Relations Between Information and Estimation in Discrete-Time Lévy Channels

Jiantao Jiao, Kartik Venkat, Tsachy WeissmanIEEE Trans. Information Theory 2017 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new class of communication channels called "discrete-time Lévy channels" and establishes fundamental relationships between information theory (mutual information) and estimation theory (minimum mean squared error) for these channels. This work unifies and extends existing results for Gaussian and Poisson channels, providing a more general framework for understanding information processing in noisy systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses a long-standing question in information and estimation theory: how are measures of information (like mutual information) related to measures of estimation accuracy (like mean squared error)? While elegant relationships have been found for specific channel models like Gaussian and Poisson channels, it was unclear if these relationships held for broader classes of channels. The authors aim to bridge this gap by introducing and analyzing a more general family of channels, the discrete-time Lévy channels, and demonstrating that the established information-estimation relationships extend to this broader class. This is important because real-world communication channels often deviate from the idealized Gaussian or Poisson models.

Methods

The core of the paper involves defining and analyzing "discrete-time Lévy channels." These channels are characterized by their output distribution, which, conditioned on the input, is an "infinitely divisible distribution." This is a generalization of the distributions found in Gaussian and Poisson channels. The authors leverage concepts from probability theory, particularly Lévy processes and their properties, along with tools from convex analysis and information theory, such as Bregman divergences and Fenchel-Legendre transforms.

Key methodological contributions include:

  • Introduction of Discrete-Time Lévy Channels: Defining a new class of channels based on infinitely divisible distributions and a natural "SNR" parameter.
  • General Information-Estimation Formula: Deriving a unified formula that relates the mutual information between the channel input and output to an optimal estimation loss function for these Lévy channels. This formula is a generalization of the I-MMSE (Information-Minimum Mean Squared Error) formula for Gaussian channels.
  • Mismatched Estimation: Extending the information-estimation relationships to scenarios where the receiver's model of the channel is incorrect (mismatched estimation).
  • Specific Examples: Applying the general framework to derive explicit information-estimation relationships for the gamma and negative binomial channels, which are instances of Lévy channels.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and does not involve empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unification of Information-Estimation Relations: The paper demonstrates that the elegant relationships between mutual information and optimal estimation loss, previously known for Gaussian and Poisson channels, are not isolated phenomena but hold for a much broader class of "discrete-time Lévy channels." This suggests a deeper, underlying mathematical structure connecting information and estimation.
  • The "Correct" Loss Function: The authors identify a specific loss function for Lévy channels that naturally generalizes the squared error loss (Gaussian) and the Poisson loss. This loss function is intimately tied to the channel's characteristics and plays a crucial role in the information-estimation duality.
  • Lévy Channels as a Natural Generalization: The introduction of discrete-time Lévy channels provides a principled way to extend existing results. Their connection to infinitely divisible distributions and Lévy processes makes them a natural and theoretically rich family of channels.
  • SNR Interpretation for Lévy Channels: The parameter $\gamma$ in the Lévy channel definition is shown to have a natural interpretation as a "signal-to-noise ratio" level, allowing for a systematic study of channel quality.
  • Mismatched Estimation Duality: The paper extends the information-estimation duality to the setting of mismatched estimation, showing a direct relationship between relative entropy and the "cost of mismatch" in estimation.

Key Results

  • General I-MMSE-like Formula: The paper presents a general formula (Theorem 10) relating the derivative of mutual information with respect to SNR to the optimal estimation loss for discrete-time Lévy channels. This formula is a direct generalization of the I-MMSE formula for Gaussian channels and the analogous result for Poisson channels.
  • Entropy Representation: A novel representation for the entropy of a random variable is derived for Lévy channels (Theorem 11), which is shown to be invariant to one-to-one transformations, a surprising property for the derived expression.
  • Mismatched Estimation Theorem: A theorem (Theorem 12) is presented that relates the relative entropy between true and mismatched channel output laws to an integral of the "cost of mismatch" over SNR levels.
  • Recovery of Gaussian and Poisson Results: The paper shows how the established results for Gaussian (Theorem 10, Corollary 14) and Poisson (Theorem 10, Corollary 14) channels are recovered as special cases of their general framework.
  • Explicit Results for Gamma and Negative Binomial Channels: The authors derive specific information-estimation relationships for the gamma channel (Theorem 15) and the negative binomial channel (Theorem 17), demonstrating the applicability and richness of their general theory.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumptions for Theorems: The theorems presented have certain regularity conditions on the input distribution and the channel characteristics (e.g., finite moments, integrability conditions). While these are often necessary for mathematical tractability, exploring weaker conditions could broaden the applicability.
  • Conjecture on Largest Family: The authors conjecture that discrete-time Lévy channels are the largest family for which these information-estimation results can be established. Proving this conjecture would be a significant theoretical achievement.
  • Continuous-Time Extension: The paper focuses on discrete-time Lévy channels. Extending these results to continuous-time Lévy channels would be a natural next step.
  • Practical Applications: While the theoretical framework is established, exploring specific practical applications in communication systems, signal processing, or machine learning where these Lévy channels might arise would be valuable.
  • Comparison with Other Generalizations: The paper briefly discusses alternative approaches to generalizing information-estimation results (Section VI.B). A more in-depth comparison and analysis of the advantages of their proposed framework could be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

Fundamental relations between information and estimation have been established in the literature for the discrete-time Gaussian and Poisson channels. In this paper, we demonstrate that such relations hold for a much larger class of observation models. We introduce the natural family of discrete-time Lévy channels where the distribution of the output conditioned on the input is infinitely divisible. For Lévy channels, we establish new representations relating the mutual information between the channel input and output to an optimal expected estimation loss, thereby unifying and considerably extending results from the Gaussian and Poisson settings. We demonstrate the richness of our results by working out two examples of Lévy channels, namely the gamma channel and the negative binomial channel, with corresponding relations between information and estimation. Extensions to the setting of mismatched estimation are also presented.
BibTeX
@article{jiao2017relations,
  author = {Jiantao Jiao and Kartik Venkat and Tsachy Weissman},
  title = {{Relations Between Information and Estimation in Discrete-Time Lévy Channels}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Information Theory},
  year = {2017},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=unykKSQrzXD},
}
Figure