Remote C–H bond cooperation strategy enabled silver catalyzed borrowing hydrogen reactions

Zhe Chen, Laofeng Ouyang, Ning Wang, Weikang Li, Zhuofeng KeChemical 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "remote C-H bond cooperation" strategy to enable silver (Ag(I)) to catalyze borrowing hydrogen/hydrogen auto-transfer (BH/HA) reactions, overcoming limitations of traditional metal-ligand cooperation (MLC) for low-coordination metals. This approach utilizes a specific N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC) ligand that, through its dissociative arm, remotely assists in the catalytic cycle, paving the way for more efficient and versatile catalysis with coinage metals.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Transition metal catalysis often relies on "metal-ligand cooperation" (MLC) to achieve efficient chemical transformations. In the context of borrowing hydrogen/hydrogen auto-transfer (BH/HA) reactions, which are atom-economical processes for synthesizing valuable compounds from alcohols and amines, MLC plays a crucial role. Traditional MLC strategies typically involve functional groups directly attached to the ligand that cooperate with the metal center. However, these approaches face significant challenges when applied to low-coordination and less reactive metal ions like Ag(I), which are part of the coinage metal group. These challenges include:

  • Instability: The metal center can become unstable during protonation/deprotonation events on the ligand's functional site.
  • Linear Coordination: Ag(I) ions prefer linear coordination, limiting the spatial arrangement for traditional MLC.
  • Poisoning: Extra functional sites on the ligand can sometimes interfere with or poison the active metal center.

This paper aims to overcome these limitations by developing a new MLC strategy that is compatible with the unique characteristics of Ag(I) and other low-coordination d¹⁰ metals, thereby expanding their catalytic utility.

Methods

The researchers developed a novel "remote C-H bond cooperation" strategy. Key aspects of their methodology include:

  • Ligand Design: They synthesized and employed a specific bis-N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC) ligand. This ligand is designed such that one of its arms can act as a "remote" functional site.
  • Catalyst Synthesis: They synthesized silver complexes featuring this bis-NHC ligand.
  • BH/HA Reaction Testing: The catalytic system was tested for N-alkylation reactions using benzyl alcohol and aniline as model substrates, a common BH/HA transformation.
  • Mechanistic Studies:
    • Theoretical Calculations (DFT): Density Functional Theory was used to investigate the reaction mechanism, including transition states, energy barriers, and the role of the ligand's C-H bond. They calculated hydride dissociation energies (HDE) and orbital energies of the Ag-H bond to understand ligand effects.
  • Spectroscopic Analysis: ¹H NMR was used to probe the interaction of the ligand's functional moiety.
  • Substrate Scope Exploration: The optimized catalytic system was tested with a variety of anilines and alcohols to assess its versatility.
  • Gram-Scale Reaction: A larger scale reaction was performed to demonstrate the practical applicability of the method.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Remote C-H Bond Cooperation: The core innovation is using a C-H bond on a dissociative arm of the NHC ligand, positioned remotely from the silver center, to assist in catalysis. This bypasses the direct interaction issues faced by traditional MLC.
  • Ag(I) Catalysis Enabled: This strategy successfully activates Ag(I) for BH/HA reactions, a feat that has been challenging for coinage metals due to their low coordination and reactivity.
  • Ligand Electronic Effects: The electron-donating nature of the bis-NHC ligand is crucial for stabilizing the silver-hydride species and enhancing its reactivity.
  • Outer-Sphere Mechanism: The remote C-H bond assistance facilitates an outer-sphere mechanism, where the C-H bond forms a hydrogen bond with the alcohol substrate, lowering the activation barrier for dehydrogenation.
  • Overcoming Linear Coordination: The remote cooperation strategy circumvents the limitations imposed by the linear coordination preferences of Ag(I).
  • Avoiding Poisoning: By covalently attaching the functional C-H bond to the ligand, the risk of poisoning the active silver center is significantly reduced compared to using free functional groups.

Key Results

  • Unprecedented BH/HA for Ag(I): The developed NHC-Ag catalyst achieved unprecedented homogeneous BH/HA reactions for Ag(I).
  • High Yields: The N-alkylation of aniline with benzyl alcohol was achieved in an excellent isolated yield of 95% under optimized conditions.
  • Broad Substrate Scope: The catalytic system demonstrated good to excellent yields (60-98%) for a wide range of anilines and alcohols, including those with electron-donating and electron-withdrawing substituents.
  • Gram-Scale Synthesis: A gram-scale reaction successfully produced the target N-benzyl aniline in 73% yield.
  • Synthetic Application: The method was used to efficiently synthesize an aminopyridine derivative, which can be further converted into a thonzonium bromide with antifungal activity.
  • Mechanistic Validation: DFT calculations confirmed that the remote C-H bond of the NHC ligand plays a critical role in facilitating the dehydrogenation step through hydrogen bonding, with a significantly lower activation barrier (0.0 kcal mol⁻¹) compared to systems lacking this interaction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Substrate Limitations: While the scope is broad, the paper notes that substrates with electron-withdrawing groups in para and ortho positions of the aniline, and halo-substituents, showed reduced reactivity or required harsher conditions. Dehalogenation was also observed.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that this strategy has the potential to be applied to other low-coordination d¹⁰ coinage metals, broadening the scope of MLC catalysis. Further exploration of different remote C-H bond functionalities and their electronic properties could lead to even more efficient and selective catalytic systems. The paper also hints at the importance of the "acidic nature" of the C-H bond in the remote cooperation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Metal-ligand cooperation (MLC) is an essential strategy in transition metal catalysis. Traditional NH-based and OH-based MLC catalysts, as well as the later developed (de)aromatization strategy, have been widely applied in atom-economic borrowing hydrogen/hydrogen auto-transfer (BH/HA) reactions. However, these conventional MLC approaches are challenging for low-coordination and low-activity coinage metal complexes, arising from the instability during (de)protonation on the coordination atom, the constraint in linear coordination, and possible poisoning due to extra functional sites. Herein, we demonstrate a remote C-H bond cooperation strategy that enables the unprecedented homogeneous Ag(i)-catalyzed BH/HA reaction. The covalent C-H bifunctional site well facilitates (de)hydrogenation, especially under the low coordination circumstances of d<sup>10</sup> Ag(i). The strong electron-donating bis-<i>N</i>-heterocyclic carbene (NHC) ligand stabilizes the silver-hydride and stimulates the hydride activity on the <i>trans</i>-position of ligands. Mechanistic studies implicate the plausible remote assistance of the dissociative NHC arm in facilitating BH/HA reactions. Our findings emphasize the potential of the remote C-H bond cooperation strategy for low coordination metals in catalyzing BH/HA reactions and broadening MLC catalysts to d<sup>10</sup> coinage metals.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2024remote,
  author = {Zhe Chen and Laofeng Ouyang and Ning Wang and Weikang Li and Zhuofeng Ke},
  title = {{Remote C–H bond cooperation strategy enabled silver catalyzed borrowing hydrogen reactions}},
  booktitle = {Chemical},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1039/d4sc05486e},
}
Figure