Remote Renewable Hubs For Carbon-Neutral Synthetic Fuel Production

Mathias Berger, David Radu, Ghislain Detienne, Thierry Deschuyteneer, Aurore Richel, Damien ErnstarXiv 2021 · arXiv

Abstract

Decarbonizing heavy industry and long-haul transport requires high-energy-density carbon-neutral fuels. This paper evaluates the techno-economic feasibility of producing synthetic methane in resource-rich regions like North Africa for export to European markets. Using a novel graph-based optimization framework (GBOML) with hourly resolution over a five-year horizon, the study identifies key cost drivers—including financing costs and renewable variability—and estimates a 2030 delivery cost of approximately 150 €/MWh.

Introduction

As the global transition toward net-zero emissions accelerates, "hard-to-electrify" sectors such as aviation, shipping, and heavy industry remain a significant challenge. While direct electrification is the preferred path for many applications, these sectors require fuels with high energy density. Many industrial regions, particularly in Europe, lack the land area and renewable potential to produce these fuels locally at the required scale.

"Remote Renewable Hubs" offer a solution: leveraging the vast solar and wind resources of regions like North Africa or Patagonia to produce synthetic fuels. However, the economic viability of these global supply chains depends on complex interactions between intermittent energy sources, storage requirements, and chemical conversion processes.

Methodology: Graph-Based Optimization

To capture these complexities, the authors developed a graph-based optimization modeling framework. This approach abstracts the supply chain into a network of nodes and hyperedges.

Graph-based optimization framework illustrating nodes as subsystems and edges as connectivity constraints.

In this framework:

  • Nodes represent individual subsystems, such as wind farms, electrolysis plants, or CO2 storage tanks. Each node contains its own local variables, constraints, and objectives.
  • Hyperedges define the connectivity and flow conservation (mass and energy balances) between these subsystems.

This structure is implemented in GBOML (Graph-Based Optimization Modelling Language). Unlike traditional strategic models that rely on "representative days," this model utilizes a full hourly resolution over a five-year period (2015–2019). This high temporal resolution is critical for capturing long-term seasonal variations and short-term weather shocks that impact the sizing and operation of storage and conversion facilities.

Techno-Economic Analysis and Data

The study models a 2030 scenario for a supply chain originating in Algeria and ending in North-Western Europe. It integrates high-quality datasets, including:

  • ERA5 Weather Data: Hourly irradiance and wind speed data from the ECMWF.
  • 2030 Projections: CAPEX, OPEX, and efficiency metrics for PEM electrolysis, Sabatier methanation, Direct Air Capture (DAC), and LNG shipping, sourced from the IEA and Danish Energy Agency.

The problem is formulated as a large-scale Linear Program (LP), ensuring computational efficiency while maintaining the granularity needed for reliable cost estimation.

Key Insights: Drivers of Synthetic Fuel Costs

The analysis reveals several critical factors that determine the final cost of synthetic methane:

The Impact of Financing

The Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) is perhaps the most significant non-technical driver. At a standard 7% WACC, the delivered cost is ~150 €/MWh. If financing costs were eliminated (0% WACC), the cost would drop to ~88 €/MWh, highlighting the importance of de-risking these massive capital investments.

The Synergy of Wind and Solar

While North Africa is often associated with solar power, wind energy is the "Most Valuable Player" in this system. Wind's higher capacity factor allows downstream chemical plants (electrolyzers and methanators) to operate more consistently. A hybrid wind-solar configuration is significantly more cost-effective (~150 €/MWh) than a solar-only setup (~202 €/MWh), as it reduces the need for expensive hydrogen storage.

Economic Curtailment and Flexibility

Interestingly, the model suggests that "throwing away" approximately 25% of potential renewable energy is the most economical choice. Oversizing renewable capacity to meet demand during average periods is cheaper than building enough storage to capture every peak. Furthermore, increasing the operational flexibility of methanation and DAC plants could reduce total system costs by an additional 6%.

Results and Conclusion

The study estimates that carbon-neutral synthetic methane can be delivered to Europe for 149.7 €/MWh (HHV) by 2030, with a "well-to-tank" energy efficiency of 43.9%. Wind turbines represent the largest cost component (28.9%), followed by electrolysis (19.6%).

While the model assumes perfect foresight and linear efficiencies, it provides a robust baseline for future energy strategy. Future research will expand this framework to include non-linear plant behavior, weather uncertainty, and alternative energy carriers like ammonia or liquid hydrogen.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{berger2021remote,
  author = {Mathias Berger and David Radu and Ghislain Detienne and Thierry Deschuyteneer and Aurore Richel and Damien Ernst},
  title = {{Remote Renewable Hubs For Carbon-Neutral Synthetic Fuel Production}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2102.11375},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2102.11375},
}
Figure