Replication and discovery of musculoskeletal QTLs in LG/J and SM/J advanced intercross lines

Ana I. Hernández Cordero, Peter Carbonetto, Gioia Riboni-Verri, J.s. Gregory, David J. Vandenbergh, Joseph P. Gyekis, David A. Blizard, Arimantas LionikasPhysiological 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study maps genetic variations (QTLs) influencing muscle and bone traits in a mouse model, replicating known QTLs and discovering new ones. By analyzing a large population of advanced intercross lines, the researchers identified specific genomic regions associated with muscle mass and tibia length, providing a foundation for understanding the genetic basis of musculoskeletal health.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Individual differences in muscle mass and skeletal size are significant, impacting metabolism, energy expenditure, and even longevity. While genetics plays a crucial role in these variations, the specific genes and genomic regions (Quantitative Trait Loci or QTLs) responsible for musculoskeletal traits are not fully understood. Previous studies have identified some QTLs in mouse models like the LG/J and SM/J strains, but these findings need further refinement and confirmation. This paper aims to address this by mapping QTLs for muscle and bone traits in a well-established advanced intercross line (AIL) derived from these strains, seeking to replicate previous findings and discover novel genetic influences.

Methods

The researchers employed two primary analytical software packages for QTL mapping: GEMMA and QTLRel. Both are based on linear mixed models (LMMs), a robust approach for accounting for population structure and "cryptic relatedness" among individuals, which can inflate false positive associations. A key methodological choice was the use of AILs, specifically the 50th filial generation (F50) of the LG/SM lineage. AILs are generated by intercrossing two distinct inbred strains for many generations, leading to increased recombination and higher resolution for mapping QTLs compared to traditional F2 crosses.

GEMMA was chosen for its computational efficiency, requiring substantially less processing time than QTLRel. Notably, GEMMA models only additive genetic effects, while QTLRel can also account for dominance effects. The study found that GEMMA recovered all QTLs identified by QTLRel, suggesting that for this dataset and these traits, the inclusion of dominance effects in QTLRel did not significantly increase QTL detection power, making GEMMA a more practical choice for large populations.

To identify candidate genes within the identified QTL regions, the researchers used a multi-pronged approach:

  1. In silico analysis: Examining gene expression data from databases like BioGPS and GEO, and comparing mRNA abundance between the LG/J and SM/J strains.
  2. Functional prediction: Assessing the impact of nonsynonymous single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and indel variants on protein function using tools like Poly-Phen2 and SIFT.
  3. Experimental validation: Conducting quantitative RT-PCR (qPCR) to measure gene expression differences in homozygous LG/J versus SM/J mice for specific candidate genes.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 506 male mice from the 50th filial generation (F50) of the LG/SM advanced intercross line (AIL). These mice were derived from the LG/J and SM/J inbred strains.

Phenotypic data collected included:

  • Weights of four hindlimb muscles: tibialis anterior (TA), extensor digitorum longus (EDL), gastrocnemius (gastroc), and soleus.
  • Tibia length.

Genotypic data were obtained using the MEGA Mouse Universal Genotyping Array, yielding approximately 75,746 SNPs. A subset of 7,236 SNPs polymorphic between the LG/J and SM/J strains was selected for genome-wide association analyses.

The study also referenced existing datasets for gene expression analysis, including:

  • RNA-Seq data from Lionikas et al. (2012) for skeletal muscle.
  • Publicly available databases like BioGPS and Gene Expression Omnibus (GEO).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • AILs are powerful for fine-mapping: The use of a 50th-generation AIL significantly increased recombination, allowing for more precise localization of QTLs compared to earlier generations or simpler crosses.
  • GEMMA is a computationally efficient alternative: The study demonstrated that GEMMA, which only considers additive effects, can effectively identify QTLs comparable to QTLRel (which includes dominance effects) but with a substantial reduction in computational time, making it ideal for large-scale studies.
  • Heritability exceeds additive QTL effects: The estimated SNP heritability for muscle mass (0.46-0.56) and tibia length (0.40) was considerably higher than the cumulative effect of the identified QTLs (which explained only a fraction of the variance). This suggests a complex genetic architecture involving interactions (epistasis) or other factors contributing to the "missing heritability."
  • Replication and Novelty: The study successfully replicated previously identified QTLs for muscle and bone traits, while also discovering six novel QTLs for muscle weight, underscoring the value of continued investigation in AILs.
  • Candidate gene prioritization is crucial: The systematic approach to identifying candidate genes within QTL intervals, combining in silico analysis with experimental validation (qPCR), is essential for pinpointing genes likely responsible for the observed phenotypic variation.

