Reliability evaluation by initial model randomization for refraction traveltime tomography

Kazuya Shiraishi, Susumu Abe, Takaya Iwasaki, Hideo Saitô, Hiroshi Sato, Shin Koshiya, Naoko Kato, Ryuta Arai, T. KawanakaBUTSURI-TANSA(Geophysical 2010 · DOI

Abstract

Seismic refraction traveltime tomography is a powerful tool for estimating subsurface physical properties. However, as a non-linear inverse problem, its results are often sensitive to the choice of the initial model and survey geometry. This paper evaluates a Monte Carlo-based uncertainty analysis method that uses initial model randomization to quantify the reliability of tomographic solutions. By performing hundreds of inversions with randomized starting points, we derive statistical maps of mean velocity and standard deviation. Case studies using numerical simulations and field data from the Kitakami Lowland, Japan, demonstrate that this method provides objective reliability metrics, highlighting geological features such as fault zones and structural boundaries.

Introduction

In deep crustal exploration, integrated analysis using seismic reflection data often relies on refraction traveltime tomography to provide a broad velocity structure. A significant challenge in this workflow is the inherent uncertainty of the resulting velocity model. Geologists must distinguish between genuine physical structures and artifacts caused by numerical instability or poor ray coverage. Traditional methods often lack quantitative measures of reliability. This study explores a statistical approach to address these spatial uncertainties through initial model randomization.

Methodology: Initial Model Randomization

The core of the proposed method is a Monte Carlo uncertainty analysis. Instead of a single inversion, the workflow involves generating a large ensemble of potential solutions to assess the stability of the result.

Flowchart of the uncertainty analysis workflow using initial model randomization.

As shown in Figure 1, the process follows these steps:

  1. Randomization: Hundreds of 1D initial velocity models are generated, with velocities at specific depths varied randomly within a plausible range.
  2. Tomographic Inversion: Each initial model undergoes a standard inversion process using the Simultaneous Iterative Reconstruction Technique (SIRT) and Linear Travel-time Interpolation (LTI).
  3. Statistical Synthesis: The results from all inversions are aggregated to calculate the mean velocity and the standard deviation.

This statistical approach allows for the identification of stable features (low standard deviation) versus those highly dependent on the starting model (high standard deviation).

Field Application and Results

The method was applied to a high-density seismic survey line in the Kitakami Lowland, Northeast Japan. The survey targeted the Ide fault zone, utilizing 712 shot points over a 40 km line. For this analysis, 500 randomized initial models were used to ensure statistical convergence.

Average velocity model derived from 500 randomized initial models for the Kitakami Lowland survey.

The resulting average velocity model (Figure 5) reveals a detailed subsurface structure. Key findings include:

  • Structural Correlation: The estimated velocity distribution aligns well with known geological structures and reflection seismic sections, confirming the validity of the averaged model.
  • Uncertainty as a Diagnostic: High standard deviation values were observed near sharp velocity contrasts and fault zones. This suggests that uncertainty maps can serve as a secondary tool for geological interpretation, pinpointing areas of structural complexity.
  • Convergence: Analysis showed that the statistical results (mean and standard deviation) stabilize after approximately 200 to 300 iterations, providing a balance between computational cost and reliability.

Conclusion

Initial model randomization provides a robust, quantitative framework for evaluating the reliability of seismic tomography. While computationally intensive—requiring significant CPU time—the method is highly parallelizable and offers an objective basis for geological interpretation. These high-reliability models are essential for advanced seismic processing techniques, such as Full-Waveform Inversion (FWI) and pre-stack depth migration, where an accurate starting model is paramount.

Summary updated

Abstract

弾性波トモグラフィ解析は地下の物性値を直接推定できる有効な手法であり,稠密長大展開の反射法地震探査データを用いた深部地殻構造探査における統合解析では,広域の速度構造を推定できる屈折初動走時トモグラフィの重要度が高まっている。一方で,逆問題の解として求まる速度モデルの信頼性に対する定量的な評価が必要となる。初期モデル依存性や観測ジオメトリによる偽像など解の空間的な不確実性について,モンテカルロ確度解析を用いて統計的な評価を行なう方法が提唱されている。本稿では,ある条件下でランダムに生成した数百組の初期モデルに対してトモグラフィ解析を実施し,全ての解から平均の速度分布及び標準偏差分布を求めることで解の信頼度を評価するこの方法について,数値シミュレーション及びフィールドデータを用いたケーススタディを実施しその適用性について検討した。断層帯を横断する稠密長大展開のデータに対して500の初期モデルを用いて本解析を実施し,速度構造及び標準偏差分布による誤差範囲を求めた。地質構造によく対応する速度分布が信頼度の指標とともに得られ,さらに,誤差範囲の分布が速度コントラストの大きな境界や断層近傍など地質構造の変化をも反映していることが明らかとなった。この手法はモデル数に応じて計算コストは増大するものの,200~300程度のランダム化をすることでトモグラフィ解析結果に対する信頼度を示すための有効な手段といえる。さらに,チェッカーボードテストを追加して実施することにより分解能に関してもあわせて評価することができる。初期モデルランダム化を伴うトモグラフィにより得られた速度構造とその他の情報は,フルウェーブトモグラフィの初期モデルや反射法データのマイグレーション処理における速度モデル,統合地質解釈における客観的な根拠など有用な情報となる。
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shiraishi2010reliability,
  author = {Kazuya Shiraishi and Susumu Abe and Takaya Iwasaki and Hideo Saitô and Hiroshi Sato and Shin Koshiya and Naoko Kato and Ryuta Arai and T. Kawanaka},
  title = {{Reliability evaluation by initial model randomization for refraction traveltime tomography}},
  booktitle = {BUTSURI-TANSA(Geophysical},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.3124/segj.63.345},
}
Figure