Region Detection in Markov Random Fields: Gaussian Case

Ilya Soloveychik, Vahid TarokharXiv 2018 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We consider the problem of model selection in Gaussian Markov fields in the sample deficient scenario. The benchmark information-theoretic results in the case of d-regular graphs require the number of samples to be at least proportional to the logarithm of the number of vertices to allow consistent graph recovery. When the number of samples is less than this amount, reliable detection of all edges is impossible. In many applications, it is more important to learn the distribution of the edge (coupling) parameters over the network than the specific locations of the edges. Assuming that the entire graph can be partitioned into a number of spatial regions with similar edge parameters and reasonably regular boundaries, we develop new information-theoretic sample complexity bounds and show that a bounded number of samples can be sufficient to consistently recover these regions. Finally, we introduce and analyze an efficient region growing algorithm capable of recovering the regions with high accuracy. We show that it is consistent and demonstrate its performance benefits in synthetic simulations.

Introduction

In the study of Gaussian Markov Random Fields (GMRFs), the traditional objective of model selection is the exact recovery of the underlying graph structure—specifically, identifying every edge between vertices. Standard information-theoretic results establish that for a $d$-regular graph with $p$ vertices, the number of samples $n$ must scale at least as $c \log p$ to ensure consistent recovery. However, many modern datasets, such as those found in whole-brain functional imaging, operate in a "sample deficient" regime where $n \ll \log p$. In such scenarios, recovering the exact edge-level topology is mathematically impossible.

This paper proposes a paradigm shift: rather than attempting to recover every individual edge, we focus on identifying spatially contiguous regions characterized by similar connectivity patterns or "coupling parameters." By leveraging the geometric structure of these regions, we demonstrate that it is possible to bypass the logarithmic sample complexity barrier, achieving consistent recovery even with a small, bounded number of samples.

Theoretical Framework and Geometric Priors

The core of this approach lies in the assumption that edges are not distributed randomly but are organized into spatial regions with regular boundaries. To formalize this, the authors utilize Convex Polyominoes (CPMs)—discrete shapes on a lattice that are connected and possess regular boundaries.

Information-Theoretic Bounds

By applying the Large Deviation Principle (LDP) to count the possible configurations of these regions and utilizing Fano’s Inequality, the research establishes new lower bounds for sample complexity. A striking finding is that for region detection, the required number of samples $n$ can actually decrease as the number of vertices $p$ increases. Specifically, the sample complexity scales as $1/p^{2\xi}$, where $\xi$ is a constant representing boundary regularity. This suggests that as the graph density increases, the "local evidence" within a region grows, making the detection of the region's parameters and boundaries more efficient.

The GRID Algorithm

To practically address the region recovery problem, the authors introduce the Greedy Region Detection (GRID) algorithm. The algorithm operates in two primary stages:

  1. Seeding Stage: The graph is overlaid with a coarse lattice. Local coupling parameters are estimated for each cell, and "seeds" are identified—cells that statistically appear to be located deep within a homogeneous region.
  2. Growing Stage: Starting from these seeds, the algorithm greedily incorporates neighboring cells that share similar statistical properties. As the algorithm approaches suspected boundaries, the lattice is refined to improve spatial resolution.

An optimized variant, Convex-GRID, incorporates a "convexification" step. This step fills in gaps and smooths the detected shapes to better align with the physical reality of spatial regions, which typically exhibit regular, non-erratic boundaries.

Experimental Results

The framework was evaluated using synthetic simulations involving a $d$-regular graph ($d=4$) with $p = 20,000$ vertices embedded in a 2x2 square. The square was partitioned into four distinct regions, each with a different coupling parameter ranging from 0.04 to 0.08.

With only $n = 5,000$ samples—a clear sample-deficient scenario relative to the $p=20,000$ vertices—the algorithm demonstrated high accuracy. Performance was measured by the "expected area error," representing the deviation between the detected regions and the ground truth. The Convex-GRID algorithm showed rapid convergence; by the 10th iteration, the area error was reduced from approximately 0.9 to nearly 0.2. These results confirm that the greedy approach can match theoretical lower bounds within a factor of $\sqrt{\log p}$, indicating near-optimal efficiency.

Discussion and Future Directions

The research demonstrates that the bottleneck for learning in GMRFs is not necessarily the number of edges, but the complexity of the boundaries between regions. Smooth boundaries with a high radius of curvature are significantly easier to detect than complex ones.

While the current work provides a robust foundation for 2D Gaussian cases, several avenues for future research remain:

  • 3D Generalization: Extending the GRID machinery to 3D volumes is essential for more accurate modeling of brain activity.
  • Non-Gaussian Distributions: Adapting the framework for Ising models or other discrete distributions would broaden its applicability to social and biological networks.
  • Lattice Alignment: Future iterations must address potential sensitivities to the orientation and alignment of the underlying lattice used for seeding.

In conclusion, by shifting the focus from individual edges to spatial regions, this work provides a path forward for analyzing high-dimensional networks where data is scarce but spatial structure is rich.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the problem of model selection in Gaussian Markov fields in the sample deficient scenario. The benchmark information-theoretic results in the case of d-regular graphs require the number of samples to be at least proportional to the logarithm of the number of vertices to allow consistent graph recovery. When the number of samples is less than this amount, reliable detection of all edges is impossible. In many applications, it is more important to learn the distribution of the edge (coupling) parameters over the network than the specific locations of the edges. Assuming that the entire graph can be partitioned into a number of spatial regions with similar edge parameters and reasonably regular boundaries, we develop new information-theoretic sample complexity bounds and show that a bounded number of samples can be sufficient to consistently recover these regions. Finally, we introduce and analyze an efficient region growing algorithm capable of recovering the regions with high accuracy. We show that it is consistent and demonstrate its performance benefits in synthetic simulations.
BibTeX
@misc{soloveychik2018region,
  author = {Ilya Soloveychik and Vahid Tarokh},
  title = {{Region Detection in Markov Random Fields: Gaussian Case}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1802.03848},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1802.03848},
}

Loading related content...

Figure