Relationship between clinical outcomes and nerve conduction studies before and after surgery in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome

Masato Ise, Taichi Saito, Yoshimi Katayama, Ryuichi Nakahara, Yasunori Shimamura, Michiaki Hamada, Masuo Senda, Toshifumi OzakiResearch 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Nerve conduction studies (NCS) are the gold standard for diagnosing carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS), yet their ability to predict surgical outcomes remains unclear. This study evaluated whether preoperative or 6-month postoperative NCS results could forecast clinical and motor recovery at one year. Analyzing 85 hands following open carpal tunnel release, researchers found that preoperative NCS did not correlate with long-term improvement. In contrast, sensory conduction velocity (SCV) and distal motor latency (DML) at 6 months postoperatively were strong predictors of 12-month grip strength and disability scores. These findings suggest that mid-recovery electrophysiological assessments provide a reliable "crystal ball" for long-term patient outcomes.

Introduction

Carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) is the most common entrapment neuropathy, frequently requiring surgical intervention to decompress the median nerve. While open carpal tunnel release is generally effective, both surgeons and patients often seek objective ways to predict the extent of recovery. Historically, clinicians looked to preoperative NCS—measuring the speed of electrical signals—to estimate surgical success. However, data on the prognostic value of baseline nerve health has been conflicting. This study addresses this gap by shifting the focus from preoperative status to the recovery trajectory measured six months after surgery.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective analysis of 85 hands (from 67 patients) that underwent open carpal tunnel release at Okayama University Hospital between 2011 and 2020. Patients with confounding conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis, polyneuropathy, or those on dialysis were excluded.

The study utilized two primary types of metrics:

  1. Clinical Outcomes: The Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand (DASH) questionnaire for patient-reported disability and Grip Strength (GS) for objective motor function.
  2. Electrophysiological Outcomes (NCS): Distal Motor Latency (DML), measuring motor signal speed, and Sensory Conduction Velocity (SCV), measuring sensory signal speed.

Assessments were performed preoperatively and at 6 and 12 months post-surgery. The team used Spearman’s correlation and Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) curves to identify specific "cutoff" values for predicting clinical improvement.

Results

The Baseline Blind Spot

A key finding was that preoperative NCS scores showed no significant correlation with the degree of improvement in grip strength or DASH scores. This indicates that the severity of nerve damage before surgery does not necessarily dictate the patient's ultimate recovery potential.

The Six-Month Checkpoint

Clinical recovery was found to be a slow, ongoing process. Significant improvements in DASH and grip strength were observed between the 6-month and 12-month marks. Notably, 40% of patients experienced a temporary decrease in grip strength at 6 months compared to baseline, likely due to surgical scar tenderness (pillar pain), before surpassing their original strength by 12 months.

Predictive Power of Postoperative NCS

Nerve health at 6 months post-op served as a powerful predictor for outcomes at one year:

  • Grip Strength: Postoperative SCV correlated strongly with changes in grip strength (r = 0.67). An SCV cutoff of ≥ 38.5 m/s at 6 months predicted significant grip strength improvement with 100% specificity.
  • Disability Reduction: Postoperative DML correlated with DASH score changes (r = -0.59). A DML cutoff of ≤ 4.4 ms at 6 months predicted significant improvement in DASH scores with 66.7% specificity.
  • Sensory-Disability Link: Postoperative SCV also showed a strong correlation (r = 0.77) with overall DASH score improvement at 12 months.

Discussion

The study highlights that the median nerve's state mid-way through the healing process is more indicative of long-term success than its preoperative state. The 6-month mark serves as a critical prognostic window. The phenomenon of "pillar pain" explains why some patients may feel discouraged by a temporary dip in grip strength early on; clinicians can use 6-month NCS data to reassure these patients of their long-term recovery trajectory.

Conclusion

Nerve conduction studies at 6 months postoperatively are effective tools for predicting clinical and motor outcomes at one year in CTS patients. By utilizing specific SCV and DML thresholds, clinicians can provide more accurate, objective prognoses, helping to manage patient expectations and monitor the success of surgical decompression.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background: Nerve conduction study (NCS) is the only useful test for objective assessment of carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS). However, the relationship between pre- and postoperative NCS and clinical outcomes was unclear. This study aimed to determine whether pre- and postoperative (6 months) NCS could predict patient-oriented and motor outcomes (6 and 12 months postoperatively) in patients with CTS. Methods: Of the 85 patients with CTS, 107 hands were analyzed from March 2011 to March 2020. All patients underwent open carpal tunnel release and were examined using the disabilities of the arm, shoulder and hand (DASH) questionnaire and grip strength (GS) preoperatively and 6 and 12 months. Moreover, NCS was examined preoperatively and 6 months postoperatively. Distal motor latency (DML) and sensory conduction velocity (SCV) were the parameters used for NCS. The correlation coefficient between NCS and DASH or GS was calculated. A receiver operating characteristic curve was utilized to determine the NCS threshold value to predict DASH and GS improvement. Results: The average scores of GS preoperatively and 6 and 12 months postoperatively were 21.3, 22.3, and 22.8, respectively. On the other hand, the average scores of DASH preoperatively and 6 and 12 months postoperatively were 28.8, 18.3, and 12.2, respectively. The average NCS scores (DML and SCV) preoperatively/6 months postoperatively were 7.3/5.4 and 27.8/36.7, respectively. Preoperative NCS did not correlate with DASH and GS. Postoperative SCV correlated with the change in grip strength (6–12 months, r = 0.67; 0–12 months, r = 0.60) and DASH (0–12 months, r = 0.77). Moreover, postoperative DML correlated with the change in DASH (6–12 months, r = -0.33; 0–12 months, r = -0.59). The prediction for the improvement of GS/DASH achieved a sensitivity of 50.0%/66.7% and a specificity of 100%/100%, at an SCV cutoff score of 38.5/45.0 or above. The prediction for improvement of GS/DASH achieved a sensitivity of 83.3%/66.7% and a specificity of 100%/66.7% at a DML cutoff score of 4.4/4.4 or below. Conclusions: NCS at 6 months postoperatively can be used to predict the improvement of clinical outcome after 6 months postoperatively in patients with CTS.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ise2021relationship,
  author = {Masato Ise and Taichi Saito and Yoshimi Katayama and Ryuichi Nakahara and Yasunori Shimamura and Michiaki Hamada and Masuo Senda and Toshifumi Ozaki},
  title = {{Relationship between clinical outcomes and nerve conduction studies before and after surgery in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-445381/v1},
}
Figure