, can be successfully adapted to encode syntactic relationships, offering a lighter-weight alternative to existing methods.
- Reflection's Promise: Among the GTs explored, reflection (RefE) appears to be particularly effective in encoding syntactic relations and supporting compositional tasks.
- Bidirectional Composition: A bidirectional composition strategy (syn-BiD), which combines root-as-head and root-as-tail representations, consistently yields the best performance, suggesting the importance of considering information from multiple syntactic perspectives.
- Syntax Matters for Composition: Syntax-aware composition strategies significantly outperform simple additive composition, especially for models trained on syntactic data.
- Brain-Inspired Separation: The finding that bidirectional phrase representations lie distant from word representations, even when composed, aligns with some neuroscientific theories suggesting distinct processing for words, phrases, and sentences.
Key Results
- Word Similarity: GT models trained on text8 generally outperform the Dependency Matrix (DM) model and achieve comparable or better results than KG-trained models on word similarity benchmarks.
- Composition: GT models, particularly RefE, with syntax-aware composition strategies (especially syn-BiD), significantly outperform the additive baseline and DM on the ML10 compositional benchmark. For instance, RefE with syn-BiD achieved the best average score.
- DM's Weakness: The DM model, relying on unconstrained linear maps, struggles to improve performance with syntax-aware composition, showing higher variation in results compared to GT models.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations:
- The study acknowledges that the text8 corpus used for training is significantly smaller than those used by other models in prior work, which might explain some performance differences on certain benchmarks (e.g., SimLex).
- The paper focuses on two-token phrases for composition and does not explore more complex structures like relative clauses.
- Future Work:
- Investigate composition on larger scales.
- Explore syntactic-relation composition.
- Examine whether syntactic and semantic graphs can be embedded simultaneously within this framework.
Summary updated