Relativistic asymmetries in the galaxy cross-correlation function

Elena Giusarma, Shadab Alam, Hongyu Zhu, Rupert A. C. Croft, Shirley HoarXiv 2017 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This study investigates the asymmetry in the two-point cross-correlation function of two galaxy populations, focusing on relativistic effects such as gravitational redshift. By comparing General Relativistic Perturbation Theory (GRPT) and Newtonian perturbation theory, we find that while GRPT accurately predicts large-scale linear effects ($r > 50$ Mpc/h), it fails at smaller scales where non-linearities dominate. Conversely, Newtonian theory effectively describes small-scale asymmetries ($r < 20$ Mpc/h) where gravitational redshift is the primary driver. These findings align with recent observational data from the SDSS BOSS survey.

Introduction: The "Lopsided" Universe

When mapping the cosmos, astronomers rely on redshift ($z$) as a proxy for distance. However, this measurement is influenced by peculiar velocities (Doppler shifts) and gravitational redshift—the energy loss of light escaping a galaxy's gravitational well. These effects break the expected symmetry in the spatial distribution of different galaxy populations, creating a detectable "dipole" or asymmetry in their cross-correlation.

Geometry of the galaxy cross-correlation problem, showing the observer (O), two galaxies (i, j), and the relevant angles and distances.

Theoretical Frameworks: GRPT vs. Newtonian Models

The research evaluates two approaches to modeling this asymmetry:

  • General Relativistic Perturbation Theory (GRPT): A linear framework accounting for wide-angle effects and cosmic evolution. While mathematically rigorous, it assumes a "smooth" universe, often failing at the non-linear scales where most data exists.
  • Newtonian Perturbation Theory: Used here to model the local, non-linear physics of galaxy clusters. It focuses on the mean gravitational redshift difference ($\delta z_g$) between populations based on their specific potential wells.

To quantify these effects, the authors utilize the Dipole ($\xi_1$) and the Shell Estimator ($z_g^{shell}$). The latter converts spatial asymmetry into an equivalent velocity (km/s), providing a more intuitive physical comparison.

Key Insights: The Scale Divide and Sign Flips

A critical finding is the "scale divide." GRPT is effective for very large scales ($r > 50$ Mpc/h), but the signal there is currently too faint for reliable measurement. On smaller scales ($r < 10$ Mpc/h), GRPT predicts cancellations between relativistic terms that are not observed in real-world data.

The shell estimator $z_g^{shell}$ as a function of scale $r$, comparing relativistic and wide-angle effects.

Furthermore, the asymmetry estimator can undergo a "sign flip" depending on the scale. Small-scale physics—specifically the deep potential wells of individual galaxies—can reverse the predicted direction of asymmetry compared to large-scale cosmic trends.

Results and Observational Alignment

The study confirms that gravitational redshift dominates asymmetry on scales below 20 Mpc/h. The predicted signal is subtle—approximately 0.1 to 0.4 km/s—yet it is consistent with the $2.7\sigma$ detection recently reported in SDSS BOSS data. By incorporating a small velocity offset to account for internal galaxy potentials, the Newtonian model's predictions align closely with high-resolution N-body simulations.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The limitations of linear GRPT highlight the need for a unified framework that bridges non-linear Newtonian physics at cluster scales with large-scale relativistic effects. Such models will be essential for upcoming missions like DESI and Euclid, which seek to use these subtle asymmetries to test General Relativity across cosmic history.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the asymmetry in the two-point cross-correlation function of two populations of galaxies focusing in particular on the relativistic effects that include the gravitational redshift. We derive the cross-correlation function on small and large scales using two different approaches: General Relativistic and Newtonian perturbation theory. Following recent work by Bonvin et al., Gaztanaga et al. and Croft, we calculate the dipole and the shell estimator with the two procedures and we compare our results. We find that while General Relativistic Perturbation Theory (GRPT) is able to make predictions of relativistic effects on very large, obviously linear scales (r &gt; 50 Mpc/h), the presence of non-linearities physically occurring on much smaller scales (down to those describing galactic potential wells) can strongly affect the asymmetry estimators. These can lead to cancellations of the relativistic terms, and sign changes in the estimators on scales up to r ~ 50 Mpc/h. On the other hand, with an appropriate non-linear gravitational potential, the results obtained using Newtonian theory can successfully describe the asymmetry on smaller, non-linear scales (r &lt; 20 Mpc/h) where gravitational redshift is the dominant term. On larger scales the asymmetry is much smaller in magnitude, and measurement is not within reach of current observations. This is in agreement with the observational results obtained by Gaztnaga et al. and the first detection of relativistic effects (on (r &lt; 20 Mpc/h) scales) by Alam et al.
BibTeX
@misc{giusarma2017relativistic,
  author = {Elena Giusarma and Shadab Alam and Hongyu Zhu and Rupert A. C. Croft and Shirley Ho},
  title = {{Relativistic asymmetries in the galaxy cross-correlation function}},
  year = {2017},
  eprint = {1709.07854},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1709.07854},
}
Figure