Reliable sweeps

Xinyu Zhang, Young J. Kim, Dinesh ManochaSymposium on Solid and Physical Modeling 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel algorithm for generating accurate, topology-preserving approximations of swept volumes for complex polyhedral models. It addresses the challenge of creating reliable swept volume representations for applications like motion planning and CAD/CAM by guaranteeing both geometric and topological correctness, a feat not achieved by prior methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The "swept volume" (SV) of an object is the region it occupies as it moves along a trajectory. Computing this volume is crucial in fields like robotics (for collision detection and motion planning), computer-aided design (CAD), and computer-aided manufacturing (CAM). The challenge lies in the fact that calculating the exact SV for complex, non-convex polyhedral objects can be computationally prohibitive due to its high combinatorial and algebraic complexity. Existing approximation methods often struggle to provide guarantees on the topological integrity of the resulting SV (e.g., ensuring no spurious holes are created) or the accuracy of its sharp features, which are critical for many applications. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing a practical algorithm that generates swept volume approximations with provable geometric and topological guarantees.

Methods

The core of the proposed algorithm is a topology-preserving, error-bounded approximation technique based on adaptive volumetric grids and front propagation. Here's a breakdown of the key methods:

  • Adaptive Volumetric Grid Generation: Instead of using a uniform grid, the algorithm employs an adaptive subdivision strategy. This means the grid resolution is refined only where necessary, leading to more efficient computation and reduced memory usage.
  • Front Propagation: This technique is used to identify "free cells" within the grid – cells that contain points belonging to the swept volume. It works by initializing a "front" at a known free point and allowing it to propagate through the grid. This propagation is guided by three mechanisms: cell propagation (within a cell), vertex propagation (to neighboring cells), and downward propagation (to children cells during subdivision).
  • Geometric and Topological Tests: To ensure the quality of the approximation, each grid cell is subjected to two crucial tests:
  • Extended Complex Cell Test: This test checks for simple intersections between the surface and the grid cell, aiming to prevent ambiguous configurations.
  • Extended Star-shaped Test: This test ensures that the surface within a cell is "star-shaped," meaning all points in the surface are visible from a specific point within the cell. This is extended to handle open surface primitives (like ruled and developable surfaces) which are common in SV computation.
  • Isosurface Reconstruction: Once the adaptive grid is generated and the necessary signed distance information is computed for grid points, a standard isosurface extraction algorithm (like Marching Cubes or its variants, such as dual contouring) is used to extract the boundary of the swept volume. Dual contouring is specifically mentioned for its ability to preserve sharp features.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it evaluates its algorithm on a set of "benchmarks" that represent common scenarios in geometric and solid modeling, motion planning, and CNC milling. These include:

  • Solid Modeling examples: a sphere under hypotrochoid sweep, a torus under helical sweep, and a torusknot under helical sweep.
  • Robot Motion Planning example: the swept volume of a Puma robot.
  • CNC Milling example: the swept volume of a milling tool.

These benchmarks are used to demonstrate the algorithm's performance and compare it against existing methods.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Adaptive Grids are Key for Efficiency and Accuracy: The paper strongly advocates for adaptive grids over uniform grids. By focusing computational effort only where needed, it achieves significant speedups and memory reductions while maintaining accuracy.
  • Front Propagation as a Smart Navigator: Using front propagation to identify free cells is an elegant way to guide the adaptive meshing process. It ensures that the algorithm explores the relevant parts of the volume without unnecessary computation.
  • Guaranteed Topology is Non-Negotiable: The emphasis on topological guarantees (same genus, no extra holes) is crucial. This is highlighted as a major limitation of previous methods and a key contribution of this work, especially for applications like collision detection where topological errors can lead to missed collisions.
  • Handling Open Surfaces is Essential: Swept volumes often involve open surface primitives. The extension of the star-shaped test to handle these open surfaces is a critical technical innovation.
  • Dual Contouring for Sharp Features: The choice of dual contouring for isosurface extraction is important for preserving sharp geometric features, which are vital for CAD/CAM applications.

Key Results

  • Topology-Preserving Approximation: The algorithm guarantees that the approximated swept volume has the same topology as the exact swept volume.
  • Geometric Guarantees: The algorithm can achieve arbitrarily tight two-sided Hausdorff error bounds, meaning the approximation can be made as close to the exact SV as desired, given sufficient computational resources.
  • Performance Improvements: Compared to prior work (specifically [Kim et al. 2003]), the new algorithm generates 20-70 times fewer grid cells while guaranteeing topology and error bounds.
  • Reduced Memory Footprint: The adaptive grid approach leads to considerably lower memory requirements than uniform grid methods.
  • Practical Applicability: The algorithm is demonstrated on complex benchmarks from various application domains, showcasing its practical utility.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Degenerate Inputs: The algorithm may struggle with degenerate inputs, such as tangential contact between surface primitives or arbitrarily close surface primitives. These situations can lead to an excessive number of subdivisions, potentially impacting accuracy or performance.
  • Conservative Subdivision: The subdivision scheme can sometimes be overly conservative, generating more cells than strictly necessary.
  • Outer Boundary Only: The current algorithm focuses solely on approximating the outer boundary of the swept volume and does not compute internal voids.
  • Future Work:
    • Optimization of Pre-processing: Implementing more sophisticated optimizations for finding surface primitives that intersect with a cell (e.g., using range query data structures) could significantly improve runtime.
  • Application Exploration: Further exploring the use of SV approximations in applications like four-dimensional collision detection and shape modeling.
  • Envelope of Curved Surfaces: Extending the approach to handle envelopes of curved surfaces, which is a more general problem.
  • Practical Algorithms for Arrangement Problems: Developing practical algorithms for a wider class of arrangement problems that arise in geometric applications.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2009reliable,
  author = {Xinyu Zhang and Young J. Kim and Dinesh Manocha},
  title = {{Reliable sweeps}},
  booktitle = {Symposium on Solid and Physical Modeling},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1145/1629255.1629306},
}
Figure