Releasing incompatible males drives strong suppression across populations of wild and Wolbachia -carrying Aedes aegypti in Australia

Nigel W. Beebe, Dan Pagendam, Brendan Trewin, Andrew Boomer, Matt Bradford, Andrew Ford, Catherine Liddington, Artiom Bondarenco, Paul J. De Barro, Joshua Gilchrist, Christopher J. Paton, Kyran M. Staunton, Brian J. Johnson, Andrew J. Maynard, Gregor J. Devine, Leon E. Hugo, Gordana Rašić, Helen Cook, Peter Massaro, Nigel Snoad, Jacob E. Crawford, Bradley J. White, Zhiyong Xi, Scott A. RitchieProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have successfully used the incompatible insect technique (IIT) with Aedes aegypti mosquitoes in Australia, releasing genetically modified males that cause incompatible matings, leading to significant population suppression (over 80%). This method shows promise for controlling arbovirus vectors and even demonstrated a lasting suppression effect into the following season in one treated area.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Aedes aegypti mosquitoes are a major global vector for diseases like dengue, yellow fever, chikungunya, and Zika. Traditional control methods, primarily insecticide-based, are becoming less effective due to insecticide resistance and raise concerns about environmental impact and non-target effects. While sterile insect technique (SIT) and genetically modified mosquitoes have shown promise, challenges remain in terms of male fitness, regulatory hurdles, and public acceptance. This paper addresses the need for more effective, species-specific, and environmentally friendly mosquito control methods by evaluating the incompatible insect technique (IIT) in a real-world setting, specifically targeting Aedes aegypti populations that already carry different strains of the Wolbachia bacterium.

Methods

The core of this study involved developing and deploying a novel Wolbachia-infected Aedes aegypti male strain.

  • Strain Development: A US strain of Ae. aegypti carrying the Wolbachia strain wAlbB (originally from Aedes albopictus) was backcrossed with a local Australian Ae. aegypti strain. This process, repeated four times, created the wAlbB2-F4 strain, which was engineered to be reproductively incompatible with both wild-type Ae. aegypti (lacking Wolbachia) and Ae. aegypti already carrying the wMel Wolbachia strain (common in North Queensland).
  • Mass Rearing and Sex Sorting: The wAlbB2-F4 males were mass-reared. Crucially, Verily Life Sciences' sex-sorting technology was employed to ensure virtually no female contamination in the released males. This technology claims a female contamination rate of 1 in 900 million.
  • Field Release: Three isolated landscapes in northern Australia were selected as treatment sites. Over 20 weeks, approximately three million wAlbB2-F4 males were released, with about 50 males per house, three times a week. This frequency was chosen to maintain adequate male overflooding ratios, accounting for the short lifespan of male Ae. aegypti.
  • Monitoring and Data Collection: Paired traps (BG Sentinel traps for adults and ovitraps for eggs/larvae) were used in both treatment and control landscapes to monitor mosquito populations. Adult mosquito collections were analyzed for species, sex, and Wolbachia strain presence using molecular methods (PCR). Larval productivity was assessed from ovitrap collections.
  • Statistical Analysis: Population suppression was quantified by comparing adult trapping rates between treatment and control landscapes. Statistical analysis, including the Theil-Sen estimator and Bonferroni/Benjamini-Hochberg corrections, was used to assess the significance of population declines.

Datasets

The study utilized field data collected from three treatment and three control landscapes in northern Australia. The primary dataset comprises weekly adult mosquito trapping data (from BG Sentinel traps) and larval productivity data (from ovitraps) collected over the 20-week release period and the subsequent season. This data was collected from October 2017 to June 2019. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing monitoring methods were employed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bidirectional Incompatibility is Key: The study successfully demonstrated that a Wolbachia strain (wAlbB2-F4) could induce reproductive incompatibility with both wild-type and wMel Wolbachia-carrying Ae. aegypti. This is crucial for controlling diverse mosquito populations.
  • High Suppression Achieved with Modest Overflooding: Strong population suppression (over 80%) was achieved with initial overflooding ratios of 5:1 to 10:1, suggesting that extremely high ratios might not be necessary for effective control.
  • Lasting Suppression Effect: One of the treated landscapes showed a remarkable suppression effect that extended into the following season, with virtually no adult Ae. aegypti detected for the first 8 weeks. This suggests the potential for long-term impact beyond the release period.
  • Sex-Sorting Technology is Critical: The near-absence of released females in traps validates the effectiveness of the advanced sex-sorting technology, which is vital for preventing the establishment of the released strain and ensuring the IIT's success.
  • IIT Doesn't Disrupt wMel Balance: The release of wAlbB2-F4 males did not disproportionately affect the wMel Wolbachia population, maintaining its high prevalence. This is important as wMel provides arbovirus-blocking properties.

