Repeated Sub-Concussive Impacts and the Negative Effects of Contact Sports on Cognition and Brain Integrity

Michail Ntikas, Ferdinand Binkofski, N. Jon Shah, Magdalena IetswaartInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This review synthesizes current evidence on the detrimental effects of repetitive sub-concussive head impacts in contact sports on brain health and cognitive function. It highlights the need for advanced neuroscientific methods and policy changes to mitigate these risks, emphasizing that even impacts below the threshold of concussion can lead to cumulative damage.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While sports offer numerous physical and mental health benefits, contact sports present a significant risk of head injuries. Beyond overt concussions, there's growing concern about the cumulative effects of repeated, lower-force head impacts, termed "sub-concussive impacts." These impacts, common in sports like soccer, American football, and rugby, occur frequently throughout an athlete's career. The problem this paper addresses is the lack of a comprehensive understanding of how these repeated sub-concussive impacts affect brain integrity and cognitive function over time, and the potential long-term consequences, such as neurodegeneration. Existing research often conflates concussion and sub-concussion, making it difficult to isolate the effects of the latter.

Methods

This paper is a review, synthesizing existing research rather than presenting new experimental data. The authors analyze findings from various neuroscientific modalities used to study the effects of repetitive sub-concussive head impacts (RSHI). These include:

  • Neurocognitive Testing: Standardized tests assessing memory, attention, learning, and reaction time.
  • Neuroimaging:
    • Structural MRI: Techniques like voxel-based morphometry and diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) to detect changes in brain structure (e.g., cortical thinning, white matter abnormalities).
  • Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy (MRS): To assess neurometabolic changes (e.g., alterations in N-acetyl aspartate, glutamate, glutamine, creatine, choline).
  • Functional MRI (fMRI): To examine changes in brain activity and functional connectivity.
  • Quantitative MRI (qMRI): Advanced techniques for precise measurement of physical parameters like water content (oedema) and relaxation times.
  • Electrophysiology:
    • Electroencephalography (EEG): Specifically, event-related potentials (ERPs) to assess attention and cognitive processing.
  • Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS): To measure intracortical inhibition and cortical silent periods.
  • Fluid Biomarkers: Analysis of blood or cerebrospinal fluid for markers of axonal damage, neuroinflammation, and neuronal integrity (e.g., NfL, S100b, tau, NSE).

The review emphasizes the need for a multimethods approach, combining these techniques to gain a more complete picture.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper reviews existing studies, which would have used various datasets from participants in contact sports and control groups.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Silent" Threat: Sub-concussive impacts, while not causing immediate concussion symptoms, can accumulate over time and lead to measurable deficits and structural changes in the brain. This highlights a significant, often overlooked, risk in contact sports.
  • Early Detection is Key: Neuroimaging and fluid biomarkers show promise in detecting brain changes before overt neurocognitive symptoms appear, suggesting these methods are crucial for early identification of RSHI effects.
  • Mechanisms Remain Elusive: While various markers of brain alteration are identified (e.g., axonal damage, neuroinflammation, altered neurometabolism), the precise physiological mechanisms linking RSHI to these changes and subsequent cognitive deficits are still not fully understood.
  • Concussion vs. Sub-Concussion: The paper stresses the importance of distinguishing between the effects of single concussive events and the cumulative impact of repeated sub-concussive blows, as they may have different or additive effects.
  • Policy Lag: Governing bodies are beginning to implement policy changes (e.g., in soccer heading guidelines), but these are often reactive and not fully informed by robust scientific evidence on safe limits or mitigation strategies.

Key Results

  • Cognitive Impairment: Studies show mixed results, but some indicate that RSHI can impair specific cognitive domains like memory, attention, and learning. For instance, performing 20 soccer headers has been linked to impaired pair associative learning.
  • Structural Brain Changes: MRI studies have revealed cortical thinning, white matter abnormalities, and reduced grey matter density in athletes with a history of RSHI, even in the absence of diagnosed concussions.
  • Metabolic Alterations: MRS studies have shown changes in neurometabolites (e.g., reduced N-acetyl aspartate, altered glutamate/glutamine) in contact sport athletes, suggesting glial dysfunction and altered neural signaling.
  • Functional Connectivity Changes: fMRI studies indicate altered functional connectivity in brain networks, particularly in the default mode and visual networks, in athletes exposed to RSHI.
  • Biomarker Evidence: Fluid biomarkers like NfL and S100b have shown increases in athletes after exposure to RSHI, though findings can be mixed and influenced by other factors like exercise.
  • TMS Findings: TMS studies suggest increased cortical silent periods after routine heading or tackling, indicative of altered brain inhibition.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Conflation of Effects: A significant limitation is the difficulty in disentangling the effects of RSHI from those of overt concussions and general physical exertion in many studies.
  • Mixed Cognitive Findings: The inconsistency in neurocognitive testing results highlights the need for more sensitive and specific assessment tools.
  • Limited Longitudinal Data: While some longitudinal studies exist, more are needed to definitively establish the long-term consequences of RSHI and the link between acute/sub-acute effects and chronic neurodegenerative diseases.
  • Dose-Response Relationship: It is currently unknown how much sport-related impact is "safe." Future research needs to establish clear dose-response relationships for RSHI.
  • Mechanism Elucidation: Further research is required to fully understand the underlying biological mechanisms of RSHI-induced brain damage.
  • Interdisciplinary Approach: The authors strongly advocate for a more interdisciplinary and multimethods approach, combining neuroimaging, electrophysiology, fluid biomarkers, and cognitive testing to build a more compelling evidence base.
  • Policy Guidance: More research is urgently needed to guide governing bodies in developing evidence-based policies to protect athletes' brain health.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sports are yielding a wealth of benefits for cardiovascular fitness, for psychological resilience, and for cognition. The amount of practice, and the type of practiced sports, are of importance to obtain these benefits and avoid any side effects. This is especially important in the context of contact sports. Contact sports are not only known to be a major source of injuries of the musculoskeletal apparatus, they are also significantly related to concussion and sub-concussion. Sub-concussive head impacts accumulate throughout the active sports career, and thus can cause measurable deficits and changes to brain health. Emerging research in the area of cumulative sub-concussions in contact sports has revealed several associated markers of brain injury. For example, recent studies discovered that repeated headers in soccer not only cause measurable signs of cognitive impairment but are also related to a prolonged cortical silent period in transcranial magnetic stimulation measurements. Other cognitive and neuroimaging biomarkers are also pointing to adverse effects of heading. A range of fluid biomarkers completes the picture of cumulating effects of sub-concussive impacts. Those accumulating effects can cause significant cognitive impairment later in life of active contact sportswomen and men. The aim of this review is to highlight the current scientific evidence on the effects of repeated sub-concussive head impacts on contact sports athletes' brains, identify the areas in need of further investigation, highlight the potential of advanced neuroscientific methods, and comment on the steps governing bodies have made to address this issue. We conclude that there are indeed neural and biofluid markers that can help better understand the effects of repeated sub-concussive head impacts and that some aspects of contact sports should be redefined, especially in situations where sub-concussive impacts and concussions can be minimized.
BibTeX
@article{ntikas2022repeated,
  author = {Michail Ntikas and Ferdinand Binkofski and N. Jon Shah and Magdalena Ietswaart},
  title = {{Repeated Sub-Concussive Impacts and the Negative Effects of Contact Sports on Cognition and Brain Integrity}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph19127098},
}
Figure