Abstract
Many cortical areas increase in size considerably during postnatal development, progressively displacing neuronal cell bodies from each other. At present, little is known about how cortical growth affects the development of neuronal circuits. Here, in acute and chronic experiments, we study the layout of ocular dominance (OD) columns in cat primary visual cortex during a period of substantial postnatal growth. We find that despite a considerable size increase of primary visual cortex, the spacing between columns is largely preserved. In contrast, their spatial arrangement changes systematically over this period. Whereas in young animals columns are more band-like, layouts become more isotropic in mature animals. We propose a novel mechanism of growth-induced reorganization that is based on the "zigzag instability," a dynamical instability observed in several inanimate pattern-forming systems. We argue that this mechanism is inherent to a wide class of models for the activity-dependent formation of OD columns. Analyzing one representative of this class, the Elastic Network model, we show that this mechanism can account for the preservation of column spacing and the specific mode of reorganization of OD columns that we observe. We conclude that column width is preserved by systematic reorganization of neuronal selectivities during cortical expansion and that this reorganization is well described by the zigzag instability. Our work suggests that cortical circuits may remain plastic for an extended period in development to facilitate the modification of neuronal circuits to adjust for cortical growth.
Introduction
During postnatal development, the mammalian brain undergoes massive physical expansion. In cats, the surface area of the primary visual cortex (V1) increases by a factor of approximately 2.5 between weeks 1 and 12. This creates a fundamental neurobiological puzzle: how do functional circuits—which are already active and processing information—adjust to this changing physical landscape?
One intuitive hypothesis is the "balloon effect," where functional columns simply stretch along with the growing tissue. However, if the spacing between columns is tied to specific neural computation requirements, stretching might degrade performance. This study investigates whether columns stretch, if new columns are inserted, or if the system employs a more complex reorganization strategy to maintain its functional geometry during growth.
Methods
The authors combined experimental observations with mathematical modeling. Ocular dominance (OD) columns were mapped in kittens from Postnatal Day 28 to 98 using acute labeling (2-DG and $[^3H]$-proline autoradiography) and chronic intrinsic signal optical imaging. A wavelet-method was employed to precisely measure two parameters: column spacing ($\Lambda$) and "bandedness" ($\alpha$), which quantifies the transition from stripe-like to patchy patterns.
To explain the biological findings, the researchers utilized the Elastic Network (EN) model, a standard framework for activity-dependent neural development, introducing cortical expansion into the simulations to test different growth scenarios.
Experimental Results
Analysis of the biological data revealed that the "balloon effect" is incorrect. While the V1 area increased by nearly 50% in the studied samples, the spacing between OD columns remained virtually constant ($r = -0.034, p < 0.825$). Because the area grows while spacing is fixed, the total number of functional units, or "hypercolumns," in V1 increased significantly.
However, the shape of the columns changed systematically. In younger animals, columns appeared as long, parallel stripes (high bandedness). As the cortex grew, these stripes became more "isotropic"—bending and becoming patchier. The bandedness parameter $\alpha$ decreased by nearly a factor of 2 over the developmental period.
The Zigzag Instability and Computational Modeling
The authors identify a link to physics to explain this reorganization: the "zigzag instability." In pattern-forming systems like fluid convection rolls, forcing a striped pattern to expand makes it unstable; the stripes "zigzag" to restore their original characteristic wavelength.
When subjected to expansion, the Elastic Network model perfectly replicated the biological observations: a transient spacing increase followed by a drop in bandedness as the pattern reorganized. This suggests that the brain maintains functional spacing by dynamically reconfiguring neuronal selectivities. For the pattern to reorganize while the physical tissue expands, individual neurons must change their eye preference over time, implying that the cortex remains functionally plastic specifically to accommodate physical growth.
Conclusion
Column width in the visual cortex is preserved during expansion through a systematic reorganization of neuronal selectivities. This process is well-described by the zigzag instability, a universal dynamical mechanism. These findings suggest that cortical circuits remain plastic for an extended period to facilitate modifications that adjust for physical growth, ensuring that functional geometry is maintained even as the underlying substrate expands.
Summary updated