Reflective obstructions of unitary modular varieties

Yota MaedaJournal of Algebra 2022 · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper tackles the problem of determining when unitary modular varieties are of "general type," a key classification in algebraic geometry. The authors provide a quantitative estimate for "reflective obstructions," a crucial component in this classification, showing they become small in higher dimensions. This work connects the study of these varieties to the construction of specific mathematical objects called "cusp forms."

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In algebraic geometry, classifying varieties based on their "Kodaira dimension" is a fundamental pursuit. Varieties of "general type" are considered the most abundant and complex. For certain types of varieties, like those arising from modular forms, determining if they are of general type often involves analyzing "obstructions." These obstructions can be categorized into reflective, cusp, and elliptic types. While elliptic obstructions have been resolved, and cusp obstructions are understood through the existence of cusp forms, the reflective obstructions have remained a challenge, particularly for unitary modular varieties. This paper aims to provide a quantitative understanding of these reflective obstructions, specifically showing they are manageable in higher dimensions, thereby advancing the classification of unitary modular varieties.

Methods

The core of this paper's approach lies in applying Prasad's volume formula to estimate the dimension of spaces of modular forms on ball quotients. This is a standard tool in the field, but its application here is novel. The authors introduce a criterion for when a certain line bundle, denoted $M(a)$, is "big" (a technical term related to geometric complexity), which is directly tied to the magnitude of these reflective obstructions. They then systematically analyze these obstructions by:

  • Decomposing the problem: The analysis is broken down based on the underlying imaginary quadratic field ($F$) and the structure of the Hermitian lattices ($L$).
  • Classifying reflective vectors: A significant portion of the paper is dedicated to classifying "reflective vectors" and their associated "branch divisors," which are the source of the reflective obstructions. This involves detailed case analysis for different types of fields ($F \neq Q(\sqrt{-1}), Q(\sqrt{-3})$, $F = Q(\sqrt{-1})$, $F = Q(\sqrt{-3})$).
  • Using volume formulas: Prasad's volume formula is used to compute the Hirzebruch-Mumford volume of arithmetic subgroups, which is then related to the dimension of spaces of modular forms.
  • Quantitative estimates: The paper focuses on providing explicit, quantitative estimates for these volumes and obstructions, particularly in terms of the dimension of the variety ($n$) and other parameters.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Reflective obstructions shrink in higher dimensions: A central finding is that for unitary modular varieties, the reflective obstructions become "small enough" as the dimension increases (specifically, beyond dimension 138). This is a crucial step towards proving these varieties are of general type.
  • Connection to cusp forms: The study of reflective obstructions is shown to be reducible to the problem of constructing specific "cusp forms" of small weight. This highlights a deep interplay between different aspects of the theory of modular forms.
  • Finiteness conjecture: As a byproduct, the paper formulates and partially proves a conjecture analogous to a known result in the orthogonal case: there are only finitely many Hermitian lattices that admit reflective modular forms. This is a significant structural result.
  • Prasad's volume formula as a key tool: The paper demonstrates the power of Prasad's volume formula in providing quantitative estimates for geometric quantities related to modular forms and varieties, offering a new perspective compared to previous studies.

Key Results

  • Theorem 1.1: For a primitive Hermitian lattice $L$ of signature $(1,n)$ with $n > 2$ and satisfying a specific condition ($\heartsuit$), the line bundle $M(a)$ is big if the dimension of the variety is sufficiently large. This directly addresses the reflective obstructions.
  • Corollary 1.2: For unramified square-free lattices, if the dimension $n > 138$ or if the discriminant is large and $n$ is even, then $M(a)$ is big for any $a > 1$. This provides concrete thresholds.
  • Conjecture 1.6: The set of Hermitian lattices admitting reflective modular forms with a given slope is finite. This is partially proven.
  • Explicit estimates: The paper provides detailed, explicit estimates for the function $V(L, F)$ and $W(L, F, a)$ under various conditions, which are crucial for determining when $M(a)$ is big.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cusp obstructions: While this paper focuses on reflective obstructions, the effectiveness of the cusp obstructions (related to $(n+1-a)L - \Delta$) is not fully resolved. The paper notes that this can be addressed if one can construct a non-zero cusp form of a specific weight, but this construction is not undertaken here.
  • General case for cusp forms: The paper mentions that constructing cusp forms of arbitrary weight is a challenge, and their work relies on the existence of such forms.
  • Specific lattices: While the paper provides general theorems, the explicit application to specific lattices is a direction for future work.
  • Ramified case for $v=2$: The analysis for ramified extensions over $Q_2$ is noted as requiring more detailed calculations, and the paper simplifies this by focusing on unramified cases for $v=2$.

Summary updated

Abstract

To prove that a modular variety is of general type, there are three types of obstructions: reflective, cusp and elliptic obstructions. In this paper, we give a quantitative estimate of the reflective obstructions for the unitary case. This shows in particular that the reflective obstructions are small enough in higher dimension, say greater than $138$. Our result reduces the study of the Kodaira dimension of unitary modular varieties to the construction of a cusp form of small weight in a quantitative manner. As a byproduct, we formulate and partially prove the finiteness of Hermitian lattices admitting reflective modular forms, which is a unitary analog of the conjecture by Gritsenko-Nikulin in the orthogonal case. Our estimate of the reflective obstructions uses Prasad's volume formula.
BibTeX
@article{maeda2022reflective,
  author = {Yota Maeda},
  title = {{Reflective obstructions of unitary modular varieties}},
  journal = {Journal of Algebra},
  year = {2022},
}
Figure