‘Reinvisiblisation’ of Indian Migrant Labours during/post COVID-19 Pandemic: A Biopolitical Study

R. S. Bali, Isha Malhotra, Anurag KumarSpace 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper examines the "reinvisiblisation" of Indian migrant workers following the COVID-19 pandemic, arguing that while the 2020 lockdown briefly forced their plight into the national spotlight, state power structures have since worked to push them back into the margins. By applying biopolitical frameworks from Foucault, Agamben, and Butler, the authors demonstrate how policy responses often prioritized economic "docility" and utility over the fundamental human rights and social security of the informal labor force.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The authors tackle the structural "invisibility" of the millions of migrant laborers who form the backbone of India’s informal economy. When the Indian government announced a nationwide lockdown on March 24, 2020, with only four hours' notice, it triggered a mass exodus of workers from urban centers back to their rural homes.

The paper addresses the gap between the brief moment of "visibility" these workers gained through viral media coverage of their suffering and the subsequent "reinvisiblisation" by policymakers. The authors argue that the state failed to recognize these workers within "frames of recognition," treating them as disposable "bare life" rather than citizens entitled to protection. This neglect is contrasted sharply with the "Vande Bharat Mission," which utilized state resources to repatriate Indian citizens from abroad while domestic migrants were left to walk hundreds of kilometers.

Methods

This is a qualitative study rooted in critical theory and social science. The authors employ content analysis of selected viral incidents, news reports, and case studies reported during the pandemic.

The "novelty" here lies in the multi-layered theoretical synthesis used to interpret these events:

  • Foucauldian Biopolitics: Using the concept of "docile bodies" to analyze how the state attempts to regulate and discipline the movement of laborers to maintain their economic utility.
  • Agamben’s "State of Exception": Analyzing how emergency laws suspended legal protections, turning roads and quarantine centers into "spaces of exception" where migrant lives were reduced to "bare life."
  • Butler’s "Precarity": Delineating how certain lives are rendered "ungrievable" and exposed to differential levels of violence and death based on class and caste.

Datasets

As a qualitative theoretical study, the paper does not use large-scale quantitative datasets or machine learning benchmarks. Instead, its "data" consists of:

  • Media Artifacts: Viral videos (e.g., a child sleeping on a moving suitcase, a baby trying to wake a dead mother at a railway station).
  • News Reports: Documented incidents like the Aurangabad train accident (where 16 workers were killed while sleeping on tracks) and the Auraiya truck crash.
  • Policy Documents: Analysis of the Atma Nirbhar Bharat package, the Garib Kalyan Rozgar Abhiyaan, and the 2021 draft national migration policy.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Paradox of Visibility: The pandemic didn't create the migrants' problems; it merely exposed the "hyper-precarity" they already lived in. However, once the immediate crisis passed, the state used "inclusive" policy rhetoric to re-establish control, effectively making the workers invisible again.
  • Necropolitics in Action: The authors highlight a "differential value" of human life. The state mobilized aircraft for the middle class (Vande Bharat) but allowed the poor to be sprayed with chemical disinfectants on roadsides, treating their bodies as "trash to be disposed of."
  • Resistance as "Counter-Power": The mass movement of migrants in defiance of lockdown orders is framed as a form of resistance against a disciplinary regime that sought to keep them confined in "spaces they never owned."
  • Docility-Utility Relation: Post-lockdown relief measures are critiqued not as genuine welfare, but as attempts to "restabilize power relations" and ensure a steady supply of compliant, low-cost labor for the neoliberal economy.

Key Results

The paper concludes that the Indian state’s response was characterized by "pandemic precarity." * Qualitative Finding: The "reinvisiblisation" process was successful because the "counter-power" of the media spotlight was temporary. Once restrictions eased, workers were forced back into the same unregulated, precarious conditions they fled. * Policy Critique: The authors find that one-time schemes like the Garib Kalyan Rozgar Abhiyaan were insufficient, as most migrants eventually had to return to urban centers due to a lack of sustainable rural employment. * Structural Failure: The study highlights that despite the 2021 draft national migration policy, significant budget cuts in landmark schemes like MGNREGA (cut by 33% in 2023) signal a continued lack of political will to address migrant welfare.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while the discourse on migrant labor received unprecedented attention, it failed to translate into long-term structural change.

Future Directions suggested: * Immobility Infrastructure: The need for a "setup and mechanisms" that can support workers when the primary "mobility infrastructure" (transportation, jobs) fails during a crisis. * Labor Reform: Moving beyond one-time cash transfers toward implementing long-pending labor reforms that provide social security, minimum wages, and the Right to Education for migrants' children. * Centralized Databases: The paper emphasizes the urgent need for a central database to track migration patterns and ensure that "inclusive" policies actually reach the intended recipients.

Summary updated

Abstract

The paper unravels the ‘reinvisiblisation’ of the Indian migrant labours, who underwent mass exodus because of the lockdown imposed during the COVID-19 pandemic that brought to light their ‘invisibility’ to Indian planners and policymakers. The research qualitatively analyses the selected incidents to elucidate upon their precarious experiences unique to the pandemic. It employs the Foucauldian theoretical framework of docile bodies to understand the workings of biopower in disciplining the body of migrant labours to maintain their docility and utility even amidst the pandemic. The study further employs Judith Butler’s concept of precarious lives to delineate how migrant workers and labours were exposed to violence, injury, and death on their way back home. The research lays bare the attempts of the disciplinary regime to render them docile in the guise of assistance and ‘inclusive’ policy changes and concludes by suggesting serious changes in policy measures and alternatives to avoid such crises in the future.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bali2024reinvisiblisation,
  author = {R. S. Bali and Isha Malhotra and Anurag Kumar},
  title = {{‘Reinvisiblisation’ of Indian Migrant Labours during/post COVID-19 Pandemic: A Biopolitical Study}},
  booktitle = {Space},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.20896/saci.v12i1.1402},
}
Figure