TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel hybrid fuzzy BWM-TOPSIS method to evaluate regional water resource security, addressing the critical need for robust assessment in China. By integrating fuzzy logic with established decision-making techniques, the method provides a more nuanced understanding of water security by considering both quantity and quality, offering valuable insights for policy and resource management.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Water resource security is a growing global concern, particularly in China, where it acts as a major bottleneck for sustainable development. Existing evaluation methods often struggle to provide a unified conclusion or lack practical feasibility. This paper tackles this challenge by proposing a comprehensive evaluation framework that considers water security from two crucial perspectives: water quantity and water quality. The authors highlight that a sole focus on either aspect is insufficient, as a region might have abundant water but poor quality, or vice-versa, both leading to a state of scarcity. They also introduce novel indicators for water quality security, such as the harmless disposal rate of household garbage, to provide a more holistic assessment.
Methods
The core of this paper is the development of a hybrid fuzzy BWM-TOPSIS method.
- Fuzzy BWM (Best-Worst Method): This technique is used to determine the weights of different indicators. Unlike traditional methods that might assign equal importance, BWM allows decision-makers to express the relative importance of indicators through pairwise comparisons. The authors enhance BWM by incorporating triangular fuzzy linguistic sets. This allows experts to express their judgments using linguistic terms (e.g., "very important") that are then translated into fuzzy numbers, providing a more flexible and accurate representation of subjective preferences.
- TOPSIS (Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution): This multi-criteria decision-making method is used to rank alternatives (in this case, regions) based on their water security levels. TOPSIS works by identifying the positive and negative ideal solutions and then calculating the distance of each alternative from these ideals. The region closest to the positive ideal solution and farthest from the negative ideal solution is considered the best.
The paper integrates these two methods: Fuzzy BWM is used to derive the indicator weights, which are then fed into the TOPSIS framework to rank the regions.
Datasets
The study utilizes data from 2017 for six provinces and cities in North China: Beijing (BJ), Tianjin (TJ), Hebei (HB), Shanxi (SX), Shandong (SD), and Henan (HN). The data sources include:
- China National Bureau of Statistics (for total water resources, per capita water resources, surface and underground water resources, area of provinces/cities, GDP, industrial water consumption, domestic water consumption, waste treatment rates, and pollutant discharge).
- Statistical yearbook of each region (for annual average rainfall).
- 2018 China Environmental Statistical Yearbook (for urban domestic sewage treatment rate).
- 2017 Ecological Environment Bulletin of each region (for excellent water resources proportion and functional water body loss proportion).
No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study relies on publicly available statistical data.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Water Quantity and Quality are Inseparable: The paper strongly emphasizes that a comprehensive water security evaluation must consider both quantity and quality. Ignoring one aspect can lead to flawed conclusions and ineffective policies.
- Fuzzy Logic Enhances Subjectivity: The use of triangular fuzzy linguistic sets in BWM is a key innovation. It acknowledges that expert opinions are often imprecise and allows for a more realistic capture of these nuances, leading to more robust indicator weighting.
- Novel Water Quality Indicators: The inclusion of "harmless disposal rate of household garbage," "excellent water resources proportion," and "functional water body loss proportion" as water quality indicators offers a more complete picture beyond traditional pollution metrics.
- Regional Disparities are Significant: The case study clearly illustrates the vast differences in water security levels across North China, highlighting the need for region-specific strategies.
- Sensitivity Analysis Confirms Robustness: The sensitivity analysis demonstrates that the ranking of regions is relatively stable even when indicator weights are perturbed, suggesting the reliability of the proposed method.
Key Results
The study applied the fuzzy BWM-TOPSIS method to six regions in North China and found:
- Henan Province ranked highest in water resource security, followed by Shanxi Province.
- Tianjin City ranked last, indicating the most severe water security issues.
- The proposed fuzzy BWM-TOPSIS method produced different rankings compared to an equal-weight TOPSIS method, particularly for Shandong and Shanxi provinces, underscoring the importance of weighted indicators.
- A comparison with the Fuzzy BWM-AHP method also showed some shifts in rankings, suggesting that different MCDM approaches can yield varied results, but the proposed method offers a convenient calculation process.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations:
- The study acknowledges that the data used is from 2017, and more recent data could provide a more up-to-date assessment.
- While fuzzy logic is used, the paper suggests exploring more complex fuzzy linguistic environments, such as "hesitant fuzzy linguistic environments" and "type-2 fuzzy environments," for even more nuanced evaluations.
- Future Work:
- The authors propose extending the research to include more complicated fuzzy linguistic environments.
- They also suggest continuously monitoring the latest available data for water resource security evaluation to analyze trend variations and further refine the research.
- The methodology is deemed applicable to other evaluation problems beyond water resources, suggesting its broader utility.
Summary updated