Reliability of Real-Time Kinematic (RTK) Positioning for Low-Cost Drones’ Navigation across Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) Critical Environments

Luca Tavasci, Francesco Nex, Stefano GandolfiSensors 2024 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper investigates the reliability of low-cost Real-Time Kinematic (RTK) GNSS positioning for drones operating in challenging environments with limited satellite visibility and multipath effects. The study reveals that while RTK offers centimeter-level accuracy in ideal conditions, its performance degrades significantly in critical scenarios, and detecting "false fixes" in real-time remains a challenge.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Drones are increasingly used for infrastructure inspection and surveying, often requiring them to fly close to buildings, under bridges, or in tunnels. These scenarios create "critical environments" where Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) signals are obstructed or reflected, leading to degraded positioning accuracy. While high-end geodetic GNSS receivers can handle these conditions, lightweight, low-cost drones typically use more affordable modules. This paper addresses the crucial question of how reliable these low-cost RTK GNSS systems are in such challenging, real-world operational conditions and whether their performance degradation is detectable by the drone's navigation system in real-time.

Methods

The researchers simulated critical environments by mounting a low-cost Ublox F9P RTK GNSS module on a cart. This allowed for controlled, repeatable trajectories that mimicked drone flight paths near tall walls, under tunnels, and in areas with limited sky visibility. They focused on three main aspects:

  1. Maintaining Fix: How well the RTK system retains its centimeter-level "fixed" solution when approaching obstacles.
  2. Re-fixing Time: The time it takes for the system to re-establish a fixed solution after losing it due to signal obstruction.
  3. False Fixes: The occurrence and detectability of "false fixes," where the system incorrectly reports a fixed solution with significant errors.

They used the QGround Control software to log navigation data and analyzed parameters like elevation, precision estimates (VRMS/HRMS), and the number of visible satellites.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data collected from controlled tests simulating specific operational scenarios.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Low-cost RTK is not a magic bullet: While RTK offers high precision, its performance is highly sensitive to environmental conditions.
  • "False fixes" are a major concern: The system can report a "fixed" solution that is actually meters off, posing a significant risk to drone safety. These are particularly problematic when the drone is hovering, as motion is needed to reveal the incoherence of a false fix.
  • Real-time detection of errors is difficult: While precision estimates (VRMS/HRMS) can sometimes indicate a loss of quality, they are not always sufficient to reliably detect false fixes, especially in certain scenarios.
  • Hovering is detrimental to re-fixing: Drones that hover in critical environments after losing their fix take longer to re-establish it, and are more prone to false fixes, compared to drones that maintain motion.
  • Practical recommendations are crucial: The paper provides actionable advice for drone operators to mitigate risks in critical environments.

Key Results

  • Loss of Fix: The RTK system typically lost its fixed solution within 1-5 meters of approaching an obstacle (tall wall or tunnel entrance).
  • Re-fixing Time: Re-acquiring a fixed solution after leaving a signal-denied area generally took between 9-13 seconds, but could extend to over 200 seconds in some cases, particularly when influenced by multipath or partial sky obstruction.
  • False Fixes: False fixes were observed in tests simulating hovering near obstacles (Test-1 and Test-2). These errors could be several meters in magnitude and were not always easily detectable by real-time precision estimates. Test-3, involving continuous motion, showed no significant false fixes.
  • Precision Estimates: VRMS/HRMS values can serve as a proxy for positioning quality. A threshold of 3-5 cm for VRMS is suggested to reject unreliable solutions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Scope: The study used a single type of low-cost GNSS module (Ublox F9P) and a specific cart-based setup. More comprehensive testing with different hardware, baseline setups, and simulated obstacles could provide broader insights.
  • Real-time Detection: The paper acknowledges the difficulty in reliably detecting false fixes in real-time and suggests setting thresholds on precision parameters as a mitigation strategy. Further research into more robust real-time anomaly detection algorithms is warranted.
  • Antenna Effects: While the Helical antenna was chosen for its omnidirectional properties, further investigation into the impact of different antenna types and their placement on drone platforms could be beneficial.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring different baseline setups, a wider range of locations, and potentially using simulated obstacles and GNSS antennas for more comprehensive analysis. They also highlight the need for more precise reference solutions for cart trajectories and a deeper analysis of parameters like DOP, sky-plots, and multipath influence.

Summary updated

Abstract

UAVs are nowadays used for several surveying activities, some of which imply flying close to tall walls, in and out of tunnels, under bridges, and so forth. In these applications, RTK GNSS positioning delivers results with very variable quality. It allows for centimetric-level kinematic navigation in real time in ideal conditions, but limitations in sky visibility or strong multipath effects negatively impact the positioning quality. This paper aims at assessing the RTK positioning limitations for lightweight and low-cost drones carrying cheap GNSS modules when used to fly in some meaningful critical operational conditions. Three demanding scenarios have been set up simulating the trajectories of drones in tasks such as infrastructure (i.e., building or bridges) inspection. Different outage durations, flight dynamics, and obstacle sizes have been considered in this work to have a complete overview of the positioning quality. The performed tests have allowed us to define practical recommendations to safely fly drones in potentially critical environments just by considering common software and standard GNSS parameters.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tavasci2024reliability,
  author = {Luca Tavasci and Francesco Nex and Stefano Gandolfi},
  title = {{Reliability of Real-Time Kinematic (RTK) Positioning for Low-Cost Drones’ Navigation across Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) Critical Environments}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=6zkmBocg4E},
}
Figure