TL;DR
This paper tackles the challenge of efficient pathfinding on static grids, a common problem in robotics and games. The authors introduce novel algorithms that significantly reduce preprocessing time and space requirements for goal bounding techniques, while maintaining or even improving online query performance compared to state-of-the-art methods.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Finding the shortest path on a grid is a fundamental problem. Existing methods like Jump Point Search (JPS) and its extensions (JPS+BB, Topping) offer impressive speedups but rely on computationally expensive "all-pairs precomputation" to build auxiliary data structures. This precomputation can take hours and consume gigabytes of memory, making these methods impractical for applications with limited resources. The paper addresses this by proposing methods that achieve similar or better performance with significantly reduced preprocessing costs.
Methods
The core of the paper's contribution lies in reducing the scope of precomputation. Instead of computing goal bounding data for every grid cell, the authors propose doing so only for "independent jump points." This significantly shrinks the dataset.
Key techniques and algorithms introduced or improved include:
- Reduced Precomputation for Goal Bounding: Instead of all-pairs precomputation, Dijkstra searches are performed only from grid cells associated with independent jump points.
- New Algorithms:
- JPS+BB+: An extension of JPS+BB that uses bounding boxes but with the reduced precomputation. It also incorporates new partial expansion and intermediate pruning strategies.
- TOPS (Two-Oracle Pathfinding Search): A search-based algorithm that uses compressed first-move data. It aims to reduce branching factors significantly at each jump point.
- Topping+: An extraction-based algorithm that identifies optimal paths by extracting multiple paths from start successors to the target, similar to Topping but with partial CPDs.
- Canonical Tie-breaking: A strategy to select among equivalent optimal first-moves during preprocessing, which helps reduce data size and improve online performance.
- Partial Expansion and Intermediate Pruning: Enhanced strategies that leverage goal bounding data to further reduce the search space and avoid unnecessary operations.
Datasets
The paper evaluates its algorithms on several benchmark datasets:
- Sturtevant's Repository: Includes datasets like StarCraft, Dragon Age: Origins (DAO), Baldur's Gate II (BG), Warcraft III, Rooms, and Mazes.
- GPPC-2014 Competition Maps: A set of 132 maps, including 105 from games and 27 synthetic benchmarks.
The authors note that their implementations are based on publicly available codes for JPS+BB and SRC.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The Power of "Independent Jump Points": The key insight is that precomputing goal bounding data only for a small subset of "independent jump points" is sufficient to achieve high performance, drastically reducing preprocessing costs.
- Partial Precomputation is Sufficient: The paper demonstrates that a "partial" precomputation, focusing on critical points, can rival or surpass "full" precomputation methods in terms of online performance.
- Canonical Tie-breaking Preserves Optimality: Contrary to some prior suggestions, the authors prove that their canonical tie-breaking strategy for selecting first-moves guarantees optimality and completeness.
- Goal Bounding Enhances Pruning: Integrating goal bounding data with techniques like intermediate pruning can significantly reduce the search space and improve efficiency.
Key Results
The paper reports substantial improvements in preprocessing costs:
- Preprocessing Time and Space: Savings of "orders of magnitude" are achieved for preprocessing time and space compared to existing methods like JPS+BB and Topping. For example, Table 2 shows JPS+BB+ reducing preprocessing time by over an order of magnitude and space by a similar factor compared to JPS+BB.
- Online Performance: The new algorithms (JPS+BB+, TOPS, Topping+) are competitive with and often outperform state-of-the-art methods.
- JPS+BB+ is shown to be up to 30% faster than JPS+BB (as mentioned in the abstract). Table 3 shows significant reductions in query time and heap operations.
- TOPS and Topping+ are comparable to or faster than existing methods, especially when using compressed data. Table 6 shows TOPS and Topping+ achieving competitive query times, sometimes outperforming baselines.
- GPPC-2014 Results: Table 7 and 8 show that the proposed methods (JPS+BB+, TOPS, Topping+) are competitive on the challenging GPPC-2014 benchmarks, with significantly reduced setup times and comparable or improved query times.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations:
- The paper acknowledges that while their methods are significantly faster in preprocessing, some existing methods (like SRC) might still offer slightly better compression for certain datasets, though at a higher preprocessing cost.
- The performance of Topping+ can be slower on "room maps" compared to other methods due to the higher number of CPD calls.
- Future Work:
- The authors suggest exploring the integration of other orthogonal speedup methods, such as symmetry breaking and contraction, with goal bounding.
- Combinations of symmetry breaking, contraction, and goal bounding are seen as promising for further gains, potentially breaking the 1µs threshold for pathfinding on static grids.
- Investigating the interplay between goal bounding and f-value based partial expansion is also mentioned as an interesting direction.
Summary updated