Remarks on replica diagonal collective field condensations in SYK

Sergio Caracciolo, Matteo A. Cardella, Mauro PastorearXiv 2018 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper investigates a phase transition in the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model, a quantum system with surprising connections to black holes. The authors calculate the critical temperature at which a collective field, crucial for describing the SYK model's low-energy behavior, condenses. This work provides a deeper understanding of the SYK model's complex phase structure and its holographic duals.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model, a disordered quantum mechanical system of Majorana fermions, has garnered significant attention due to its exact solvability in the large $N$ limit and its intriguing connections to quantum gravity and black hole physics. At high temperatures, the SYK model is expected to be in a "perturbative vacuum." However, at lower temperatures, it exhibits a rich phase structure characterized by the condensation of collective fields, leading to a breakdown of conformal symmetry.

A key question is understanding the nature of these low-temperature phases and the transitions between them. Specifically, this paper focuses on the condensation of the "replica diagonal collective field," denoted as $G(\tau, \tau')$. This condensation signifies a transition from the high-temperature perturbative vacuum to a new vacuum state. The authors aim to precisely determine the critical temperature ($T_c$) at which this condensation occurs, providing a quantitative measure of this phase transition. They also explore the implications for the model's behavior at different interaction strengths ($q$) and touch upon the possibility of spin glass phases.

Methods

The authors employ a combination of theoretical techniques to tackle this problem:

  • Functional Integral Representation: They start by reformulating the SYK model's thermal partition function using a functional integral approach. This allows for a more convenient analysis of the system's properties, especially in the large $N$ limit.
  • Hubbard-Stratonovich Transformation: A crucial step involves introducing an auxiliary Hubbard-Stratonovich (HS) field. This transformation is used to decouple the quartic interaction terms in the SYK Hamiltonian, simplifying the analysis by relating the collective field $G(\tau, \tau')$ to this auxiliary field.
  • Replica Trick: To handle the disorder averaging, the authors utilize the replica trick, considering $m$ identical copies of the system. This allows them to average over the random couplings and obtain a disorder-averaged partition function.
  • Diagrammatic Analysis (Perturbative in $1/N$): The core of the calculation involves a finite-temperature diagrammatic analysis in the large $N$ limit. They compute self-energy corrections to the auxiliary HS field. The leading order contributions in $1/N$ are identified, as higher-order diagrams are suppressed.
  • Matsubara Frequencies: The analysis is performed in the frequency domain using Matsubara frequencies, which are standard for finite-temperature quantum field theory calculations.
  • Focus on Static Mode: For the condensation analysis, the authors focus on the static mode (zero frequency) of the auxiliary field, as this mode is primarily responsible for driving the condensation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This paper is a theoretical investigation and does not rely on experimental datasets or numerical simulations of specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Quantifying the Condensation Temperature: The paper provides a concrete calculation of the critical temperature ($T_c$) for the condensation of the replica diagonal collective field $G(\tau, \tau')$. This is a significant step towards mapping out the SYK model's phase diagram.
  • Role of the Auxiliary Field: The Hubbard-Stratonovich transformation effectively reveals the importance of the auxiliary field as a proxy for the collective field, allowing for a perturbative analysis of its mass.
  • Suppression of Off-Diagonal Interactions: The analysis highlights that replica off-diagonal interactions (between different replicas) are suppressed in the large $N$ limit compared to replica diagonal interactions. This justifies focusing on the diagonal components for the condensation analysis.
  • Generalization to Higher $q$: The method developed for $q=4$ is successfully generalized to arbitrary even $q \ge 4$, showing a consistent framework for studying the SYK model with varying interaction strengths.
  • Connection to Spin Glasses: The paper touches upon the potential connection between the condensation of off-diagonal collective fields and spin glass phases, suggesting avenues for future research.

Key Results

  • Critical Temperature for $q=4$: For the SYK model with $q=4$ interactions, the critical temperature for the condensation of the replica diagonal collective field is found to be $T_c \approx 0.072 J$, where $J$ is a characteristic energy scale of the model.
  • Critical Temperature for Generic Even $q \ge 4$: The critical temperature for generic even $q \ge 4$ is found to be $T_c \sim J / q^{1/q}$, which scales with the interaction strength $q$.
  • Leading Order Self-Energy: The paper derives the leading order $1/N$ contribution to the self-energy of the static auxiliary field, which is crucial for determining when its squared mass becomes negative, signaling condensation.
  • Suppression of Off-Diagonal Condensation: The analysis suggests that the condensation of replica off-diagonal components of the collective field is suppressed by a factor of $1/N$, making it less likely to occur at the same critical temperature as the diagonal condensation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Validity of Perturbative Approach: The authors acknowledge that their calculation of off-diagonal condensation is performed in the perturbative Majorana fermion vacuum. They suggest that a more accurate analysis would require performing this calculation in the vacuum where the diagonal $G_{aa}(\tau, \tau')$ has already condensed.
  • Spin Glass Phase: While the paper discusses the possibility of spin glass phases, a definitive conclusion about their existence and the conditions under which they arise is left for future work. The analysis of off-diagonal condensation is a necessary step towards understanding this.
  • Deep Infrared Limit: The paper mentions that studies in the deep infrared limit have shown instabilities for static off-diagonal $G_{ab}$ for $a \neq b$, but these results lie outside the regime of validity of the perturbative calculation.
  • Subtleties in Functional Integral Representation: Appendix A discusses subtleties in switching between operatorial and functional integral representations of the SYK thermal partition function, indicating that careful handling of normal ordering is required.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model with generic order $q \ge 4$ random couplings, we compute the critical temperature relating the Majorana fermions high temperature perturbative vacuum to the vacuum where the replica diagonal collective field $G(τ, τ')$ condenses. We study, by a finite temperature diagrammatic analysis, the effective action of an auxiliary Hubbard-Stratonovich bilocal field related to $G(τ, τ')$ in the large $N$ limit. Subtelties that arise in switching from the operatorial to the functional integral representation of the SYK thermal partition function are also discussed.
BibTeX
@misc{caracciolo2018remarks,
  author = {Sergio Caracciolo and Matteo A. Cardella and Mauro Pastore},
  title = {{Remarks on replica diagonal collective field condensations in SYK}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1807.10213},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1807.10213},
}
Figure