Relating the entanglement spectrum of noninteracting band insulators to their quantum geometry and topology

Markus Legner, Titus NeupertPhysical 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals a deep connection between the "entanglement spectrum" of non-interacting insulators and their fundamental quantum geometric and topological properties. By analyzing a specific type of system partitioning that preserves translational symmetry, the authors demonstrate that topological phases are characterized by a gapless "entanglement Fermi surface," effectively mapping topological stability to entanglement properties.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Classifying topological phases of matter has traditionally relied on identifying topological invariants (like Chern numbers) or observing distinct edge states. While the entanglement spectrum has emerged as a powerful tool for characterizing topological order, its relationship with the underlying quantum geometry of the bulk electronic states, especially for systems preserving translational symmetry, remained less explored. Specifically, the authors investigate how the entanglement spectrum behaves when the system is partitioned in a way that doesn't break its translational symmetry (e.g., by tracing out sublattice degrees of freedom). This leads to the question: can we find a universal signature of topological phases in this "sublattice entanglement spectrum" (SLES), and how does it relate to the geometric properties of the Bloch states?

Methods

The core of the paper involves analyzing the entanglement Hamiltonian ($H_E$), which is derived from the reduced density matrix of a subsystem. For non-interacting fermions, this Hamiltonian is a single-particle operator whose eigenvalues form the entanglement spectrum. The authors focus on a specific type of partitioning called the sublattice entanglement spectrum (SLES), where the partitioning is done by tracing out internal degrees of freedom at each lattice site (like sublattice or spin). This method preserves the full translational symmetry of the system, meaning momentum remains a good quantum number.

A key technique is the use of the correlation matrix ($C_1$), which is directly related to the entanglement Hamiltonian. The authors also leverage the concept of quantum geometry, specifically the Fubini-Study metric on the space of Bloch states. They derive a relationship between the trace of the entanglement spectrum and the quantum distance between projectors representing the occupied bands and the chosen partitioning. This allows them to establish bounds on the quantum geometric tensor.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical models and their properties, not on experimental data or simulated datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Topological Phases as "Entanglement Metals": The paper establishes that nontrivial topological phases in non-interacting insulators are characterized by a gapless SLES, featuring an "entanglement Fermi surface" at zero entanglement energy. This is a significant conceptual shift, mapping the stability of topological phases from energy gaps to entanglement properties.
  • Symmetry Preservation is Key: Partitioning methods that preserve translational symmetry (SLES) are crucial for revealing topological information. Spatial bipartitions, while useful, can introduce discontinuities that obscure these connections.
  • Entanglement Spectrum as a Quantum Distance Measure: The trace of the entanglement spectrum at a given momentum is shown to be directly related to the quantum distance between the occupied Bloch states and the chosen partitioning projector. This provides a novel interpretation of the entanglement spectrum.
  • Geometric Bounds on Entanglement: The Fubini-Study metric, a measure of quantum geometry, provides an upper bound for the momentum derivative of the entanglement eigenvalues. This links the smoothness of the wave function's geometry to the behavior of the entanglement spectrum.
  • Universality in SLES: For Chern insulators, a gapless SLES is a robust indicator of non-trivial topology, regardless of the specific partitioning choice, as long as it's non-trivial. For Z2 topological insulators, the connection is also established, particularly through Kramer's degeneracy.

Key Results

  • For non-interacting band insulators, a nontrivial topological phase (Chern insulator or Z2 topological insulator) implies a gapless sublattice entanglement spectrum (SLES).
  • This gapless SLES is characterized by an "entanglement Fermi surface" where entanglement eigenvalues cross zero.
  • The quantum distance between the occupied bands and the partitioning projector is directly related to the sum of the entanglement eigenvalues.
  • The quantum geometric tensor (Fubini-Study metric) is bounded by quantities derived from the entanglement spectrum, specifically its momentum derivatives.
  • The paper illustrates these findings with concrete examples of the $\pi$-flux model (Chern insulator) and the Kane-Mele model (Z2 topological insulator).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Generalization to Interacting Systems: The current work focuses on non-interacting systems. A significant future direction is to extend these findings to interacting "highly entangled" symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases and phases with intrinsic topological order.
  • Many-Body Metric: The paper primarily deals with single-particle entanglement spectra. Extending the concept of quantum geometry to the many-body metric of the ground state, defined by external control parameters, is highlighted as an important avenue.
  • Experimental Accessibility: While the quantum metric tensor is experimentally accessible (e.g., via optical susceptibility), the direct experimental measurement of the entanglement spectrum remains a challenge. The paper suggests that the derived relations might offer indirect pathways to probe entanglement properties.
  • Arbitrary Partitionings: While the paper focuses on symmetry-preserving partitionings, it acknowledges that not all partitionings reveal topological information, similar to spatial bipartitions. Further exploration of the conditions for meaningful partitionings could be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the entanglement spectrum of noninteracting band insulators, which can be computed from the two-point correlation function, when restricted to one part of the system. In particular, we analyze a type of partitioning of the system that maintains its full translational symmetry, by tracing over a subset of local degrees of freedom, such as sublattice sites or spin orientations. The corresponding single-particle entanglement spectrum is the band structure of an entanglement Hamiltonian in the Brillouin zone. We find that the hallmark of a nontrivial topological phase is a gapless entanglement spectrum with an ``entanglement Fermi surface.'' Furthermore, we derive a relation between the entanglement spectrum and the quantum geometry of Bloch states contained in the Fubini-Study metric. The results are illustrated with lattice models of Chern insulators and ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ topological insulators.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{legner2013relating,
  author = {Markus Legner and Titus Neupert},
  title = {{Relating the entanglement spectrum of noninteracting band insulators to their quantum geometry and topology}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.88.115114},
}
Figure