Regular omega-Languages with an Informative Right Congruence

Dana Angluin, Dana FismanarXiv 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the concept of "informative right congruence" for omega-regular languages, a crucial property for efficient automata learning and minimization. The authors explore subclasses of omega-regular languages that possess this property, establishing new hierarchies of expressiveness and introducing the notion of "respective of the right congruence" to further refine these classes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For finite words, the Myhill-Nerode theorem establishes a powerful connection between the states of a minimal deterministic finite automaton (DFA) and the equivalence classes of a language's right congruence. This relationship is fundamental for automata minimization and learning. However, this direct correspondence breaks down for omega-regular languages (languages of infinite words). Many omega-regular languages have a "trivial" or "uninformative" right congruence, meaning the number of equivalence classes is far smaller than the number of states in a minimal automaton. This lack of informativeness poses a significant challenge for developing efficient algorithms for learning and minimizing omega-automata. The paper aims to identify and characterize subclasses of omega-regular languages where the right congruence is informative, thereby paving the way for more efficient algorithmic approaches.

Methods

The paper builds upon existing theory of omega-automata (Büchi, co-Büchi, Muller, Parity, and Transition-Table) and their expressiveness. The core of their investigation revolves around the concept of the "rightcon automaton," which is an automaton directly constructed from the right congruence of a language. The authors define and analyze classes of languages where this rightcon automaton is isomorphic to a minimal automaton recognizing the language.

Key methodological contributions include:

  • Defining "Informative Right Congruence": A language has an informative right congruence if its rightcon automaton is isomorphic to a minimal automaton accepting the language.
  • Introducing "Respective of the Right Congruence": A novel property that captures a specific behavior of how languages accept periodic words, related to but distinct from non-counting languages.
  • Establishing Hierarchies: The paper systematically defines and proves inclusion relationships between various classes of omega-regular languages based on these properties (e.g., IB, IC, IP, IM, IT for languages with informative right congruences, and RB, RC, RP, RM, RT for those also respective of their right congruence).
  • Theoretical Analysis: The proofs rely on constructing automata, analyzing their properties (like SCCs and acceptance conditions), and demonstrating strict inclusions between defined classes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical characterizations and properties of language classes rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Right Congruence is Not Enough for Omega-Languages: The paper strongly reiterates that the direct Myhill-Nerode theorem's power for finite words does not translate to omega-languages, highlighting the need for specialized approaches.
  • Weak Regular Languages are a Starting Point: The class of weak regular w-languages (intersection of Büchi and co-Büchi deterministic classes) is identified as having informative right congruences, serving as a baseline for exploring more expressive classes.
  • "Respective of the Right Congruence" is a New Angle: This property, while related to non-counting languages, offers a distinct perspective on how languages handle periodic inputs, providing a new dimension for classification.
  • Hierarchies of Expressiveness: The paper meticulously maps out inclusion relationships between different classes of omega-regular languages, revealing a complex landscape of expressiveness based on the informativeness and "respectiveness" of their right congruences.
  • Informative Right Congruences Exist Widely: Despite the challenges, the paper shows that languages with informative right congruences can be found across the entire Wagner hierarchy of omega-regular languages, suggesting that these properties are not confined to the simplest cases.

Key Results

  • Characterization of Trivial Right Congruence: Proposition 4 provides a full characterization of regular w-languages with a trivial rightcon automaton: $L = \Sigma^* (R_1^\omega + R_2^\omega + ...
  • R_k^\omega)$ for some regular languages $R_1, ..., R_k$.
  • Strict Inclusions: The paper proves several strict inclusions between classes of languages, such as $DB \cap DC \subset IM$, $IB \cup IC \subset IM$, and $IP \subset IM$.
  • "Respective" Property is a Restriction: The classes of languages that are "respective of their right congruence" (RB, RC, etc.) are shown to be strict subclasses of their counterparts with just informative right congruences (IB, IC, etc.).
  • Non-Closure Results: Several classes of languages are shown to be not closed under Boolean operations like union, intersection, or complementation, which is a significant finding for understanding their structural properties. For instance, $DB \cap DC$ is closed under these operations, but many other defined classes are not.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Limitations: The "small experiment" on randomly generated Muller automata to assess the prevalence of informative right congruences is acknowledged as preliminary. The authors suggest a more careful study is needed.
  • Proof Omissions: Due to space constraints, some proofs are omitted and deferred to a full version of the paper.
  • Future Research Directions: The authors express hope that their findings will aid in developing more efficient minimization and learning algorithms for regular omega-languages. They also suggest further research into the learnability implications of these properties and the broader context of non-closure results under Boolean operations. The paper explicitly mentions that the full definition of the Wagner Hierarchy is not included for brevity, referring readers to other works.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{angluin2018regular,
  author = {Dana Angluin and Dana Fisman},
  title = {{Regular omega-Languages with an Informative Right Congruence}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.4204/eptcs.277.19},
}
Figure