REEXAMINATION OF ASTROPHYSICAL RESONANCE-REACTION-RATE EQUATIONS FOR AN ISOLATED, NARROW RESONANCE

J. J. He, J. Hu, L. Y. Zhang, L. Li, Shutao Xu, Xiaohan Yu, M. L. LiuInternational Journal of Modern Physics E 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper re-examines the validity of commonly used analytical equations for calculating astrophysical resonance reaction rates (RRRs) for "narrow" resonances. The authors find that these equations, derived under several simplifying assumptions, are only accurate under specific circumstances and can lead to significant underestimations of reaction rates, particularly at low stellar temperatures. They recommend using broader resonance approximations for more reliable calculations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the origin of elements and the processes powering stars requires accurate calculations of nuclear reaction rates in astrophysical environments. A key component of these calculations involves "resonance reactions," where a reaction proceeds through an intermediate excited state (a resonance) in a compound nucleus. For decades, researchers have relied on simplified analytical equations to estimate these resonance reaction rates (RRRs), particularly for "narrow" resonances (where the resonance width is small compared to its energy). However, the authors of this paper question the universal applicability of these analytical formulas, suggesting that the assumptions made in their derivation might not hold true in all relevant astrophysical scenarios, especially at the low temperatures found in many stellar interiors. This could lead to inaccurate predictions of stellar evolution and nucleosynthesis.

Methods

The authors critically re-examine three key assumptions underlying the classical analytical equations for narrow resonance RRRs:

  1. The "FIRST assumption": The Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution function changes negligibly over the resonance region.
  2. The "SECOND assumption": The de Broglie wavelength squared is inversely proportional to the center-of-mass energy, implying the resonance energy dominates.
  3. The "THIRD assumption": The partial widths (proton and gamma) are constant over the resonance region.

They analyze the impact of violating each of these assumptions, particularly focusing on how the energy dependence of the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution (represented by $\delta_{MB}$) and the energy dependence of partial widths affect the calculated rates. To assess the accuracy, they compare the results from the classical analytical equations with numerical integrations of the reaction rate integral, using both narrow and broad resonance approximations. They illustrate their findings with a specific example: the 21Na(p,γ)22Mg reaction.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical re-examination and numerical calculations based on established nuclear physics principles and experimental data for specific resonances.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Narrow" is Relative (and Temperature-Dependent): The definition of a "narrow" resonance (often taken as $\Gamma/E_R < 10\%$) is found to be ambiguous and highly dependent on stellar temperature. At low temperatures, even resonances previously considered "narrow" can exhibit significant variations in the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution across their width, invalidating the assumption of a constant distribution.
  • Analytic Equations Underestimate Rates: The classical analytical equations, which assume constant partial widths and a constant Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution, tend to underestimate the true reaction rates, especially at low stellar temperatures. This is because they fail to capture the contribution from the "low-energy wing" of the resonance, which becomes more significant when the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution is broad.
  • Broad Resonance Approximation is More Robust: The authors suggest that using the broader resonance approximation for calculations, even for resonances that might be classified as "narrow," provides more reliable results, particularly at lower temperatures.
  • Partial Width Dependence Matters: The energy dependence of partial widths, especially the Coulomb barrier penetration factor for charged particles, is crucial. While often assumed constant, this dependence can be significant and further complicates the validity of the narrow resonance approximations.

Key Results

  • For the example reaction 21Na(p,γ)22Mg, at a low temperature of $T_9 = 0.2$ GK, the ratio of numerically calculated RRRs (using a broad resonance formula) to analytically calculated RRRs (using the narrow resonance formula) was as low as $2.4 \times 10^{-7}$ for a full-range integration. This indicates a massive underestimation by the analytical method.
  • Even for a "narrow" resonance with $\Gamma/E_R \approx 2\%$, the $\delta_{MB}$ (variation of the Maxwell-Boltzmann function) could be as high as 59% at $T_9 = 0.1$ GK, demonstrating the breakdown of the narrow resonance assumption.
  • The paper highlights that for resonances with widths of a few keV, the analytical equations can underestimate rates by a considerable amount, even at "Gamow-peak" temperatures.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Ambiguity in "Narrow" Definition: The paper points out the lack of a clear, universally accepted definition for "narrow" vs. "broad" resonances, which contributes to the problem.
  • Questioning Extension to Low Energies: The authors raise a question about the physical appropriateness of extending broad-resonance formulism to very low energies where the resonance and Gamow-peak are far apart, though they do not address this question in the current work.
  • Future Work: The authors strongly suggest that researchers should be more cautious when using classical narrow-resonant equations and recommend employing numerical integration with broad-resonance approximations for more accurate RRR calculations, especially at low stellar temperatures. They believe this re-examination is crucial for improving the accuracy of stellar evolution and nucleosynthesis models.

Summary updated

Abstract

The well-known astrophysical resonant-reaction-rate (RRR) equations for an isolated narrow resonance induced by the charged particles have been reexamined. The validity of those assumptions used in deriving the classical analytic equations has been checked, and found that these analytic equations only hold for certain circumstances. It shows the customary definition of "narrow" is inappropriate or ambiguous in some sense, and it awakes us not to use those analytic equations without caution. As a suggestion, it is better to use the broad-resonance equation to calculate the RRR numerically even for a narrow resonance of a few keV width. The present conclusion may influence some work in which the classical narrow-resonant equations were used for calculating the RRRs, especially at low stellar temperatures for those previously defined "narrow" resonances.
BibTeX
@article{he2011reexamination,
  author = {J. J. He and J. Hu and L. Y. ZHANG and L. LI and Shutao Xu and Xiaohan Yu and M. L. Liu},
  title = {{REEXAMINATION OF ASTROPHYSICAL RESONANCE-REACTION-RATE EQUATIONS FOR AN ISOLATED, NARROW RESONANCE}},
  journal = {International Journal of Modern Physics E},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1142/s0218301311017399},
}

Loading related content...

Figure