Remote Sensing of Seawater Temperature and Salinity Profiles by the Brillouin Lidar Based on a Fizeau Interferometer and Multichannel Photomultiplier Tube

Yuanqing Wang, Yangrui Xu, Ping Chen, Kun Liang2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel Brillouin lidar system using a Fizeau interferometer and a multichannel photomultiplier tube (PMT) to remotely measure seawater temperature and salinity profiles. This new approach overcomes limitations of previous methods, achieving high accuracy (0.5°C and 1% salinity) and an effective detection depth exceeding 40.51 meters, making it a promising tool for oceanographic research.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate measurement of ocean temperature and salinity is crucial for understanding ocean dynamics, climate regulation, and maritime activities. While lidar technology offers an active remote sensing solution, existing Brillouin lidar systems face challenges with real-time spectral measurement, spectral integrity, continuity, and stability. Traditional methods using scanning Fabry-Perot interferometers are too slow for practical lidar applications, while edge-based methods offer limited spectral information and flexibility. Even more recent dual-edge etalon methods, while faster, are highly sensitive to environmental fluctuations, impacting accuracy. This paper aims to address these limitations by developing a more robust and accurate Brillouin lidar system for profiling ocean temperature and salinity.

Methods

The core innovation of this work lies in the development of a new Brillouin lidar system that combines a Fizeau interferometer with a multichannel photomultiplier tube (PMT).

  • Fizeau Interferometer: This component is used for spectral separation. It generates interference fringes from the backscattered light, where each fringe represents a spatial expansion of the complete Rayleigh-Brillouin (RB) scattering spectrum. The Fizeau interferometer's free spectral range (FSR) was set to 25 GHz to accommodate the typical RB scattering spectrum of seawater (around 20 GHz), and its finesse was optimized to 90% reflectivity for a balance between spectral resolution and light transmission.
  • Multichannel Photomultiplier Tube (PMT): The interference fringes from the Fizeau interferometer are then compressed and detected by a multichannel PMT. This device quantifies the continuous RB scattering spectrum into discrete sparse energy points. The number of channels in the PMT was analyzed, with 16 channels being selected as a compromise between spectral accuracy and system complexity/cost.
  • Spectral Reconstruction: A software algorithm is used to reconstruct the continuous RB scattering spectrum from the discrete data acquired by the PMT. This reconstructed spectrum allows for the extraction of the Brillouin frequency shift and linewidth.
  • Temperature and Salinity Retrieval: The extracted Brillouin shift and linewidth are then fed into a dual-parameter inversion model to calculate the seawater temperature and salinity.

The system also includes a light emission part (pulsed laser) and a reference beam (PMT0) to monitor laser energy fluctuations, contributing to the overall stability and accuracy.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention the use of pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, the authors conducted experimental measurements and simulations to evaluate their proposed system. The experimental data was collected using their developed Brillouin energy measurement system. Simulations were performed to analyze the impact of various parameters, such as PMT channel numbers and SNR, on measurement accuracy and detection depth.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fizeau Interferometer for Spectral Integrity: Using a Fizeau interferometer allows for the acquisition of the complete Rayleigh-Brillouin spectrum, unlike edge-based methods that only capture a single spectral parameter. This provides richer spectral information for more comprehensive analysis.
  • Multichannel PMT for Real-time Measurement: The multichannel PMT offers a faster response time compared to ICCDs used in some previous systems, enabling more rapid spectral acquisition and thus better suitability for lidar applications requiring real-time profiling.
  • Improved Anti-interference Capability: By measuring both Rayleigh and Brillouin spectra, the system gains a stable reference point. This approach makes the spectral measurement more robust against system instabilities like jitter, enhancing its anti-interference ability.
  • Trade-offs in System Design: The paper highlights critical design trade-offs, such as the number of PMT channels (accuracy vs. complexity) and Fizeau interferometer finesse (resolution vs. light throughput), demonstrating a practical engineering approach.
  • Experimental Validation of Theoretical Potential: While theoretical calculations suggest high detection depths, the experimental results show a slightly lower but still significant performance, underscoring the importance of accounting for real-world system efficiencies.

Key Results

  • Temperature Measurement Accuracy: Achieved 0.5 °C.
  • Salinity Measurement Accuracy: Achieved 1‰.
  • Effective Detection Depth: Exceeded 40.51 meters under specific conditions (attenuation coefficient α = 0.2, accumulation time of 10 s, and required accuracies).
  • Anti-jamming Capability: Simulations showed Brillouin shift error less than 2 MHz and linewidth error mostly less than 3 MHz when the spectrum was shifted by up to 0.762 GHz (equivalent to 1 mm spectral drift).
  • Experimental Detection Depth: In an experimental setup with an attenuation coefficient of 0.099, the maximum measurement depth was found to be 13.68 m.
  • Theoretical Maximum Detection Depth (Analogy): Based on experimental results and system parameters, the theoretical maximum detection depth was estimated to be 42.90 m.
  • SNR Requirement: An SNR greater than 35 was found to be necessary for achieving the target temperature and salinity accuracies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Fabrication Precision: The multibeam interference principle of the Fizeau interferometer requires precise fabrication to ensure spectral integrity and accuracy.
  • PMT Channel Consistency: The response performance of individual channels in the multichannel PMT may not be perfectly consistent, necessitating nonuniform correction for accurate applications.
  • Actual System Efficiency: The experimental system's efficiency is lower than theoretical models due to factors like optical lens attenuation and detector efficiency, leading to a lower achieved detection depth compared to theoretical predictions.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest building a physical setup for verification and analysis to further promote the application of this Brillouin lidar in oceanographic studies. They also imply that further optimization of system efficiency could lead to even greater detection depths.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{wang2023remote,
  author = {Yuanqing Wang and Yangrui Xu and Ping Chen and Kun Liang},
  title = {{Remote Sensing of Seawater Temperature and Salinity Profiles by the Brillouin Lidar Based on a Fizeau Interferometer and Multichannel Photomultiplier Tube}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/s23010446},
}
Figure