Relative Average Look Duration and its Association with Neurophysiological Activity in Young Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder

Dmitry Isaev, Samantha Major, Michael Murias, Kimberly L. H. Carpenter, David Carlson, Guillermo Sapiro, Géraldine DawsonScientific 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) is characterized by early attentional differences that often precede the hallmark symptoms of social communication impairments. Development of novel measures of attentional behaviors may lead to earlier identification of children at risk for ASD. In this work, we first introduce a behavioral measure, Relative Average Look Duration (RALD), indicating attentional preference to different stimuli, such as social versus nonsocial stimuli; and then study its association with neurophysiological activity. We show that (1) ASD and typically developing (TD) children differ in both (absolute) Average Look Duration (ALD) and RALD to stimuli during an EEG experiment, with the most pronounced differences in looking at social stimuli; and (2) associations between looking behaviors and neurophysiological activity, as measured by EEG, are different for children with ASD versus TD. Even when ASD children show attentional engagement to social content, our results suggest that their underlying brain activity is different than TD children. This study therefore introduces a new measure of social/nonsocial attentional preference in ASD and demonstrates the value of incorporating attentional variables measured simultaneously with EEG into the analysis pipeline.

Introduction

Early diagnosis of Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) is critical for effective intervention, yet current diagnostic tools often rely on subjective clinical observations of symptoms that may only emerge later in development. One of the earliest signs of ASD is a difference in how children allocate attention—specifically, a reduced preference for social stimuli (like faces and speech) compared to nonsocial stimuli (like toys or geometric patterns). While eye-tracking and EEG have been used separately to study these differences, few studies have integrated them into a joint analysis. This research addresses the lack of a robust, normalized measure that captures preferential attention and links it directly to synchronized brain activity, moving beyond simple looking behavior to understand what the brain is doing during engagement.

Methodology

The study involved 62 children (31 with ASD, 31 typically developing) between the ages of 2 and 7. While wearing a 124-channel EEG net, children watched three types of videos designed to elicit varying levels of social engagement.

Experimental stimuli used in the study: a social video (woman singing), dynamic toys, and cascading bubbles as a control.

Key Metrics

The researchers introduced two primary behavioral metrics:

  • Average Look Duration (ALD): Total time spent looking at the screen divided by the number of individual "looks." This captures the sustained nature of intermittent attention.
  • Relative Average Look Duration (RALD): A normalized index calculated as $(ALD_{social} - ALD_{toys}) / (ALD_{social} + ALD_{toys})$. This provides a within-subject measure of preference, ranging from -1 (toy preference) to +1 (social preference).

On the neurophysiological side, the team calculated Relative Power (RP) across standard frequency bands and the Theta-Beta Ratio (TBR), a metric often associated with attentional control.

Results and Discussion

Behavioral Separation

ASD children exhibited significantly shorter ALD than TD children across all stimuli ($F_{1,177} > 35.39, p < 0.001$), with the most robust differences occurring during social videos. RALD effectively distinguished the two groups when comparing Social vs. Toys ($p < 0.002$) and Social vs. Bubbles ($p < 0.04$).

A raster plot illustrating the intermittent nature of looking behavior across participants, highlighting the variability in attention captured by the ALD metric.

Neurophysiological Divergence

The most striking insight is that even when ASD and TD children show similar RALD (behavioral engagement), their brains process information differently. In TD children, a higher preference for social stimuli was linked to higher TBR (increased theta/decreased beta), a pattern associated with healthy multi-sensory attention. In contrast, ASD children showed a significant negative association in posterior regions ($p < 0.05$). This suggests that the social context specifically taxes the attentional systems of children with ASD in a way not visible through behavior alone.

Conclusion and Limitations

This study demonstrates that RALD is a valuable metric for quantifying social attentional preference. By combining it with EEG, researchers can identify "hidden" neurophysiological differences in how children with ASD process social information.

While the findings are promising, the authors note limitations including a relatively small sample size (n=62) and significant differences in mean IQ between the ASD and TD groups. Future work should aim to replicate these results in larger, better-matched cohorts and explore RALD's potential as a diagnostic classifier or a tool for monitoring intervention efficacy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) is characterized by early attentional differences that often precede the hallmark symptoms of social communication impairments. Development of novel measures of attentional behaviors may lead to earlier identification of children at risk for ASD. In this work, we first introduce a behavioral measure, Relative Average Look Duration (RALD), indicating attentional preference to different stimuli, such as social versus nonsocial stimuli; and then study its association with neurophysiological activity. We show that (1) ASD and typically developing (TD) children differ in both (absolute) Average Look Duration (ALD) and RALD to stimuli during an EEG experiment, with the most pronounced differences in looking at social stimuli; and (2) associations between looking behaviors and neurophysiological activity, as measured by EEG, are different for children with ASD versus TD. Even when ASD children show attentional engagement to social content, our results suggest that their underlying brain activity is different than TD children. This study therefore introduces a new measure of social/nonsocial attentional preference in ASD and demonstrates the value of incorporating attentional variables measured simultaneously with EEG into the analysis pipeline.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{isaev2020relative,
  author = {Dmitry Isaev and Samantha Major and Michael Murias and Kimberly L. H. Carpenter and David Carlson and Guillermo Sapiro and Géraldine Dawson},
  title = {{Relative Average Look Duration and its Association with Neurophysiological Activity in Young Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-57902-1},
}
Figure