Relational conflicts during COVID-19: Impact of loss and reduction of employment due to prevention measures and the influence of sex and stress (in the iCARE study)

Noémie Tremblay, Camille Léger, Frédérique Deslauriers, Lydia Hébert-Auger, Vincent Gosselin Boucher, Simon Bacon, Maximilien V. Dialufuma, Kim Lavoie, for the iCARE Study TeamJournal of Health Psychology 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study found that losing or reducing employment during the COVID-19 pandemic significantly increased relational conflicts, with males experiencing this effect more strongly than females. While COVID-19-related stress also independently boosted conflicts, it didn't alter the relationship between job loss and conflict.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic brought unprecedented public health measures, including lockdowns and social distancing, which led to widespread job losses and reduced employment. These economic disruptions, coupled with increased stress and isolation, raised concerns about their impact on interpersonal relationships, particularly within households. While previous research has linked unemployment to relationship strain, this study specifically investigates how pandemic-induced job changes, alongside COVID-19 stress and sex, influenced relational conflicts in a Canadian context. The authors aim to understand these dynamics to inform targeted interventions and policy recommendations.

Methods

The researchers employed logistic regression analyses to examine the associations between employment status, sex, COVID-19-related stress, and relational conflicts. They conducted a main effects model to assess the primary relationships and then introduced an interaction term for sex and employment status. Due to a significant interaction, they performed disaggregated analyses for males and females separately. A separate model explored the impact of COVID-19-related stress. All analyses were adjusted for several covariates, including age, survey wave, ethnicity, presence of anxiety/depressive disorders, number of children, and a weighting variable to ensure sample representativeness. Statistical significance was set at p < 0.05.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the International COVID-19 Awareness and Responses Evaluation (iCARE) Study. Specifically, they analyzed three waves of data collected from a Canadian representative sample between October 29, 2020, and March 23, 2021. Participants were recruited through an online polling firm (Léger Opinion©). The sample was weighted by age and sex to reflect the Canadian population.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Job loss as a significant conflict driver: The pandemic's economic fallout wasn't just about finances; it directly translated into increased household friction.
  • Gendered impact of job loss: While both sexes were affected, men experiencing job loss saw a more pronounced increase in relational conflicts compared to women. This suggests that for men, employment might be more tightly linked to their social identity and stress management.
  • Stress as an independent factor: High levels of COVID-19-related stress, regardless of employment status, were a strong predictor of relational conflicts, highlighting the pervasive psychological toll of the pandemic.
  • No interaction between stress and job loss: Interestingly, while both stress and job loss independently contributed to conflict, the stress of the pandemic didn't amplify the conflict arising from job loss itself. This might be due to financial support measures like CERB mitigating some of the financial stress associated with job loss.

Key Results

  • Participants who experienced a loss or reduction of employment were 3.6 times more likely to report increased relational conflicts compared to those with stable employment.
  • A significant interaction between employment status and sex was found. Males who lost or reduced employment were 5.2 times more likely to report relational conflicts, whereas females were 2.4 times more likely to do so, indicating a stronger impact on males.
  • Individuals reporting higher levels of COVID-19-related stress were nearly 10 times more likely to report relational conflicts (OR = 9.54).
  • There was no statistically significant interaction between COVID-19-related stress levels and loss or reduction of employment on relational conflicts.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Cross-sectional data: The study used consecutive cohorts rather than longitudinal data, limiting the ability to track temporal trends within the same individuals.
  • Self-report bias: All data were self-reported, potentially introducing social desirability bias, although anonymity was maintained.
  • Individual perspective: The study captured individual experiences, not those of partners or family members, whose perspectives might differ.
  • Marital status not assessed: The analysis did not distinguish between married and cohabiting individuals, potentially overlooking nuances in relational dynamics.
  • Crude measures: The measures for relational conflicts were described as "crude" rather than validated, though designed for ecological validity.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • Developing more precise measures of relational conflicts to differentiate types (verbal/physical), intensity, and frequency.
  • Exploring dyadic relationships (e.g., employed males vs. unemployed females) to understand relational dynamics more deeply.
  • Examining the relationship between relational conflicts and other variables like substance use disorders.
  • Investigating the impact of financial support measures like CERB on stress and relational conflicts.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study explored the association between pandemic-related loss/reduction of employment, sex, COVID-19-related stress and relational conflicts. A sample of 5103 Canadians from the iCARE study were recruited through an online polling firm between October 29, 2020, and March 23, 2021. Logistic regressions revealed that participants with loss/reduction of employment were 3.6 times more likely to report increased relational conflicts compared to those with stable employment (OR = 3.60; 95% CIs = 3.03-4.26). There was a significant interaction between employment status and sex (<i>x</i><sup>2</sup> = 10.16; <i>p</i> < 0.005), where loss/reduction of employment was associated with more relational conflicts in males compared to females. There was a main effect of COVID-19-related stress levels on relational conflicts (increased stress vs no stress : OR = 9.54; 95% CIs = 6.70-13.60), but no interaction with loss/reduction of employment (<i>x</i><sup>2</sup> = 0.46, <i>p</i> = 0.50).
BibTeX
@article{tremblay2024relational,
  author = {Noémie Tremblay and Camille Léger and Frédérique Deslauriers and Lydia Hébert-Auger and Vincent Gosselin Boucher and Simon Bacon and Maximilien V. Dialufuma and Kim Lavoie and for the iCARE Study Team},
  title = {{Relational conflicts during COVID-19: Impact of loss and reduction of employment due to prevention measures and the influence of sex and stress (in the iCARE study)}},
  journal = {Journal of Health Psychology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1177/13591053241260672},
}
Figure