Relationship between postural balance and knee and toe muscle power in young women.

Yoshimi Katayama, Masuo Senda, Michiaki Hamada, Masaki Kataoka, Mai Shintani, Hajime InouePubMed 2004 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated the relationship between lower extremity muscle power and postural balance in young women. It found that while closing the eyes significantly increased body sway, especially during single-leg stance, lower extremity muscle power did not appear to be the primary factor influencing balance in this healthy young population.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Falls are a significant concern, particularly in the elderly, and are often attributed to age-related physiological changes. While factors like decreased muscle power and balance disturbances are known contributors, the specific interplay between lower extremity muscle strength and postural sway, especially in younger, healthy individuals, remains an area needing further exploration. Understanding these relationships can inform the development of better risk assessment tools and targeted interventions. This paper aims to clarify how knee and toe muscle power relate to body sway in young women, a population that might serve as a baseline for understanding age-related declines.

Methods

The researchers recruited 57 healthy young women volunteers (in their 20s) for the study. They employed two primary measurement techniques:

  • Body Sway Measurement: A stabilimeter (Gravicorder GS11) was used to quantify body sway. Measurements were taken during:
  • 30-second two-leg standing (eyes open).
  • 10-second one-leg standing (eyes open and closed, alternating between right and left legs, with 5 trials each).
  • Several parameters of body sway were analyzed, including locus length per time unit (rate of sway), locus length per environmental area (fine postural control), environmental area (degree of equilibrium impairment), rectangle area, root mean square area, and the ratio of sway with eyes closed to eyes open (Romberg ratio).
  • Lower Extremity Muscle Power Measurement:
    • Knee Flexor and Extensor Power: Assessed using a Cybex II dynamometer during knee bending-stretching exercises. Peak torque was measured and normalized by body weight.
  • Toe Flexor and Abductor Power: Measured using a custom-developed toe myometer. Flexion power of all toes, hallux abduction power, and little toe abduction power were recorded.

Statistical analysis involved comparing stable and unstable groups (defined by their ability to maintain one-leg standing with eyes closed) using Student's t-test and calculating correlation coefficients.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized data collected from the 57 participants.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Eyes Have It (for Sway): Closing the eyes significantly increased body sway, particularly during the more challenging one-leg stance. This highlights the crucial role of visual input in maintaining balance.
  • One-Legged Challenge: A substantial portion (62%) of the young women were unable to maintain single-leg stance with their eyes closed for the required 10 seconds. This difficulty strongly correlated with increased body sway.
  • Asymmetry in Balance: Many participants exhibited an asymmetry in their balance, with one leg being more stable than the other, underscoring the need to assess both legs individually, especially with eyes closed.
  • Muscle Power's Limited Role (in this context): Contrary to the researchers' initial hypothesis, lower extremity muscle power (knee and toe) did not show a strong, consistent correlation with body sway measures in the overall group. This suggests other factors might be more dominant in maintaining balance in healthy young individuals.

Key Results

  • Increased Sway with Eyes Closed: Body sway with eyes closed was approximately 1.35 times greater than with eyes open during two-leg standing and about 3 times greater during one-leg standing.
  • Unstable Group Sway: The group unable to maintain one-leg stance with eyes closed (unstable group) exhibited significantly greater sway (LNG/TIME and ENV.AREA) compared to the stable group.
  • Muscle Power Correlations (Limited): In the stable group, some correlations were observed: toe abductor power and knee extensor/flexor power correlated with certain sway parameters (LNG/E, ENV.AREA) during one-leg standing with eyes open. However, these relationships were not consistently found across all measures or in the unstable group.
  • No Significant Differences in Muscle Power: No significant differences in knee or toe muscle power were found between the stable and unstable groups.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Muscle Power Influence: The study's primary limitation is that lower extremity muscle power did not emerge as a dominant factor in maintaining balance in this young, healthy cohort. This suggests that other factors, such as proprioceptive reflexes, visual input, or even other muscle groups, might play a more significant role.
  • Sample Specificity: The study focused on young, healthy women. The findings may not generalize to other age groups, genders, or individuals with underlying health conditions.
  • Future Directions: The authors emphasize the need for further research to clarify the roles of other muscle groups and systems (e.g., vestibular, proprioceptive) in postural control. They also highlight the importance of standardized testing methods, particularly the necessity of assessing both legs alternately with eyes closed to capture the full range of balance capabilities. The study suggests that while simple tests like one-leg standing with eyes open might be useful for general fitness screening, they are insufficient for comprehensive risk assessment.

Summary updated

Abstract

Muscle power in the lower extremities and body sway were measured in 57 healthy young women volunteers in their 20's. Body sway was measured with a stabilimeter for 30 sec during two-leg standing, and for 10 sec during one-leg standing with the eyes open or closed, alternating between right and left legs (5 times each). The measured parameters of body sway were locus length per time unit, locus length per environmental area, environmental area, rectangle area, root mean square area, and the ratio of sway with eyes closed to sway with eyes open. Knee flexor and extensor power and toe flexor and abductor power were the measures representing lower extremity muscle power. The increase in sway with the eyes closed was more marked during one-leg standing than two-leg standing, as expected. We found that 36 of 57 subjects (62%) were unable to maintain one-leg standing with their eyes closed, and this failure correlated with marked body sway (P = 0.0086). Many subjects had one leg that was classified as stable and the other leg classified as unstable. Clearly, testing of both legs alternately with eyes closed is necessary to measure the full range of sway in subjects. Lower extremity muscle power did not appear to be the dominant factor in maintaining balance in these young subjects.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{katayama2004relationship,
  author = {Yoshimi Katayama and Masuo Senda and Michiaki Hamada and Masaki Kataoka and Mai Shintani and Hajime Inoue},
  title = {{Relationship between postural balance and knee and toe muscle power in young women.}},
  booktitle = {PubMed},
  year = {2004},
  doi = {10.18926/amo/32087},
}

Loading related content...

Figure