Removing False Targets for Cyclic Prefixed OFDM Sensing with Extended Ranging

Kai Wu, J. Andrew Zhang, Xiaojing Huang, Y. Jay GuoSensors 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the "false target" problem in Integrated Sensing and Communications (ISAC) systems that use OFDM communication signals for sensing. The authors identify that these false targets stem from the cyclic prefixes (CPs) inherent in CP-OFDM waveforms and propose two novel methods to effectively remove them, significantly reducing false alarm rates by over 50% compared to existing approaches.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern wireless systems are increasingly aiming to combine communication and sensing functionalities into a single platform, known as Integrated Sensing and Communications (ISAC). A promising approach is Communications-Enabled Sensing (CES), where existing communication waveforms are repurposed for sensing. Orthogonal Frequency-Division Multiplexing (OFDM) is a popular choice for this. While a Unified Sensing Framework (USF) has been developed to extend the sensing capabilities of OFDM beyond traditional limits, it suffers from a critical issue: the appearance of "false targets" in the sensing results. These false targets are spurious detections that appear at incorrect locations, hindering accurate sensing. This paper aims to thoroughly investigate the root cause of these false targets and develop effective solutions to eliminate them without compromising the detection of true targets.

Methods

The paper introduces two primary methods for addressing the false target issue:

  1. Modified Unified Sensing Framework (MUSF) - Preventing False Targets: This approach modifies the USF by proactively preventing false targets from being generated. It achieves this by identifying and nullifying the parts of the communication signal that are responsible for creating false targets. Specifically, it targets the cyclic prefixes (CPs) and the trailing samples of OFDM symbols that are used to generate CPs. This is done by creating an indicator matrix that zeros out these specific signal components before they are processed by the USF.
  2. Sequential Target Detection and Removal - Removing False Targets: This method takes a different approach by allowing false targets to appear in the initial sensing output (Range-Doppler Map or RDM) and then systematically removing them. It leverages the key insight that false targets have predictable locations relative to true targets and known strength relationships. The algorithm first identifies the strongest peak (assumed to be a true target), then estimates the locations and strengths of its associated false targets based on the paper's theoretical analysis. It then reconstructs an RDM of this detected target and its false counterparts and subtracts it from the overall RDM. This process is repeated sequentially to remove all detected targets and their associated false targets.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on simulated data generated according to the described signal model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CPs are the Culprits: The paper definitively identifies the periodic cyclic prefixes (CPs) within CP-OFDM waveforms as the primary cause of false targets in the USF. This is a crucial theoretical breakthrough.
  • Predictable False Target Locations: False targets are not random; they appear at specific, predictable range bins relative to the true target's location. This predictability is key to their removal.
  • Strength Relationship: The paper derives a relationship between the strength of true targets and their associated false targets, which is essential for the removal method.
  • Trade-offs in Removal: The paper highlights a trade-off: preventing false targets (MUSF) can slightly reduce the signal processing gain for true targets, potentially lowering their detection probability. Removing them sequentially (Algorithm 4) preserves the true target's signal strength but requires more computational steps.

Key Results

  • Significant False Alarm Rate Reduction: The proposed methods, particularly Algorithm 4, can reduce the false alarm rate by over 50% compared to the prior art (USF).
  • Effective False Target Removal: Both proposed algorithms successfully remove false targets, as demonstrated by simulations. MUSF (Algorithm 3) eliminates them entirely, while Sequential Target Detection and Removal (Algorithm 4) effectively reconstructs and removes them.
  • Extended Ranging Capability: The underlying USF framework, which these methods build upon, maintains extended ranging capabilities beyond the CP length, a significant advantage over classical OFDM sensing (COS).
  • High Detection Probability: Algorithm 4, by focusing on peak detection and removal without explicit thresholding, achieves the maximum detecting probability, especially at higher SNRs.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumption of Known Target Count (Algorithm 4): For illustration, Algorithm 4 assumes the number of targets is known. In practice, a threshold detection mechanism (like CA-CFAR) would be needed to determine the number of targets.
  • Reduced Processing Gain (MUSF): The MUSF method, by nullifying CPs, can slightly reduce the processing gain for true targets, potentially impacting their detection probability at lower SNRs.
  • Future Work: The paper mentions that ISAC employing more advanced OFDM systems (e.g., DHT-OFDM, NOMA-TDS-OFDM, IM-OFDM-SS) could be an interesting future research direction. Further exploration of the computational complexity and practical implementation challenges of these methods would also be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

Employing a cyclic prefixed OFDM (CP-OFDM) communication waveform for sensing has attracted extensive attention in vehicular integrated sensing and communications (ISAC). A unified sensing framework was developed recently, enabling CP-OFDM sensing to surpass the conventional limits imposed by underlying communications. However, a false target issue still remains unsolved. In this paper, we investigate and solve this issue. Specifically, we unveil that false targets are caused by periodic cyclic prefixes (CPs) in CP-OFDM waveforms. We also derive the relation between the locations of false and true targets, and other features, e.g., strength, of false targets. Moreover, we develop an effective solution to remove false targets. Simulations are provided to confirm the validity of our analysis and the effectiveness of the proposed solution. In particular, our design can reduce the false alarm rate caused by false targets by over 50% compared with the prior art.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2022removing,
  author = {Kai Wu and J. Andrew Zhang and Xiaojing Huang and Y. Jay Guo},
  title = {{Removing False Targets for Cyclic Prefixed OFDM Sensing with Extended Ranging}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/s22229015},
}

Loading related content...

Figure