Regionalisation and cross-region integration. Twin dynamics in the automotive international trade networks

Margherita Russo, Fabrizio Alboni, Jorge Carreto Sanginés, Manlio De Domenico, Giuseppe Mangioni, Simone Righi, Annamaria SimonazziStructural 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses a novel multilayer network analysis to map the evolution of global automotive trade networks over 25 years. It reveals a dynamic interplay of regionalization (countries forming tighter trade blocs) and cross-region integration (increasing trade between these blocs), driven by factors like trade agreements and the rise of China. This provides a crucial benchmark for understanding the industry's ongoing transformation, especially with the shift to electric vehicles.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The automotive industry is a prime example of a global value chain, but understanding its complex, interconnected trade flows has been challenging. Previous studies often focused on geographical regions or aggregated product categories, missing the nuanced dynamics of how specific countries and components interact. This paper aims to fill this gap by analyzing the evolution of international trade networks for automotive parts and components over 25 years (1993-2017). It seeks to identify emergent "meso-scale" entities (clusters of countries and their trade patterns) and understand how these clusters have evolved, highlighting the interplay between regional specialization and broader integration. This is particularly relevant given recent geopolitical shifts, trade policy changes (like USMCA), and the accelerating transition to electric vehicles, all of which are reshaping the industry's global footprint.

Methods

The core methodological innovation is the application of the Infomap multilayer clustering algorithm. This approach moves beyond traditional network analysis by treating trade as a multilayered system. Each country is a "node," and trade flows for specific automotive components and parts (categorized into layers) represent the "interactions." This allows for a more granular analysis than simply looking at aggregate trade or geographical groupings. The algorithm identifies clusters of countries and their associated trade patterns by simulating random walks on this multilayer network, revealing emergent structures. This method allows the authors to:

  • Identify clusters of countries based on recurring trade patterns, not pre-defined geographical regions.
  • Quantify the relative importance of these clusters and the contribution of individual countries and specific components to their formation.
  • Analyze the evolution of these clusters and their interconnections over time.

This multilayer approach is presented as a significant advancement over previous methods that often analyzed trade networks in isolation or relied on simpler aggregation schemes.

Datasets

The study utilizes the UN Comtrade International Trade Statistics Database. The data comprises bilateral export and import flows for 30 specific automotive components and parts (categorized into four groups: Electrical and Electric Parts, Rubber and Metal Parts, Engines and Parts, Miscellaneous Parts) across 42 key trading countries. The analysis covers four specific years: 1993, 2003, 2013, and 2017, using three-year averages for each year to smooth out short-term fluctuations. This dataset, focusing on specific automotive components and parts over a long period, is crucial for the detailed network analysis performed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Regionalization and Cross-Region Integration as Twin Dynamics: The most striking finding is the simultaneous strengthening of regional trade blocs (regionalization) and increasing trade between these blocs (cross-region integration). This challenges a simple "globalization vs. regionalization" dichotomy, suggesting a more complex, intertwined evolution.
  • Emergent Clusters, Not Predefined Regions: The Infomap algorithm reveals trade clusters that don't always align with traditional geographical boundaries, highlighting how trade patterns can create new economic geographies.
  • Germany's EU Dominance and US-NAFTA Dynamics: The analysis clearly shows Germany's central role in a dense, hierarchical cluster with EU countries, and the US's role in a cluster with Canada and Mexico, particularly influenced by trade agreements like NAFTA and its successor.
  • The Rise of China as a Global Force: China's rapid ascent is a significant driver of change, not just within its own emerging cluster but also in its increasing connections to other major blocs.
  • Interconnectedness is Growing: Despite the formation of distinct regional clusters, the connections between these clusters have significantly increased over the 25-year period, indicating a more integrated global automotive trade system.

Key Results

  • Decreasing Number of Clusters, Increasing Dominance of Top Clusters: The number of identified multilayer clusters decreased from 39 in 1993 to 16 by 2003, with the top three clusters becoming increasingly dominant, accounting for 93-97% of the total "Infomap flow" (a measure of cluster importance).
  • Stable Core Clusters: Three main clusters consistently emerged: a Germany-led cluster (primarily EU), a US-led cluster (primarily NAFTA), and a China&Japan-led cluster.
  • Growing Cross-Cluster Connections: The percentage of Infomap flow generated between clusters increased from 18.5% in 1993 to 29.9% in 2017, demonstrating enhanced cross-region integration.
  • Shifting Country Roles: While Germany maintained its central role in its cluster, the US saw its influence within its cluster decline relative to Mexico. China's importance grew substantially, becoming a key player in its own cluster and a significant connector to others.
  • Impact of ICE Components: The study highlights that trade in internal combustion engine (ICE) components, while stable in overall share, saw a decline in within-cluster trade, suggesting a potential vulnerability to the transition to electric vehicles.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Trade Flows: The study primarily analyzes trade flows and does not directly incorporate other crucial factors like production location, technological capabilities, or firm-specific strategies, which are acknowledged as important determinants of trade patterns.
  • Benchmark for Future Analysis: The authors emphasize that their analysis provides a "benchmark" of the trade landscape before the recent major disruptions (COVID-19, geopolitical events, EV transition). This sets the stage for future research to compare this baseline with the post-disruption landscape.
  • Detailed Component Analysis: While the study identifies key components contributing to cross-cluster connections, future work could delve deeper into the specific production structures and trade statistics for ICE components and their electric vehicle replacements.
  • Predictive Limitations: The authors explicitly state their model is not a predictive tool due to the rapid pace of technological, geopolitical, and market changes in the automotive industry. However, the analytical framework can be used to compare future network configurations.

Summary updated

Abstract

The paper analyses the changes that occurred over 25 years in the geography of trade in automotive parts and components. Using the Infomap multilayer clustering algorithm, we identify clusters of countries and their specific trades in the automotive international trade network, we measure the relative importance of each cluster and the interconnections between them, and we analyse the contribution of countries and of trade of components and parts in the clusters. The analysis highlights the formation of denser and more hierarchical networks generated by Germany's trade relations with EU countries and by the US preferential trade agreements with Canada and Mexico, as well as the surge of China. While the relative importance of the main clusters and of some individual countries change significantly, connections between clusters increase over time.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{russo2023regionalisation,
  author = {Margherita Russo and Fabrizio Alboni and Jorge Carreto Sanginés and Manlio De Domenico and Giuseppe Mangioni and Simone Righi and Annamaria Simonazzi},
  title = {{Regionalisation and cross-region integration. Twin dynamics in the automotive international trade networks}},
  booktitle = {Structural},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1016/j.strueco.2023.07.006},
}

Loading related content...

Figure