Key Results

  • SNP Heritability: Muscle mass exhibited SNP heritability ranging from 0.46 to 0.56, while tibia length had an estimate of 0.40.
  • QTLs Identified:
    • Seven significant QTLs were identified for muscle weight on chromosomes 1, 7, 11, 12, 13, 15, and 16.
  • Two significant QTLs were identified for tibia length on chromosomes 1 and 13.
  • Effect Size: Each identified QTL explained approximately 4-5% of the phenotypic variation.
  • Replication: One muscle QTL (on Chr 7) and both bone QTLs (on Chr 1 and 13) replicated previous findings. The remaining six QTLs were novel.
  • Computational Speed: GEMMA was approximately 10 times faster than QTLRel for QTL mapping.

Limitations and Future Work

  • "Missing Heritability": The most significant limitation highlighted is the substantial gap between the estimated SNP heritability and the cumulative effect of the identified QTLs. This suggests that a larger sample size is needed to uncover the full genetic architecture, potentially including epistatic interactions or rare variants.
  • Limited Replication of Muscle QTLs: While bone QTLs were well-replicated, the replication of muscle QTLs was modest. The authors suggest this might be due to differences in covariates used in previous studies (e.g., adjusting for tibia length in this study to capture muscle-specific effects) or the use of earlier generation intercrosses in prior work.
  • Candidate Gene Function: While promising candidate genes were identified, their precise roles in mediating the observed phenotypic differences require further experimental investigation.
  • Future Directions: The authors explicitly state that a larger sample size is necessary to further dissect the genetic architecture and resolve the "missing heritability." Further functional studies on the identified candidate genes are also warranted to confirm their roles in muscle and bone development and function.

Summary updated

Abstract

The genetics underlying variation in health-related musculoskeletal phenotypes can be investigated in a mouse model. Quantitative trait loci (QTLs) affecting musculoskeletal traits in the LG/J and SM/J strain lineage remain to be refined and corroborated. The aim of this study was to map muscle and bone traits in males (n = 506) of the 50th filial generation of advanced intercross lines (LG/SM AIL) derived from the two strains. Genetic contribution to variation in all musculoskeletal traits was confirmed; the SNP heritability of muscle mass ranged between 0.46 and 0.56; and the SNP heritability of tibia length was 0.40. We used two analytical software, GEMMA and QTLRel, to map the underlying QTLs. GEMMA required substantially less computation and recovered all the QTLs identified by QTLRel. Seven significant QTLs were identified for muscle weight (Chr 1, 7, 11, 12, 13, 15, and 16), and two for tibia length, (Chr 1 and 13). Each QTL explained 4-5% of phenotypic variation. One muscle and both bone loci replicated previous findings; the remaining six were novel. Positional candidates for the replicated QTLs were prioritized based on in silico analyses and gene expression in muscle tissue. In summary, we replicated existing QTLs and identified novel QTLs affecting muscle weight, and replicated bone length QTLs in LG/SM AIL males. Heritability estimates substantially exceed the cumulative effect of the QTLs, hence a richer genetic architecture contributing to muscle and bone variability could be uncovered with a larger sample size.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cordero2018replication,
  author = {Ana I. Hernández Cordero and Peter Carbonetto and Gioia Riboni-Verri and J.S. Gregory and David J. Vandenbergh and Joseph P. Gyekis and David A. Blizard and Arimantas Lionikas},
  title = {{Replication and discovery of musculoskeletal QTLs in LG/J and SM/J advanced intercross lines}},
  booktitle = {Physiological},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.14814/phy2.13561},
}
Figure