Introduction
Argument mining aims to automatically extract the structure of arguments from natural language. A fundamental sub-task is Argument Component Detection (ACD), which involves classifying text segments—typically clauses—into categories such as claims, premises, or background information. A significant challenge in ACD is that clauses are often ambiguous when viewed in isolation; their argumentative role is frequently determined by the surrounding context. While human annotators naturally leverage this context, traditional automated methods often treat clauses as independent data points, neglecting the sequential dependencies inherent in argumentation.
Reinforcement Learning Framework
To address the limitations of independent classification, this research introduces a Reinforcement Learning (RL) framework that treats ACD as a sequential decision-making problem. The task is modeled as a Markov Decision Process (MDP) defined by:
- State: A feature vector representing the current clause, significantly enhanced by Historical Annotations (HAs). These HAs include labels assigned to surrounding clauses in the previous pass (Type-L) and preceding clauses in the current pass (Type-C).
- Action: Assigning an argumentative label (e.g., claim, premise) to the current clause.
- Reward: A feedback signal based on the alignment with human-annotated "gold standards."
The researchers utilized Least Square Policy Iteration (LSPI) to solve the MDP. LSPI was selected for its data efficiency and low computational overhead, making it particularly suitable for the relatively small datasets common in argument mining.
Experimental Setup and Datasets
The model was evaluated on two distinct corpora:
- Hotel Reviews Corpus: A novel dataset of 200 TripAdvisor reviews, annotated into six categories including major claims, recommendations, and background.
- Persuasive Essays Corpus: A benchmark dataset containing 402 essays categorized into major claims, claims, and premises.
Results and Key Insights
The integration of HAs proved to be a powerful, low-cost method for capturing logical flow. Experimental results demonstrate that the HA-augmented RL model significantly outperforms both "plain" RL and state-of-the-art supervised learning (SL) baselines like SVM and SVM-HMM.
Key findings include:
- Performance Gains: The HA-augmented RL model achieved an accuracy boost of up to 17.85% over plain RL and outperformed top SL algorithms by up to 11.94%.
- Contextual Sensitivity: The model showed marked improvement in distinguishing between premises and claims, a common point of failure for traditional classifiers.
- Window Size Impact: The effectiveness of the model is closely tied to the size of the HA windows. As shown in the performance surfaces below, increasing the context window generally leads to higher Macro-F1 scores across both datasets.
Interestingly, while plain RL initially underperformed compared to complex SVMs due to the linear nature of the value function, the addition of HAs allowed the RL model to leverage context so effectively that it surpassed the mathematical complexity of the SVM kernels.
Conclusion
This work establishes RL as a robust framework for ACD by effectively incorporating sequential context through Historical Annotations. Future research may explore Deep Reinforcement Learning to enhance the model's expressiveness and investigate the inclusion of broader contextual features, such as the linguistic properties of neighboring clauses, to further refine argument structure extraction.
Summary updated