Regularized Policy Iteration

Amir Massoud Farahmand, Mohammad Ghavamzadeh, Csaba Szepesvári, Shie MannorNeurIPS 2008 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces $L^2$-regularization to two foundational reinforcement learning (RL) algorithms: Bellman Residual Minimization (BRM) and Least-Squares Temporal Difference (LSTD). By applying non-parametric methods within a Reproducing Kernel Hilbert Space (RKHS), the authors prove that RL can achieve the same "optimal" convergence rates as supervised regression. This effectively demonstrates that learning a control policy is not theoretically harder than standard function estimation.

The Challenge of Function Approximation in RL

In reinforcement learning, if the "state space" (the environment the agent interacts with) is large or infinite, we cannot simply store a value for every possible situation in a lookup table. Instead, we must rely on function approximation to estimate the value of states we haven't explicitly visited.

The primary challenge is choosing the right "capacity" or "shape" for this approximation. If the approximation is too simple, the agent learns a poor policy; if it is too complex, the agent "overfits" to its limited experience. The authors tackle the need for adaptive methods—algorithms that automatically adjust their complexity based on the training data and the inherent smoothness of the underlying problem, rather than relying on manual trial-and-error.

Methods: Regularized Policy Evaluation

The authors build upon the standard Fitted Policy Iteration framework, where an agent iteratively evaluates its current policy and then acts greedily with respect to that evaluation to form a new policy.

Fitted Policy Q-Iteration Framework

To perform the policy evaluation (PEval) step robustly, the authors propose two new algorithms: REG-BRM (Regularized Bellman Residual Minimization) and REG-LSTD (Regularized Least-Squares Temporal Difference).

Geometric interpretation of BRM vs. LSTD

As shown in the geometric interpretation above, BRM and LSTD take different approaches to minimizing the Bellman error. To enhance these methods, the authors introduce several key mathematical innovations:

  1. $L^2$-Regularization: They add a penalty term to the standard BRM and LSTD loss functions. Similar to Ridge regression in supervised learning, this penalty discourages the model from becoming overly complex.
  2. RKHS Framework: They implement these algorithms using Reproducing Kernel Hilbert Spaces (RKHS). This allows the use of "kernels" (like the popular RBF kernel) to represent highly flexible, non-parametric functions.
  3. Closed-Form Solutions: Using the Representer Theorem, the authors derive exact mathematical solutions for the optimal weights of their kernel-based models, ensuring the algorithms remain computationally efficient.
  4. Nested Optimization: Because policy evaluation in RL often involves a "projection" step (mapping a function back into a manageable space, as seen in LSTD), the authors formulate these as nested optimization problems to ensure regularization is applied correctly at each stage.

Key Insights and Theoretical Results

This paper is primarily theoretical, focusing on proving the mathematical properties and convergence bounds of the proposed algorithms rather than empirical benchmarks.

  • RL is as "Easy" as Regression: A major open question in the field was whether RL is fundamentally harder than supervised learning. This paper suggests that, from a convergence rate perspective, it isn't. With the right regularization, RL converges at the same rate as a standard regression problem.
  • Optimal Convergence Rates: The authors prove that their algorithms achieve a convergence rate of $O(n^{-k/(2k+d)})$, where $n$ is the number of samples, $k$ is the smoothness of the function (belonging to a Sobolev space of order $k$), and $d$ is the dimension of the state space. This matches the theoretically "optimal" rate for regression.
  • Finite-Sample Bounds: Unlike many RL papers that only analyze asymptotic behavior (as data goes to infinity), this paper provides bounds for a finite number of samples. This gives researchers a concrete understanding of how much data is needed to reach a specific performance threshold.
  • Regularization vs. Sparsification: The authors highlight that while previous works used "sparsification" (picking a subset of data points to simplify the model), their method uses "regularization" (optimizing the error and penalty jointly). They argue this is a more principled approach to handling generalization error.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Hyperparameter Tuning: Algorithm performance depends heavily on choosing the right regularization coefficients ($\lambda$). While cross-validation is a solution, it adds computational overhead.
  • I.I.D. Assumption: The theoretical proofs assume that data samples are independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.). In real-world RL, data usually comes from a single, highly correlated trajectory. Extending these proofs to non-i.i.d. data remains a technical hurdle.
  • Continuous Actions: The current framework is designed for environments with a finite number of possible actions. Extending this to continuous action spaces is noted as a major future challenge.
  • $L^1$ Regularization: The authors suggest that moving from $L^2$ to $L^1$ regularization (similar to Lasso) could help the model automatically ignore irrelevant features in very high-dimensional problems.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper we consider approximate policy-iteration-based reinforcement learning algorithms. In order to implement a flexible function approximation scheme we propose the use of non-parametric methods with regularization, providing a convenient way to control the complexity of the function approximator. We propose two novel regularized policy iteration algorithms by adding L2-regularization to two widely-used policy evaluation methods: Bellman residual minimization (BRM) and least-squares temporal difference learning (LSTD). We derive efficient implementation for our algorithms when the approximate value-functions belong to a reproducing kernel Hilbert space. We also provide finite-sample performance bounds for our algorithms and show that they are able to achieve optimal rates of convergence under the studied conditions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{farahmand2008regularized,
  author = {Amir Massoud Farahmand and Mohammad Ghavamzadeh and Csaba Szepesvári and Shie Mannor},
  title = {{Regularized Policy Iteration}},
  booktitle = {Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems},
  year = {2008},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=BkEVZ_-OZS},
}
Figure