TL;DR
This paper introduces novel algorithms for regression that leverage "ordinal information" (pairwise comparisons or rankings) alongside traditional labeled data. This approach effectively combats the "curse of dimensionality," allowing for accurate function estimation in high-dimensional spaces with significantly less labeled data.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In many real-world scenarios, obtaining precise numerical labels for data points is expensive or difficult. However, humans are often adept at making relative judgments, such as comparing two items and stating which is "better" or "larger." This paper tackles the challenge of building regression models that can effectively utilize this cheaper, more abundant "ordinal information" (rankings or pairwise comparisons) to supplement a limited amount of traditional labeled data. The core problem is to understand how much ordinal information can help, and to develop algorithms that can exploit it to overcome the curse of dimensionality, where traditional methods struggle in high-dimensional spaces due to the exponential increase in data required.
Methods
The paper proposes two main algorithmic frameworks:
- Ranking-Regression (R²): For nonparametric regression, R² first uses ordinal information (either perfect or noisy rankings) to order unlabeled data points. Then, it applies isotonic regression to the limited labeled data to "denoise" and borrow statistical strength. Finally, it imputes function values for unlabeled points based on their position in the ranked sequence and the de-noised labeled points. This approach is designed to be robust to noise in the rankings.
- Comparison Linear Regression (CLR): For linear regression, CLR transforms pairwise comparisons into a classification problem. It then uses an active linear classification algorithm to estimate a normalized weight vector. This estimated vector, along with actual label queries, is used to estimate the norm of the true weight vector, yielding the final regression estimate. This method leverages the structure of linear models and existing classification algorithms.
The paper also provides theoretical guarantees in the form of minimax lower bounds, establishing the optimality of their proposed algorithms in various settings.
Datasets
The paper uses the following datasets for evaluation:
- Simulated Data: Synthetic datasets are generated for both nonparametric and linear regression to verify theoretical results and study the impact of varying noise levels in labels and rankings.
- APPA-REAL Dataset: This dataset, containing images with biological and apparent ages, is used for age prediction. Ordinal information is synthesized from apparent ages, while biological ages serve as direct labels.
- AirBnB Listing Prices Dataset: A newly curated dataset from Amazon Mechanical Turk is used to estimate rental property asking prices. This dataset includes both direct price labels and pairwise comparisons of listing prices.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Ordinal Information as a Dimensionality Reducer: The most striking insight is that high-quality ordinal information can effectively "escape the curse of dimensionality." With sufficient rankings, the number of labeled samples required for accurate nonparametric regression becomes independent of the input dimension.
- Robustness to Noise: The R² algorithm demonstrates significant robustness to noise in the ranking data, gracefully degrading performance as noise increases.
- Complementary Strengths: Ordinal information (comparisons) and direct labels have complementary strengths. Comparisons are often cheaper to obtain and can provide information about multiple data points indirectly, while direct labels offer precise values. Combining them leads to better overall performance.
- Linearity Simplifies Comparison Analysis: For linear regression, pairwise comparisons translate into constraints on model parameters, allowing for a more direct conversion to classification problems and leveraging existing powerful classification algorithms.
Key Results
- Nonparametric Regression: The R² algorithm achieves near-optimal rates, with MSE bounds that improve significantly with ordinal information, becoming independent of dimensionality when rankings are perfect or have bounded noise. For instance, the MSE can be bounded by $O(m^{-2/3} + n^{-2s/d})$ with perfect rankings, where $m$ is labeled samples and $n$ is ranked samples.
- Linear Regression: CLR achieves optimal rates for linear regression, with label complexity independent of dimension when sufficient comparisons are available. The MSE can be $O(1/m + \exp(-n/d))$ with enough comparisons.
- Empirical Validation: Experiments on simulated and real-world datasets (age prediction, AirBnB pricing) consistently show that algorithms combining ordinal and direct supervision outperform methods relying solely on direct labels, especially under budget constraints or when labels are expensive. For example, R² with comparisons provided a significant performance boost in AirBnB price estimation.
Limitations and Future Work
- Hölder Exponent > 1: The theoretical analysis for nonparametric regression primarily focuses on Hölder functions with exponents $s < 1$. Extending results to $s > 1$ is a direction for future work, as current algorithms might be sub-optimal in this regime.
- Active Acquisition of Both Data Types: While the paper considers active learning for linear regression, a more comprehensive study of actively acquiring both direct labels and ordinal information simultaneously is suggested.
- Noisy Comparison Models: The paper primarily considers bounded noise models for pairwise comparisons. Exploring other noise models, such as Tsybakov-like noise, and developing computationally efficient aggregation algorithms for them is an open problem.
- Partial Orders: The current work focuses on total rankings or pairwise comparisons. Extending the framework to handle partial orders, where only subsets of data are ranked, is a promising avenue.
- Other Comparison Models: Investigating alternative pairwise comparison models beyond the standard ones, like Plackett-Luce or Thurstone models, could offer further insights.
Summary updated