Key Results

  • Population Suppression: Strong population declines, well beyond 80%, were observed across all three treatment landscapes compared to controls.
  • Larval Productivity: Larval productivity rates in treatment areas showed significant declines, often becoming virtually undetectable, mirroring adult population suppression.
  • Following Season Impact:
    • One treatment landscape (T1) showed a 99% suppression effect at week 10 and 97% by week 27 of the following season.
  • A second landscape (T3) showed reduced adults (70% reduction at week 10, ~63% by week 27).
  • A third landscape (T2) recovered fully.
  • No Detectable Female Contamination: The advanced sex-sorting technology ensured no detectable wAlbB2-F4 females or larvae were found in traps, confirming the technology's efficacy.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Variability in Following Season Recovery: While one landscape showed sustained suppression, another recovered fully, and a third showed partial recovery. The reasons for this variability (e.g., landscape isolation, initial population density) require further investigation.
  • Large, Continuous Landscapes: The authors acknowledge that suppression beyond 95% can be challenging in large, continuous landscapes due to potential immigration from outside areas. This was observed in other studies and highlights the importance of landscape isolation for effective IIT.
  • Trap Sampling Limitations: For future elimination trials, the authors suggest a broader array of trapping methods and potentially more sophisticated genomic screening to detect immigrants, especially if complete elimination is the goal.
  • Optimal Overflooding Ratio: While the study achieved success with 5:1 to 10:1 ratios, the exact optimal ratio for maximizing efficiency and minimizing costs warrants further exploration.
  • Long-Term Eradication: The study provides a strong foundation, but longer-term monitoring and trials are needed to fully understand the potential for complete eradication and the most effective strategies for achieving it. The authors suggest that two seasons of IIT in isolated landscapes could provide deeper insights.

Summary updated

Abstract

Releasing sterile or incompatible male insects is a proven method of population management in agricultural systems with the potential to revolutionize mosquito control. Through a collaborative venture with the "Debug" Verily Life Sciences team, we assessed the incompatible insect technique (IIT) with the mosquito vector <i>Aedes aegypti</i> in northern Australia in a replicated treatment control field trial. Backcrossing a US strain of <i>Ae. aegypti</i> carrying <i>Wolbachia w</i>AlbB from <i>Aedes albopictus</i> with a local strain, we generated a <i>w</i>AlbB2-F4 strain incompatible with both the wild-type (no <i>Wolbachia</i>) and <i>w</i>Mel-<i>Wolbachia Ae. aegypti</i> now extant in North Queensland. The <i>w</i>AlbB2-F4 strain was manually mass reared with males separated from females using Verily sex-sorting technologies to obtain no detectable female contamination in the field. With community consent, we delivered a total of three million IIT males into three isolated landscapes of over 200 houses each, releasing ∼50 males per house three times a week over 20 wk. Detecting initial overflooding ratios of between 5:1 and 10:1, strong population declines well beyond 80% were detected across all treatment landscapes when compared to controls. Monitoring through the following season to observe the ongoing effect saw one treatment landscape devoid of adult <i>Ae. aegypti</i> early in the season. A second landscape showed reduced adults, and the third recovered fully. These encouraging results in suppressing both wild-type and <i>w</i>Mel-<i>Ae. aegypti</i> confirms the utility of bidirectional incompatibility in the field setting, show the IIT to be robust, and indicate that the removal of this arbovirus vector from human-occupied landscapes may be achievable.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{beebe2021releasing,
  author = {Nigel W. Beebe and Dan Pagendam and Brendan Trewin and Andrew Boomer and Matt Bradford and Andrew Ford and Catherine Liddington and Artiom Bondarenco and Paul J. De Barro and Joshua Gilchrist and Christopher J. Paton and Kyran M. Staunton and Brian J. Johnson and Andrew J. Maynard and Gregor J. Devine and Leon E. Hugo and Gordana Rašić and Helen Cook and Peter Massaro and Nigel Snoad and Jacob E. Crawford and Bradley J. White and Zhiyong Xi and Scott A. Ritchie},
  title = {{Releasing incompatible males drives strong suppression across populations of wild and <i>Wolbachia</i> -carrying <i>Aedes aegypti</i> in Australia}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.2106828118},
}
Figure