Reference Interval for Pulse Oxygen Saturation in Neonates at Different Altitudes: A Systematic Review

Bo Wang, Jia Zhang, Ya-Zhen Wu, Zhi-Hui Lu, Na Wang, Zhangbin YuFrontiers in Pediatrics 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This systematic review establishes a reference interval for neonatal pulse oxygen saturation (SpO2) at varying altitudes, revealing a crucial downward trend with increasing elevation. This work provides a much-needed tool for accurate hypoxemia diagnosis in high-altitude settings, where standard sea-level thresholds are inadequate.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately assessing oxygenation in newborns is critical for identifying hypoxemia, a condition that can lead to serious health issues. At sea level, a standard reference interval for pulse oxygen saturation (SpO2) exists, with values below 95% often indicating hypoxemia. However, this standard is not applicable at higher altitudes. As altitude increases, atmospheric pressure and the partial pressure of oxygen decrease, naturally leading to lower SpO2 levels in healthy individuals. Without altitude-specific reference intervals, neonates born at higher elevations are at risk of being misdiagnosed with hypoxemia, potentially leading to unnecessary interventions, or conversely, having true hypoxemia missed. This paper addresses the critical gap in knowledge by systematically reviewing existing data to define these altitude-specific reference intervals.

Methods

The researchers conducted a systematic review of published studies using a comprehensive search across multiple databases (PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library, Clinicaltrials.Gov, and several Chinese databases). They adhered to the PRISMA guidelines for systematic reviews. Studies were included if they reported SpO2 in healthy neonates during a stable period (24 hours after birth to discharge), measured using pulse oximetry, and specified the altitude. Studies were excluded if they involved preterm infants, measurements within 24 hours of birth, or lacked crucial data.

The quality of the included studies was assessed using the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) checklist. Data extraction focused on basic study information, participant characteristics, and SpO2 measurements (mean, standard deviation/error).

For data analysis, meta-analysis was not feasible due to variations in study methodologies. Instead, the researchers analyzed pre-ductal and post-ductal SpO2 data separately. They calculated the -2 standard deviation (SD) value for SpO2 at each altitude, which approximates the 2.5th percentile. Using Python v3.8, they performed a third-order polynomial fitting to the -2SD values against altitude to derive predictive equations for the lower limit of the SpO2 reference interval for both pre-ductal and post-ductal measurements. The final lower limit for each altitude was determined by selecting the smaller integer value between the pre- and post-ductal limits.

Datasets

The study did not introduce a new dataset. Instead, it synthesized data from seven existing cross-sectional studies. These studies were conducted in various locations including the US, Mexico, Israel, Ecuador, and China, covering a range of altitudes from 25 to 3,100 meters above sea level. The total sample size across these studies was substantial, with one study alone including over 41,000 neonates.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Altitude is a critical determinant of neonatal SpO2: The most fundamental insight is the clear and consistent decrease in the lower limit of the SpO2 reference interval as altitude increases. This directly challenges the applicability of sea-level norms in higher elevations.
  • Pre-ductal vs. Post-ductal SpO2 matters: The study acknowledges and models differences between pre-ductal and post-ductal SpO2. While the difference in the lower limit was not large, it's important for accurate clinical interpretation, especially in screening contexts.
  • Predictive equations offer a practical solution: The development of polynomial equations to predict the lower limit of SpO2 based on altitude provides a valuable, actionable tool for clinicians in high-altitude regions. This moves beyond simply presenting raw data to offering a method for real-time assessment.
  • The 24-hour mark is crucial for stable SpO2: The exclusion of data from the first 24 hours of life highlights the significant physiological transition occurring in neonates, during which SpO2 levels are unstable and fluctuate considerably. This reinforces the importance of assessing SpO2 in a stable postnatal period.

Key Results

  • Seven cross-sectional studies were included in the review, spanning from 1991 to 2020.
  • These studies covered 40 different altitudes ranging from 25 to 3,100 meters.
  • Three studies were rated as high quality, and four as moderate quality.
  • The study derived predictive equations for the lower limit of SpO2:
  • Pre-ductal SpO2: SpO2 (%) = 7.8 × 10⁻¹⁰ × (H)³ + 2.75 × 10⁻⁶ × (H)² - 0.00486 × (H) + 96.45
    • Post-ductal SpO2: SpO2 (%) = 6.612 × 10⁻¹⁰ × (H)³ + 2.482 × 10⁻⁶ × (H)² - 0.004955 × (H) + 96.86 (where H is altitude in meters)
  • For example, at an altitude of 2,500 meters, the lower limit of the reference interval was determined to be 89% (SpO2 range: 89% < SpO2 ≤ 100%).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Data Distribution: Many studies reported mean ± SD values, and some indicated that SpO2 values exceeding 100% (mean + 2SD) suggested a skewed distribution. Ideally, data would be presented as median and interquartile range for skewed distributions, and the 2.5th percentile directly. The curve-fitting method used to derive the lower limit, while practical, has its own accuracy limitations.
  • Altitude Range: The highest altitude included was 3,100 meters. The accuracy of the prediction equations for altitudes significantly higher than this needs further verification.
  • Data Gaps: For three altitudes, pre-ductal data was unavailable.
  • Variability in Factors: Factors such as season, ethnicity, POX type, and neonatal resting state varied across studies and could influence SpO2 levels. The paper notes that Tibetan infants, for instance, may have higher SpO2 than Han infants at birth, indicating altitude isn't the sole determinant.

Future Work: The authors emphasize the need for high-quality, prospective studies to confirm their findings. Future research should aim to:

  • Include a wider range of altitudes.
  • Ensure data is presented in a way that clearly indicates the 2.5th percentile for skewed distributions.
  • Systematically account for and analyze the impact of various influencing factors (season, ethnicity, POX type, resting state) to refine the predictive models and improve the quality of meta-analyses.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Introduction:</b> The reference interval for pulse oxygen saturation (SpO<sub>2</sub>) in neonates born at high altitudes has not been defined to date. The purpose of this study was to systematically review published studies and determine the reference interval of SpO<sub>2</sub> in neonates at different altitudes. <b>Methods:</b> Databases of PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library, Clinicaltrials.Gov, Chinese National Knowledge Infrastructure Database, Wanfang Database, Chinese Science Technology Journals Database, and Chinese Clinical Trial Registry were searched for studies reporting SpO<sub>2</sub> in healthy neonates at different altitudes. Retrieval time was from inception of the database to August 16, 2021. The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality checklist was used to evaluate the quality of studies. Python v3.8 was used to analyze the data. This systematic review was drafted in accordance with the guidelines of the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) statement. <b>Results:</b> Seven cross-sectional studies, published between 1991 and 2020, were identified. They were from US, Mexico, Israel, Ecuador, and China. Three studies were rated as high quality and four as moderate quality. The mean SpO<sub>2</sub> (with standard deviation or standard error) of neonates born in 40 different altitudes (ranging from 25 meters to 3,100 meters) were obtained. The prediction equation for calculation of the lower limit of the reference interval was established, and the reference intervals for SpO<sub>2</sub> at different altitudes were determined. <b>Conclusions:</b> In healthy neonates, the lower limit of the reference interval of SpO<sub>2</sub> decreases with increase in altitude. High-quality prospective studies are need to confirm our findings.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2021reference,
  author = {Bo Wang and Jia Zhang and Ya-Zhen Wu and Zhi-Hui Lu and Na Wang and Zhangbin Yu},
  title = {{Reference Interval for Pulse Oxygen Saturation in Neonates at Different Altitudes: A Systematic Review}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Pediatrics},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fped.2021.771750},
}
Figure