Removing Biological Trends from Tree-Ring Series: Testing Modified Hugershoff Curves

Keyan Fang, Xiaohua Gou, Kenneth E. Peters, Jinbao Li, Zhang FenTree-Ring 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the "start-fitting problem" in tree-ring analysis, where standard methods struggle to accurately capture early growth trends. The authors introduce biologically meaningful parameters for the Hugershoff curve and propose modified versions to better fit tree-ring data, especially at the beginning of the series. This work offers improved tools for accurately removing biological growth trends, leading to more reliable climate reconstructions from tree rings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Tree rings are invaluable archives for reconstructing past climate. However, to isolate climate signals, researchers must first remove the "biological trend" – the natural pattern of growth that changes with a tree's age. This trend is typically characterized by rapid early growth, followed by a slowing down as the tree matures. Traditional methods for removing this trend, particularly deterministic curves like the Hugershoff curve, often struggle with the very beginning of a tree-ring series (the "pith" or innermost rings). This "start-fitting problem" can lead to biased estimations of the biological trend, potentially affecting the accuracy of subsequent climate reconstructions. The paper aims to address this by developing more robust methods for fitting the early growth phase.

Methods

The core of this paper lies in refining the Hugershoff curve, a deterministic model used to represent tree growth. The authors first identify three key parameters within the Hugershoff curve that have direct biological interpretations:

  • Maximum Growth (MG): The year when the tree's growth rate is at its peak.
  • Maximum Slope (MS): The year when the growth trend is steepest (either increasing or decreasing), potentially reflecting periods of strong environmental influence.
  • Maximum Changing Ratio of Slopes (MRS): The year when the rate of change in the growth slope is most pronounced, indicating a significant shift in growth dynamics.

These parameters are derived by calculating the first, second, and third derivatives of the Hugershoff function. Based on these biologically meaningful parameters, the researchers then propose three modified Hugershoff curves. These modified curves are designed to be initiated at different points (MG, MS, or MRS) to better accommodate variations in the early growth patterns of different tree-ring series. The performance of these modified curves is then tested against the original Hugershoff curve using real tree-ring data.

Datasets

The primary dataset used for evaluation is a tree-ring width series named "Dulan29b," collected from a long-lived Sabina przewalskii tree in the Qinghai province of China. This dataset was chosen because it exhibits a clear Hugershoff growth pattern. The authors also utilized a population of other tree-ring series from the same sampling site to further test the robustness of their modified curves.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Biological Meaning in Parameters: Assigning biological meaning to the parameters of the Hugershoff curve (MG, MS, MRS) provides a more intuitive understanding of tree growth dynamics and allows for targeted modifications.
  • The "Start-Fitting Problem" is Real: The study clearly demonstrates that the innermost rings of a tree-ring series can significantly bias the fit of standard deterministic curves, leading to inaccurate representations of the biological trend.
  • Modified Curves Offer Improved Fits: The proposed modified Hugershoff curves, by adjusting their starting points based on biological parameters, show improved performance in capturing the early growth trends compared to the original curve.
  • "End-Fitting Problem" Also Noted: While the focus is on the start-fitting problem, the paper also briefly discusses an "end-fitting problem," where disturbances at the end of a series can bias the overall fit, suggesting that series length and disturbances can impact curve fitting.

Key Results

  • The study successfully derived biologically meaningful parameters (MG, MS, MRS) for the Hugershoff curve.
  • When testing modified Hugershoff curves on the Dulan29b series, the modified curves showed shapes that more closely resembled the original, unmodified series, particularly in the early portions.
  • Ratios calculated using the modified Hugershoff curves better matched the ratios from the unmodified series, indicating improved standardization.
  • Statistical measures (like F-values) generally improved with the modified curves, suggesting a better overall fit.
  • Testing on a population of tree-ring series also indicated that the modified Hugershoff curves provided better curve-fits, especially in reducing the peak at the beginning of the series.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Scope of "End-Fitting": While the "end-fitting problem" is mentioned, the paper's primary focus and detailed analysis are on the "start-fitting problem." Further investigation into robust solutions for end-fitting could be beneficial.
  • Visual Inspection Recommended: The authors suggest visually plotting the tree-ring data to empirically select the most appropriate modified Hugershoff function, implying that automated selection might still require refinement.
  • Need for More Testing: The authors acknowledge that the effectiveness of these new functions requires further testing across a wider range of tree-ring datasets and growth patterns.
  • Exploration of Adaptive Deterministic Curves: The paper briefly touches upon the idea of combining deterministic and flexible approaches (like Friedman smoother) for different time spans, suggesting this as an area for future exploration.

Summary updated

Abstract

The performance of the Hugershoff curve on fitting the growth trends of tree-ring series was tested using ring-width series with different starting years. The fitted values tend to be biased by tree-ring series close to pith, a phenomenon that was referred to as the “start-fitting problem”. We determined three parameters with specific biological age-related meanings for the Hugershoff growth curve, i.e. the maximum growth, the maximum slope and the maximum changing ratio of slopes. A set of modified Hugershoff curves with different starting years was proposed to mitigate the start-fitting problem. Behavior of the modified Hugershoff curves on tree-ring series standardizations was tested and discussed. The “end-fitting problem” suggests that deviations in one interval could bias the fitted values of other time periods by using the Hugershoff curve.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fang2010removing,
  author = {Keyan Fang and Xiaohua Gou and Kenneth E. Peters and Jinbao Li and Zhang Fen},
  title = {{Removing Biological Trends from Tree-Ring Series: Testing Modified Hugershoff Curves}},
  booktitle = {Tree-Ring},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.3959/2008-18.1},
}
Figure