Relationship between individual neuron and network spontaneous activity in developing mouse cortex

Heather Barnett, Julijana Gjorgjieva, Keiko Weir, C. P. Comfort, Adrienne L. Fairhall, William J. MoodyJournal of Neurophysiology 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

Developing brains exhibit spontaneous electrical activity (SSA) crucial for growth, but its origins are unclear. This study reveals that the piriform cortex initiates these waves due to higher intrinsic neuronal activity, a finding supported by a computational model that successfully replicates wave generation and directionality.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The developing mammalian brain generates spontaneous synchronous activity (SSA) that propagates as electrical waves. This activity is vital for normal development, but the precise mechanisms driving its initiation and propagation, particularly in the cerebral cortex, remain elusive. Previous work identified the ventrolateral piriform cortex as a unique "pacemaker" region that initiates SSA, while the dorsal neocortex merely participates. This paper aims to understand why the piriform cortex acts as a pacemaker by investigating the differences in neuronal activity patterns between the piriform and dorsal cortical regions.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Calcium Imaging: They used in vitro cultured coronal slices of developing mouse cortex (embryonic day 18 to postnatal day 2) and performed calcium imaging to visualize neuronal activity. This allowed them to observe spontaneous calcium transients, indicative of neuronal firing, at both single-cell and cluster levels.
  • Pharmacological Manipulation: To distinguish between activity driven by intrinsic neuronal properties and that mediated by synaptic connections, they applied synaptic antagonists (blocking GABA and glutamate receptors).
  • Conductance-Based Network Model: They constructed a computational model of the cortex with three layers, each representing a different region (ventral, intermediate, dorsal). Crucially, these layers differed in the proportion of neurons capable of intrinsically generating bursting activity. This model allowed them to test hypotheses about how intrinsic excitability gradients could drive wave initiation and propagation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study primarily relies on experimental data generated from cultured mouse cortical slices.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Piriform Cortex's Intrinsic "Buzz": The piriform cortex exhibits significantly more asynchronous neuronal activity between the large-scale synchronous waves compared to the dorsal cortex. This suggests a higher baseline level of intrinsic neuronal excitability in this region.
  • Synaptic Isolation Doesn't Stop the Beat: Even when synaptic transmission was blocked, asynchronous activity and cellular clusters persisted. This strongly supports the idea that these activities are driven by cell-intrinsic properties, not just network connectivity.
  • A Gradient is Key: A computational model demonstrated that a gradient of intrinsic neuronal excitability across cortical layers (higher in the ventral piriform, lower in the dorsal) was sufficient to generate directionally propagating waves that mimicked experimental observations. This highlights the importance of regional differences in intrinsic neuronal properties for orchestrating brain activity.
  • Pacemaker Persistence: The model predicted, and experiments confirmed, that the piriform cortex (the "pacemaker" region) remains active longer at the termination of a wave than the follower regions, suggesting a sustained intrinsic activity.

Key Results

  • Higher Asynchronous Activity in Piriform: The piriform cortex showed a significantly higher proportion of asynchronously active cells (37 ± 2.8%) compared to the dorsal cortex (9.6 ± 1.4%) between synchronous waves.
  • Clusters Rely on Gap Junctions: While single-cell asynchronous activity persisted after synaptic blockade, the spread of activity within clusters was significantly reduced by octanol, an antagonist of gap junctions, indicating their crucial role in cluster formation.
  • Model Replication: The network model successfully replicated key experimental findings, including the directional propagation of waves from the ventral to the dorsal regions, driven solely by a gradient of intrinsic excitability.
  • Wave Duration: Waves persisted longer in the ventral piriform cortex (5.52 ± 0.5 sec) compared to the dorsal cortex (2.95 ± 0.34 sec).

Limitations and Future Work

  • "Why" of Intrinsic Activity: While the study shows that the piriform cortex has higher intrinsic activity, the underlying molecular or cellular reasons for this difference are not fully elucidated. The authors speculate on unique features of the piriform cortex (e.g., phylogenetic age, structural organization) but acknowledge this is an area for further investigation.
  • Model Simplifications: The model, while effective, is a simplification of the complex biological system. Future work could explore more detailed network architectures and neuronal dynamics.
  • Temperature Effects: The study did not investigate the role of temperature on cluster activity, which was mentioned as a potential factor in previous research.

The authors suggest that the observed differences in cell-autonomous properties between the ventral and dorsal cortices are sufficient to explain ventral wave initiation and directionality, providing a mechanism for location-specific SSA generation. Future research could delve deeper into the cellular mechanisms underlying these intrinsic differences and explore their broader implications for brain development and function.

Summary updated

Abstract

Spontaneous synchronous activity (SSA) that propagates as electrical waves is found in numerous central nervous system structures and is critical for normal development, but the mechanisms of generation of such activity are not clear. In previous work, we showed that the ventrolateral piriform cortex is uniquely able to initiate SSA in contrast to the dorsal neocortex, which participates in, but does not initiate, SSA (Lischalk JW, Easton CR, Moody WJ. Dev Neurobiol 69: 407-414, 2009). In this study, we used Ca(2+) imaging of cultured embryonic day 18 to postnatal day 2 coronal slices (embryonic day 17 + 1-4 days in culture) of the mouse cortex to investigate the different activity patterns of individual neurons in these regions. In the piriform cortex where SSA is initiated, a higher proportion of neurons was active asynchronously between waves, and a larger number of groups of coactive cells was present compared with the dorsal cortex. When we applied GABA and glutamate synaptic antagonists, asynchronous activity and cellular clusters remained, while synchronous activity was eliminated, indicating that asynchronous activity is a result of cell-intrinsic properties that differ between these regions. To test the hypothesis that higher levels of cell-autonomous activity in the piriform cortex underlie its ability to initiate waves, we constructed a conductance-based network model in which three layers differed only in the proportion of neurons able to intrinsically generate bursting behavior. Simulations using this model demonstrated that a gradient of intrinsic excitability was sufficient to produce directionally propagating waves that replicated key experimental features, indicating that the higher level of cell-intrinsic activity in the piriform cortex may provide a substrate for SSA generation.
BibTeX
@article{barnett2014relationship,
  author = {Heather Barnett and Julijana Gjorgjieva and Keiko Weir and C. P. Comfort and Adrienne L. Fairhall and William J. Moody},
  title = {{Relationship between individual neuron and network spontaneous activity in developing mouse cortex}},
  journal = {Journal of Neurophysiology},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1152/jn.00349.2014},
}
Figure