Regional structural-functional connectome coupling is heritable and associated with age, sex and cognitive scores in adults

Zijin Gu, Keith Jamison, Mert R. Sabuncu, Amy KuceyeskibioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how the brain's structural wiring (SC) and functional activity (FC) are coupled at a regional level, revealing that this "SC-FC coupling" is not uniform. They found this coupling varies with age, sex, and cognitive ability, and is significantly heritable, particularly in higher-order brain networks. This work provides a more nuanced understanding of brain organization beyond global measures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While we know the brain's structural connections (white matter tracts, SC) form the basis for its functional activity (how brain regions activate together, FC), the precise relationship between SC and FC at a regional level has been less explored. Most studies look at global SC-FC relationships. This paper aims to fill this gap by quantifying how SC and FC are coupled within specific brain regions and how this regional coupling is influenced by individual differences like age, sex, and cognitive function, as well as its genetic underpinnings. Understanding these regional variations is crucial for a more detailed picture of brain organization and its link to behavior.

Methods

The researchers quantified regional SC-FC coupling by first creating structural connectomes (SC) using diffusion-weighted MRI (dMRI) and functional connectomes (FC) using resting-state fMRI. They then, for each individual region, calculated the Spearman-rank correlation between that region's structural connections to all other regions and its functional connections to all other regions. This yielded a regional SC-FC coupling value for each brain area. To investigate associations with individual differences, they employed a generalized linear model (GLM). Heritability was assessed using a linear mixed-effects (LME) model that accounts for genetic and environmental influences.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the Human Connectome Project (HCP) S1200 release. This dataset includes high-resolution MRI scans (dMRI and resting-state fMRI), demographic information, cognitive scores, and familial relationship data from a large cohort of healthy young adults. The brain was parcellated into 392 regions using the CC400 atlas.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Regional Specificity is Key: SC-FC coupling isn't a one-size-fits-all phenomenon. It varies significantly across different brain regions, with some areas showing strong coupling and others weak.
  • Anatomical Hierarchy Matters: Coupling strength appears to align with the brain's functional hierarchy, being strongest in primary sensory (visual) and subcortical areas, and weaker in higher-order association areas like the limbic and default mode networks.
  • Age and Sex Influence Coupling: As we age, SC-FC coupling changes, increasing in some frontal areas and decreasing in the cerebellum. Males generally exhibit stronger coupling than females, with specific regional differences.
  • Cognition is Linked to Coupling: Higher cognitive performance is associated with specific patterns of SC-FC coupling, such as increased coupling in the insula and decreased coupling in motor control areas.
  • Genetics Play a Major Role: SC-FC coupling is substantially heritable, especially in networks involved in higher-order cognitive functions, suggesting a strong genetic influence on how structure and function align.

Key Results

  • Regional SC-FC coupling ranged from -0.01 to 0.42 across the brain.
  • Visual and subcortical regions showed the highest SC-FC coupling (around 0.24), while limbic and default mode regions had weaker coupling (around 0.11-0.14).
  • SC-FC coupling was highly reproducible, with a test-retest correlation of 0.977 and an out-of-sample correlation of 0.997.
  • Age: Positive associations with age were found in bilateral medial orbito-frontal regions, while negative associations were observed in the cerebellum.
  • Sex: Males generally had higher SC-FC coupling than females, particularly in the right orbito-frontal region. Females showed higher coupling in the right hippocampus.
  • Cognition: Higher composite cognition scores were associated with decreased SC-FC coupling in bilateral middle cingulate and supplementary motor areas, and increased coupling in the right insula.
  • Heritability: Overall heritability of SC-FC coupling was substantial (mean ~0.46), with higher-order networks (dorsal/ventral attention, frontoparietal, default mode) showing the highest heritability (around 0.43-0.46). Limbic and subcortical areas were less heritable (around 0.26-0.30).

Limitations and Future Work

The study's findings are limited to a specific age range (22-37 years), so interpretations regarding age-related changes should be cautious. The authors acknowledge potential limitations in tractography algorithms for accurately reflecting anatomical connections and suggest future work could explore more refined methods. They also note that their heritability estimates are based on kinship and suggest future work could incorporate genotype data for more precise genetic analyses. Additionally, the study used a composite cognitive score, and future research could investigate associations with more specific cognitive abilities. The authors also highlight the need to account for differences in brain region microanatomy and connection types in future SC-FC coupling measures.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Large scale white matter brain connections quantified via the structural connectome (SC) act as the backbone for the flow of functional activation, which can be represented via the functional connectome (FC). Many studies have used statistical analysis or computational modeling techniques to relate SC and FC at a global, whole-brain level. However, relatively few studies have investigated the relationship between individual cortical and subcortical regions’ structural and functional connectivity profiles, here called SC-FC coupling, or how this SC-FC coupling may be heritable or related to age, sex and cognitive abilities. Here, we quantify regional SC-FC coupling in a large group of healthy young adults (22 to 37 years) using diffusion-weighted MRI and resting-state functional MRI data from the Human Connectome Project. We find that while regional SC-FC coupling strengths vary widely across cortical, subcortical and cerebellar regions, they were strongest in highly structurally connected visual and subcortical areas. Additionally, depending on the region, SC-FC coupling varied across sexes and with age and composite cognitive scores. Specifically, SC-FC coupling in the cerebellum tended to decrease with age while coupling in medial fronto-orbital areas tended to increase with age. Males had stronger coupling in many regions, particularly in the right orbito-frontal region and areas in the ventral attention and default mode networks, while females had higher coupling strength in right hippocampus. Furthermore, increased SC-FC coupling in the right insula and decreased coupling in bilateral middle cingulate and supplementary motor areas was associated with higher composite cognitive scores. Finally, we found SC-FC coupling to be highly heritable, particularly in higher order default mode, dorsal/ventral attention and fronto-parietal networks. Taken together, these results suggest regional structure-function coupling in young adults varies with age, is generally stronger in males, is associated with composite cognitive scores and is highly heritable.
BibTeX
@misc{gu2020regional,
  author = {Zijin Gu and Keith Jamison and Mert R. Sabuncu and Amy Kuceyeski},
  title = {{Regional structural-functional connectome coupling is heritable and associated with age, sex and cognitive scores in adults}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.12.09.417725},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure