Rehabilitation of high upper limb amputees after Targeted Muscle Reinnervation

Agnes Sturma, Tanja Stamm, Laura A. Hruby, Birgit Bischof, Stefan Salminger, Clemens Gstoettner, Cosima Prahm, Anna Pittermann, Robert Wakolbinger, Christian Höfer, Dario Farina, Oskar C. AszmannJournal of Hand Therapy 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper addresses the critical need for a standardized rehabilitation protocol for individuals with high upper limb amputations who have undergone Targeted Muscle Reinnervation (TMR). By combining a literature review with a Delphi study involving European experts, the authors developed a comprehensive 16-step protocol designed to guide clinicians through the entire rehabilitation process, from pre-surgery to post-discharge. This work is crucial for optimizing prosthetic control and improving functional outcomes for this patient population.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Targeted Muscle Reinnervation (TMR) is a revolutionary surgical technique that allows individuals with high upper limb amputations (e.g., above-elbow or shoulder disarticulation) to intuitively control advanced prosthetic arms. TMR works by rerouting residual nerves that once controlled the lost limb to reinnervate muscles in the residual limb or trunk. These reinnervated muscles then act as biological amplifiers, generating electromyographic (EMG) signals that can be used to control multiple degrees of freedom in a prosthetic device. While TMR significantly enhances prosthetic control capabilities, it also introduces a higher cognitive burden for the user due to the increased number of control signals.

Despite the growing adoption of TMR, there has been a notable lack of evidence-based, structured rehabilitation protocols. Existing protocols, often based on older TMR techniques with fewer control signals, are not fully equipped to handle the complexities of modern TMR. Furthermore, variations in prosthetic control algorithms (e.g., direct control vs. pattern recognition) between regions like the US and Europe add another layer of complexity to rehabilitation. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a comprehensive, expert-validated rehabilitation protocol that covers all phases of the TMR journey.

Methods

The study employed a two-pronged approach:

  1. Scoping Literature Review: A comprehensive review of existing literature was conducted to identify studies related to TMR and upper limb prosthetic rehabilitation. The review focused on publications from 2000 onwards, excluding those primarily focused on pattern recognition, lower limb rehabilitation, or phantom limb pain. This review provided a foundation for understanding current practices and identifying areas for improvement.
  2. Delphi Study: A web-based, three-round Delphi exercise was conducted with European clinicians and researchers specializing in upper limb prosthetic rehabilitation.
  3. Round 1: Experts reviewed the literature summary and proposed rehabilitation steps based on their clinical experience and evidence.
  4. Round 2: The proposed steps were refined based on expert feedback.
  5. Round 3: Experts rated the importance of each step on a scale of 0-10. Steps rated below 5 were excluded.

This methodology allowed for the aggregation of expert consensus and the development of practical, evidence-informed recommendations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on existing literature and expert opinion rather than specific datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Holistic, Multidisciplinary Approach is Paramount: The protocol emphasizes that successful TMR rehabilitation requires seamless collaboration among a multidisciplinary team (surgeons, therapists, prosthetists, psychologists, etc.) and a patient-centered approach.
  • Early Intervention and Patient Education are Crucial: Rehabilitation should commence before surgery, with thorough patient education about the procedure, expectations, and commitment required. This ensures informed decision-making and active patient participation.
  • Structured Milestones Guide Progress: The protocol defines key milestones (surgery, first volitional motor activity, prosthetic fitting, discharge) that delineate distinct stages of rehabilitation, providing a clear roadmap for both clinicians and patients.
  • EMG Biofeedback is the Cornerstone of Training: The study highlights EMG biofeedback as the most critical component of rehabilitation, enabling precise visualization and training of voluntary muscle activation, which is essential for intuitive prosthetic control.
  • Beyond Basic Control: Functional Integration: The protocol extends beyond basic prosthetic control training to include activities of daily living and emphasizes the importance of ongoing follow-up to prevent prosthetic abandonment.

Key Results

The Delphi exercise resulted in a consensus-based rehabilitation protocol comprising:

  • Two Overarching Principles:
    1. Good collaboration within the multidisciplinary team.
  • Selection of the right patient and patient education within the full team.
  • 16 Important Steps: These steps are categorized into stages from "Before Surgery" (Stage 0) to "Discharge from Rehabilitation" (Stage 4).
  • High Importance Ratings: Several steps received very high importance ratings (mean > 9), including:
  • MyoTraining (EMG biofeedback) (mean 9.7 ± 0.6)
    • MyoTesting (defining electrode positions) (mean 9.5 ± 0.9)
    • Regular training with the prosthesis after final fitting (mean 9.5 ± 0.8)
    • Table-top prosthesis training (mean 9.2 ± 1.0)
    • Facilitation of the reinnervation process (motor imagery, mirror therapy) (mean 9.1 ± 1.0)

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Small Expert Sample Size: The number of participating experts (13) was relatively small, which could limit the generalizability of the findings.
  • Potential for Selection Bias: The snowball principle used for recruitment might have led to a selection bias, as experts may have already discussed and agreed on certain aspects prior to the study.
  • Limited Controlled Studies: The scarcity of controlled studies on prosthetic rehabilitation meant that recommendations were largely based on expert experience rather than robust scientific evidence.

Future work should focus on:

  • Recruiting a Larger and More Diverse Expert Pool: Utilizing international societies or conferences could yield a broader range of opinions.
  • Conducting Controlled Studies: Rigorous research is needed to further evaluate the effectiveness of the proposed rehabilitation protocol and its individual components.
  • Adapting Protocols for Different Control Systems: While this protocol focuses on direct control, further research is needed to adapt it for pattern recognition systems.
  • Investigating Clinical Outcomes: Future studies should aim to further investigate the clinical outcomes of patients following this protocol to refine therapists' practices.

Summary updated

Abstract

Low.
BibTeX
@article{sturma2020rehabilitation,
  author = {Agnes Sturma and Tanja Stamm and Laura A. Hruby and Birgit Bischof and Stefan Salminger and Clemens Gstoettner and Cosima Prahm and Anna Pittermann and Robert Wakolbinger and Christian Höfer and Dario Farina and Oskar C. Aszmann},
  title = {{Rehabilitation of high upper limb amputees after Targeted Muscle Reinnervation}},
  journal = {Journal of Hand Therapy},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jht.2020.10.002},
}
Figure