TL;DR
This paper introduces Regular Decision Processes (RDPs), a novel model for decision-making in domains where past events, not just the current state, influence future outcomes. RDPs offer a more expressive and compact way to represent these non-Markovian dynamics than existing methods, bridging the gap between standard Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) and more complex Partially Observable MDPs (POMDPs).
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Many real-world decision-making scenarios, from robotics to everyday life, defy the "Markov assumption" – the idea that the future depends only on the present state. For instance, a car's likelihood of skidding depends not just on its current speed but also on whether it recently rained. Similarly, a robot might only be rewarded for delivering coffee if its owner previously requested it. While these non-Markovian dynamics are common, standard MDPs struggle to capture them efficiently. Existing solutions, like extending the state space to include historical information or using k-order MDPs, can lead to exponentially larger models or are limited in their ability to represent arbitrary past dependencies. This paper aims to provide a more elegant and practical framework for modeling and solving such non-Markovian problems.
Methods
The core contribution is the introduction of Regular Decision Processes (RDPs). RDPs are a type of Non-Markovian Decision Process (NMDP) where transition and reward functions are specified using formulas from Linear Dynamic Logic over finite traces (LDLf). LDLf is a logic that can express complex dependencies on the entire history of states and actions, with expressive power equivalent to regular expressions. This allows for compact and intuitive specification of non-Markovian behavior.
The paper also details how to transform RDPs into equivalent Markov Decision Processes (MDPs). This is achieved by constructing deterministic finite automata (DFAs) for each LDLf formula used in the RDP's specification. The states of the resulting MDP then encode both the RDP's state and the current states of these DFAs, effectively "unrolling" the history-dependent logic into a standard Markovian framework. This transformation allows existing MDP solvers to be applied to RDPs.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Bridging the Gap: RDPs elegantly bridge the gap between standard MDPs (which assume full observability and Markovian dynamics) and POMDPs (which handle partial observability but can be computationally intractable). RDPs focus on non-Markovian dynamics while still assuming full observability of the state.
- Expressiveness of LDLf: The use of LDLf is a key innovation, allowing for concise representation of complex temporal dependencies on arbitrary past histories, a capability lacking in simpler models like k-order MDPs.
- Automata-Based Transformation: The transformation of RDPs into MDPs via DFAs is a powerful technique. It leverages existing automata theory and MDP solving algorithms, making RDPs practically solvable.
- Approximation of POMDPs: RDPs can approximate POMDPs without needing to postulate hidden variables, making them a promising direction for learning in partially observable environments.
- Regular Policies: The paper proves that every RDP has an optimal policy that is "regular," meaning it can be expressed as a set of pairs of LDLf formulas and actions.
Key Results
- RDPs are introduced as a new model for non-Markovian domains, generalizing MDPs and k-order MDPs.
- A method is presented to transform any RDP into an equivalent MDP, enabling the use of existing MDP solvers.
- The paper shows that for any infinite horizon discounted reward POMDP, an RDP can be constructed to e-approximate its optimal policy.
- Solving RDPs is shown to be 2-EXPTIME complete, which is computationally feasible and significantly easier than solving general POMDPs.
- The existence of optimal regular policies for RDPs is proven.
Limitations and Future Work
- Automata Learning Complexity: While RDPs can be learned in principle, the paper acknowledges that automata learning (a crucial step in the learning algorithm) can be a difficult problem with significant sample complexity challenges, especially without positive and negative instances.
- Approximation Strategies: Future work is suggested in finding more effective strategies for generating approximate RDPs and bounding their size. This would further enhance their utility for approximating POMDPs.
- Practical RDP Learning: Developing practical algorithms for learning RDPs from data is highlighted as a key area for future research.
- Bounded Horizon RDPs: The complexity of solving RDPs with bounded horizons is noted as an area that could be easier than the general case and warrants further investigation.
Summary updated