TL;DR
Researchers have validated two new rapid assessment tools—the Movement Behaviour Questionnaire for babies (MBQ-B) and children (MBQ-C)—designed to measure physical activity, screen time, and sleep in children aged 0–5. These short-form surveys provide a reliable, low-burden alternative to intensive time-use diaries and expensive wearable sensors, making large-scale public health monitoring and intervention evaluation far more feasible.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Public health guidelines now emphasize "24-hour movement behaviours," recognizing that health is a product of the interplay between physical activity, sedentary time (especially screen time), and sleep. However, measuring these in children under five is notoriously difficult.
While wearable accelerometers are the gold standard for movement volume, they cannot distinguish between a child sitting quietly reading a book versus watching a tablet. Conversely, 24-hour time-use diaries (TUDs) are highly detailed but place an immense "respondent burden" on parents, leading to low compliance in large studies. There is a critical gap for "fit-for-purpose" tools that are quick to complete but scientifically robust enough for research and clinical use.
Methods
The authors developed and tested two instruments: the MBQ-B (6 items for infants/toddlers not yet walking) and the MBQ-C (9 items for children who have reached their walking milestone).
A key innovation in this study was testing two response formats:
- Open-ended: Parents report exact hours and minutes.
- Closed-ended: Parents select from pre-defined time categories (e.g., "30 to 60 minutes").
To validate these tools, 300 parent-child dyads participated in a 10-day protocol. The "ground truth" (criterion measures) consisted of:
- ActiGraph GT3X+ accelerometers: Worn for 7 days by children who could walk.
- 24-hour Time Use Diaries (TUDs): Completed by parents on two separate days to capture screen time and sleep.
Reliability was assessed via a test-retest model (completing the survey on Day 7 and again on Day 10), using Intraclass Correlation Coefficients (ICCs). Validity was measured using Spearman correlations against the diaries and accelerometers.
Datasets
The study utilized a primary dataset of 300 parent-child dyads recruited across Australia.
- MBQ-B Group: 85 dyads (infants/toddlers).
- MBQ-C Group: 215 dyads (preschool-aged). The sample was broadly representative of the Australian population across various socio-economic deciles (IRSAD).
Key Insights and Ideas
- Developmental Milestones > Chronological Age: Instead of using age cut-offs, the authors used milestones (rolling and walking) to determine which questionnaire a parent should fill out. This accounts for the wide biological variation in early childhood development.
- The "Screen Time" Nuance: The tools differentiate between interactive screen time (e.g., video chatting, educational games) and non-interactive screen time (e.g., watching TV). This aligns with modern pediatric guidelines that view these behaviors differently.
- Format Flexibility: The study found that both open-ended and closed-ended formats provided comparable information. This gives researchers the flexibility to use open-ended versions for statistical precision in trials, or closed-ended versions for quick "goal setting" in clinical pediatric settings.
- The Proxy-Report Paradox: While the surveys were highly accurate for sleep and screen time, they showed weaker (though still significant) correlations with accelerometer-measured physical activity. This highlights that while parents are good at noticing "events" (like turning on a TV or bedtime), they struggle to quantify the "sporadic and pulsatile" nature of a toddler’s play.
Key Results
- Reliability: Both tools showed impressive stability. MBQ-B ICCs ranged from 0.71 to 0.94, and MBQ-C ranged from 0.44 to 0.98. Generally, the open-ended versions were slightly more reliable.
- Validity (Sleep & Screens): Strong positive correlations were found between the MBQ and the 24-hour diaries (rho = 0.39 to 0.87).
- Validity (Physical Activity): Correlations with device-measured activity were significant but modest (rho = 0.27 to 0.42). While this seems low, it is actually consistent with or superior to other existing proxy-report tools for this age group.
- Compliance: The tools are "rapid"—the MBQ-B has only 6 items, making it one of the shortest validated tools available.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that the sample was primarily Australian, which may limit generalizability to different cultures or low-income settings where movement patterns and screen access differ. Additionally, the sample size for infants who had not yet reached the "rolling" milestone was small, meaning the "tummy time" validation should be interpreted with caution.
Future research should focus on testing these tools in more diverse global populations and assessing their "sensitivity to change"—essentially, determining if the MBQ can detect improvements in a child's behavior following a health intervention.
Summary updated