Relic gravitational waves and their detection

Wen Zhao, Yang ZhangPhysical 2006 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the detection of relic gravitational waves (RGW), a potential remnant of the early universe's inflationary period. By employing both analytical and numerical methods, the authors provide updated constraints on RGW strength and assess the capabilities of future experiments, concluding that CMB and laser interferometer experiments are complementary in their detection potential.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The early universe is thought to have undergone a period of rapid expansion called inflation. A key prediction of inflationary models is the generation of relic gravitational waves (RGW), which are ripples in spacetime that have been traveling since the universe's infancy. Detecting these RGW would provide strong evidence for inflation and offer insights into its fundamental physics. However, RGW are incredibly weak and have not yet been directly detected. This paper addresses the challenge of constraining the possible strength of RGW and evaluating how effectively current and future experiments can detect them, given the uncertainties in inflationary models.

Methods

The authors utilize two primary methods to calculate the strength of RGW, denoted as $\Omega_g(k)$:

  • Analytic Method: This approach involves deriving an analytical formula for $\Omega_g(k)$ that incorporates several damping effects: redshift suppression due to cosmic expansion, damping from the accelerating expansion of the present universe, and damping from the free-streaming of neutrinos. This method provides a direct relationship between $\Omega_g(k)$ and inflationary parameters like the scalar spectral index ($n_s$) and the tensor-to-scalar ratio ($r$).
  • Numerical Method: To overcome the limitations of the analytic method at high frequencies and for a broader range of inflationary models, a numerical approach is employed. This involves solving the "inflationary flow equations," which describe the evolution of slow-roll parameters during inflation. This method allows for a more precise calculation of $\Omega_g(k)$ across a wide frequency spectrum and is independent of specific inflationary model parameters.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical calculations and comparisons with existing observational constraints.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Complementarity of Detection Methods: A crucial finding is that experiments designed to detect RGW at different frequency ranges are not in competition but rather are complementary. CMB experiments are best suited for detecting RGW with larger tensor-to-scalar ratios ($r$), while laser interferometers excel at detecting RGW with smaller $r$.
  • Tightening Constraints: The study demonstrates that current constraints on RGW from sources like LIGO, Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN), and pulsar timing are too loose to significantly constrain single-field inflationary models. In contrast, constraints from CMB observations (like WMAP) are more effective.
  • Numerical Method's Power: The numerical approach, by solving the inflationary flow equations, provides a more robust and model-independent upper limit on RGW strength, particularly for high-frequency waves.
  • Damping Effects Matter: The inclusion of various damping effects (redshift suppression, accelerating expansion, neutrino damping) significantly impacts the calculated RGW strength, leading to tighter upper limits than those obtained without considering these factors.

Key Results

  • Analytic Upper Limit: Using current constraints on $n_s$ and $r$, an upper limit of $\Omega_g < 3.89 \times 10^{-16}$ at $\nu = 0.1$ Hz is derived.
  • Numerical Upper Limit: The numerical method yields a more general upper limit of $\Omega_g < 8.62 \times 10^{-14}$, independent of specific inflationary parameters. When current constraints on $n_s$, $a$, and $r$ are applied, this bound tightens to $\Omega_g < 2 \times 10^{-17}$.
  • Experimental Sensitivity:
    • Future laser interferometers like DECIGO are predicted to be highly effective in detecting RGW with smaller $r$ values.
  • CMB experiments (Planck, Clover, CMBPol) are more effective for detecting RGW with larger $r$ values.
  • Advanced LIGO, LISA, and ASTROD are found to have less chance of detecting RGW if single-field inflationary models hold.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Dependence: The analytic method's results are dependent on specific inflationary models, while the numerical method, though more general, is applied to single-field slow-roll inflationary models. The RGW generated from other models of inflation would require separate analysis.
  • Initial Conditions: The numerical calculations rely on randomly chosen initial conditions for Hubble slow-roll parameters. The paper acknowledges that it's unclear which set of initial conditions best reflects the actual inflationary process.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that further analysis of RGW generated from different inflationary models is needed. The complementary nature of CMB and laser interferometer experiments highlights the importance of continued development and operation of both types of detectors for a comprehensive search for RGW.

Summary updated

Abstract

As strong evidence for inflation, relic gravitational waves (RGW) have been extensively studied. Although they have not been detected yet, some constraints have been achieved by observations. Future experiments for RGW detection are mainly of two kinds: CMB experiments and laser interferometers. In this paper, we study these current constraints and the detective abilities of future experiments. We calculate the strength of RGW ${\ensuremath{\Omega}}_{g}(k)$ using two methods: the analytic method and the numerical method, by solving the inflationary flow equations. By the first method, we obtain a bound ${\ensuremath{\Omega}}_{g}&lt;3.89\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}16}$ at $\ensuremath{\nu}=0.1\text{ }\text{ }\mathrm{Hz}$, where we have used the current constraints on the scalar spectral index and the tensor-scalar ratio; furthermore, we have taken into account the redshift-suppression effect, the accelerating expansion effect, and the neutrino damping effect on RGW. But the analytic expression of ${\ensuremath{\Omega}}_{g}(k)$ depends on specific inflationary models and does not apply well for the waves with very high frequencies. The numerical method is more precise for the waves with high frequencies. It gives a bound ${\ensuremath{\Omega}}_{g}&lt;8.62\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}14}$, which is independent of the inflationary parameters, and applies to any single-field slow-roll inflationary model. After considering the current constraints on the inflationary parameters, this bound becomes ${\ensuremath{\Omega}}_{g}&lt;2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}17}$. These two methods give consistent conclusions: the current constraints on RGW from LIGO, big bang nucleosynthesis, and pulsar timing are too loose to give any constraint for the single-field inflationary models, and the constraints from WMAP are relatively tighter. Future laser interferometers are more effective for detecting RGW with the smaller tensor-scalar ratio, but the CMB experiments are more effective for detecting the waves with the larger ratio. These detection methods are complementary to each other for the detection of RGW.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2006relic,
  author = {Wen Zhao and Yang Zhang},
  title = {{Relic gravitational waves and their detection}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.74.043503},
}
Figure