Regional influences on community structure across the tropical-temperate divide

Alexander E. White, Kushal K. Dey, Dhananjai Mohan, Matthew Stephens, Trevor D. PriceNature Communications 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Many models to explain the differences in the flora and fauna of tropical and temperate regions assume that whole clades are restricted to the tropics. We develop methods to assess the extent to which biotas are geographically discrete, and find that transition zones between regions occupied by tropical-associated or temperate-associated biotas are often narrow, suggesting a role for freezing temperatures in partitioning global biotas. Across the steepest tropical-temperate gradient in the world, that of the Himalaya, bird communities below and above the freezing line are largely populated by different tropical and temperate biotas with links to India and Southeast Asia, or to China respectively. The importance of the freezing line is retained when clades rather than species are considered, reflecting confinement of different clades to one or another climate zone. The reality of the sharp tropical-temperate boundary adds credence to the argument that exceptional species richness in the tropics reflects species accumulation over time, with limited transgressions of species and clades into the temperate.

Introduction

Biogeographers have long debated whether the Earth's biological realms are discrete entities with defined borders or merely arbitrary points on a continuous gradient of species turnover. This question is central to the "tropical-temperate divide." While the tropics are significantly more diverse, it remains unclear if this is due to a gradual decline in species richness as one moves poleward or a fundamental barrier preventing tropical lineages from colonizing colder regions.

Methodology: Ecological Topic Modeling

To address this, researchers adapted Grade of Membership (GoM) models—a "topic modeling" technique typically used in natural language processing. In this framework, a geographic location is treated like a document composed of various "motifs" (biotas), much like a text might be a mixture of different topics. This "soft clustering" approach allows for the identification of transition zones and the degree to which different biotas intermingle, rather than forcing them into rigid categories.

The study utilized global distribution data for over 9,500 bird species, local census data from the Himalayas, and a comprehensive bird phylogeny collapsed into 20-million-year-old (Ma) clades to see if these patterns have deep evolutionary roots.

The Freezing Line as a Hard Wall

The most striking result of the GoM analysis is the sharpness of the tropical-temperate partition. Across various scales of analysis, the transition between tropical and temperate bird communities aligns almost perfectly with the "freezing line"—the geographic boundary where the minimum temperature of the coldest month drops below $0^\circ C$.

Global bird motifs (a, b) compared to the minimum temperature of the coldest month (c), highlighting the alignment of biological boundaries with the freezing line.

In the Himalayas, which represents the world's steepest tropical-temperate gradient, this turnover is exceptionally abrupt. The community shift occurs between 1,200m and 1,800m elevation, precisely where freezing temperatures begin to occur. The study found that moving just 1 km up in elevation in this region results in as much community turnover as moving 5,000 km horizontally, a phenomenon dubbed the "5000:1 Rule."

Deep Evolutionary Roots and Niche Conservatism

The divide persists even when analyzing phylogenetic motifs based on lineages from 20 million years ago. This suggests strong phylogenetic niche conservatism: once a lineage evolves to thrive in tropical conditions, it faces significant physiological barriers to adapting to sub-zero temperatures. Even when tropical species manage to cross the freezing line, their population densities typically plummet, indicating they are merely "existing" rather than "thriving" in the temperate zone. This barrier effectively partitions the tree of life into two distinct worlds.

Conclusion

The reality of a sharp, temperature-dependent boundary between tropical and temperate biotas supports the theory that tropical species richness is a product of long-term accumulation within a stable climate. The inability of many clades to transgress the freezing line has created two distinct biological worlds, partitioned by the fundamental physiological challenge of frost. This research underscores that climate, specifically the limit of freezing, is a primary architect of global biodiversity patterns.

Summary updated

Abstract

Many models to explain the differences in the flora and fauna of tropical and temperate regions assume that whole clades are restricted to the tropics. We develop methods to assess the extent to which biotas are geographically discrete, and find that transition zones between regions occupied by tropical-associated or temperate-associated biotas are often narrow, suggesting a role for freezing temperatures in partitioning global biotas. Across the steepest tropical-temperate gradient in the world, that of the Himalaya, bird communities below and above the freezing line are largely populated by different tropical and temperate biotas with links to India and Southeast Asia, or to China respectively. The importance of the freezing line is retained when clades rather than species are considered, reflecting confinement of different clades to one or another climate zone. The reality of the sharp tropical-temperate boundary adds credence to the argument that exceptional species richness in the tropics reflects species accumulation over time, with limited transgressions of species and clades into the temperate.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{white2019regional,
  author = {Alexander E. White and Kushal K. Dey and Dhananjai Mohan and Matthew Stephens and Trevor D. Price},
  title = {{Regional influences on community structure across the tropical-temperate divide}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-019-10253-6},
}
Figure