Reduction in the Motion Artifacts in Noncontact ECG Measurements Using a Novel Designed Electrode Structure

Jianwen Ding, Yue Tang, Ronghui Chang, Yu Li, Limin Zhang, Feng Yan2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel noncontact ECG electrode design that simultaneously captures ECG signals and motion artifact reference signals. By integrating this with an adaptive filter, the system effectively suppresses motion artifacts in wearable ECG monitoring, achieving a significant improvement in signal-to-noise ratio without requiring additional external sensors.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wearable ECG monitoring offers a comfortable and convenient way to track cardiac health over extended periods. However, a major challenge in noncontact ECG is the significant presence of motion artifacts. These artifacts, caused by the friction and relative movement between the body and the electrodes, can be very similar in frequency to the actual ECG signal, making them difficult to filter out. Traditional methods to combat motion artifacts often rely on external sensors (like accelerometers) or complex software, increasing system complexity and cost. This paper aims to address this by developing a simpler, integrated electrode solution that can effectively reduce motion artifacts in noncontact ECG measurements.

Methods

The core of this work lies in a novel electrode structure designed to capture both the ECG signal and a reference signal highly correlated with motion artifacts. The proposed electrode consists of two types: rectangular ECG electrodes that directly contact the skin (through clothing) and comb-tooth shaped reference electrodes. Both are made of silver conductive fabric and are mounted on a bandage. The key idea is that the comb-tooth shape of the reference electrodes reduces their effective area, minimizing the ECG component while maximizing their sensitivity to triboelectric effects caused by friction. This triboelectric effect, which generates charge variations, is the primary source of motion artifacts.

The system utilizes a dual-channel acquisition setup. One channel captures the ECG signal (d), which is a combination of the true ECG signal (s) and motion artifact noise (n). The second channel captures the reference signal (x) from the reference electrodes. This reference signal is then fed into an adaptive filter. The adaptive filter's goal is to learn the characteristics of the motion artifact noise from the reference signal and then subtract it from the main ECG signal. The paper employs a standard adaptive noise cancellation (ANC) concept, where the filter output (y) is an estimate of the noise, and the error signal (e = d - y) represents the cleaned ECG signal. The effectiveness of this approach hinges on the reference signal (x) being highly correlated with the motion artifact noise (n) but uncorrelated with the true ECG signal (s).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments were conducted using data collected from a volunteer during normal walking conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Integrated Reference Signal: The most significant insight is the ingenious design of the reference electrode. By using a comb-tooth shape and carefully considering its interaction with the skin and clothing, the researchers created a sensor that effectively captures motion-induced electrical noise without significantly picking up the ECG signal itself. This bypasses the need for separate motion sensors.
  • Simplicity and Cost-Effectiveness: The proposed solution is remarkably simple, integrating the noise-capturing mechanism directly into the ECG electrode structure. This avoids the added complexity and cost associated with external sensors like accelerometers.
  • Coherence is Key: The paper emphasizes the importance of the reference signal being highly correlated with the motion artifact. The electrode design, particularly the comb-tooth shape and the use of similar materials and contact surfaces, is crucial for achieving this high correlation.
  • Adaptive Filtering Synergy: The novel electrode design works in tandem with adaptive filtering. The electrode provides a clean and relevant reference signal, allowing the adaptive filter to perform its noise cancellation task much more effectively than if it were fed a less correlated reference.

Key Results

The experimental results demonstrate a significant reduction in motion artifacts.

  • The signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of the ECG signal after noise reduction was 28.44 dB, which is approximately 14 dB higher than the original signal's SNR of 14.26 dB.
  • The filtered output signal closely matched the motion artifact, and the resulting error signal (cleaned ECG) showed significantly reduced artifacts and more prominent ECG waveform characteristics.
  • The system's performance metrics, including system noise, CMRR, and frequency response, met or exceeded relevant standards (IEC 60601-2-47 and ANSI/AAMI EC13).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Optimization of Electrode Size: The authors acknowledge that the size of the electronic board was not heavily optimized, and future work could focus on reducing its size and weight for improved wearability.
  • Housing Design: Designing a protective housing for the electronic components is suggested to enhance durability and enable outdoor testing.
  • Further Testing: While experiments were conducted under normal walking conditions, more extensive testing in various real-world scenarios and with different types of physical activity would be beneficial.
  • Waveform Analysis: The paper suggests that the improved SNR could facilitate more advanced ECG analysis, such as QRS identification and HRV analysis, which could be explored in future research.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{ding2023reduction,
  author = {Jianwen Ding and Yue Tang and Ronghui Chang and Yu Li and Limin Zhang and Feng Yan},
  title = {{Reduction in the Motion Artifacts in Noncontact ECG Measurements Using a Novel Designed Electrode Structure}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/s23020956},
}
Figure