Reducing Spray Drift and Increasing Spreading Effect of the Thifluzamide Through the Use of Adjuvants and Nozzles

Gong Cw, Ying Ma, Liu Yh, Wang Xg, Zhan Xx, Rui Hua Yang, Ruan Yw, Shen Lt, Bo LiAnnals 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how different adjuvants and nozzle types affect spray drift and droplet spread when using Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) for crop protection. The research found that the adjuvant "Maifei" combined with the IDK120-015 nozzle significantly reduced spray drift and deposition, while also lowering the liquid's surface tension, offering a promising strategy for more efficient and environmentally friendly pesticide application.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The widespread adoption of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) for crop protection offers significant advantages in efficiency and precision. However, a major challenge is "spray drift" – the unintended movement of pesticide droplets away from the target area. This drift can lead to reduced pesticide efficacy, potential harm to non-target organisms, environmental contamination, and risks to human health. Traditional methods for mitigating spray drift include using air-induction nozzles or anti-drift adjuvants. This paper aims to systematically evaluate the effectiveness of various adjuvants and nozzle combinations in reducing spray drift and improving droplet deposition, providing crucial data for optimizing UAV spraying practices.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to assess spray performance and drift.

  • Atomization Performance Evaluation: They used a droplet size measurement system to analyze how different adjuvants affected the atomization of the spray liquid. This involved measuring parameters like droplet size distribution (D50, Vol<150μm) and distribution span (S).
  • Wind Tunnel Drift Studies: A specialized wind tunnel was used to simulate aerial spraying conditions. This allowed for the measurement of spray drift distance and deposition. They used a fluorescent tracer (Allura red) to quantify the amount of pesticide deposited on collection surfaces (Mylar and photo paper) at various distances downwind.
  • Surface Tension Measurement: The surface tension of the liquid formulations with and without adjuvants was measured using a ring method to understand how adjuvants alter the liquid's physical properties, which can influence droplet behavior.
  • Spreading Ability Assessment: A qualitative observation was made on how droplets spread on rice leaves when treated with different solutions, providing insight into the wetting and spreading characteristics.

The study compared several commercially available adjuvants (including "Maifei," "Neem oil," and "Transmicelle") against a blank control, and tested four different nozzle types (F110-015, IDK120-015, F110-03, and HCC80-02).

Datasets

The study did not use pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, it generated its own experimental data through controlled laboratory and wind tunnel experiments. The "dataset" consists of measurements of droplet size distribution, drift deposition amounts, drift deposition percentages, and surface tension values collected under various treatment conditions (different adjuvants and nozzles).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Adjuvant Synergy is Key: The most significant finding is the synergistic effect observed between the adjuvant "Maifei" and the air-induction nozzle IDK120-015. This combination proved far more effective at reducing spray drift than either component alone.
  • Surface Tension Matters: Adjuvants demonstrably reduce the surface tension of spray liquids. This reduction is particularly pronounced with "Maifei," suggesting that lower surface tension contributes to better droplet spread and potentially reduced drift.
  • Nozzle Design is Crucial: While adjuvants play a role, the choice of nozzle is a primary determinant of drift. The air-induction nozzle IDK120-015 consistently showed superior drift reduction capabilities across different adjuvants compared to conventional nozzles.
  • Negative Correlation with Drift: The study confirmed a negative correlation between droplet size (D50) and drift distance/deposition. Larger droplets tend to fall faster and are less prone to drifting, which is a principle leveraged by air-induction nozzles.

Key Results

  • Drift Reduction: The combination of the "Maifei" adjuvant and the IDK120-015 nozzle achieved the most significant reduction in spray drift deposition, with the anti-drift effect reaching up to 88.3%.
  • Droplet Size Modification: "Maifei" significantly decreased the percentage of fine droplets (Vol<150μm) and increased the volume median diameter (D50) compared to the blank control.
  • Surface Tension Reduction: "Maifei" was the most effective adjuvant in reducing the surface tension of the spray liquid, lowering it to 29.2 mN/m from a control value of 33.2 mN/m.
  • Nozzle Performance: The IDK120-015 nozzle consistently showed lower drift deposition amounts and a smaller distribution span (S) compared to other tested nozzles.
  • Drift Distance Impact: Drift deposition and percentage of drift decreased significantly with increasing distance from the nozzle, with the 3m distance showing the lowest deposition.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Lab vs. Field: The study was conducted in a controlled wind tunnel environment. While this provides valuable insights, real-world field conditions with varying wind patterns, atmospheric stability, and crop canopy interactions may yield different results.
  • Specific Adjuvants and Nozzles: The study focused on a limited selection of adjuvants and nozzles. Further research could explore a wider range of these components and their interactions.
  • Pesticide Efficacy: While the study focused on drift reduction, it did not directly measure the impact of these combinations on the efficacy of the thifluzamide fungicide itself. Future work could investigate if reduced drift compromises or enhances pest control.
  • Economic Viability: The cost-effectiveness of using specific adjuvants and nozzles in large-scale agricultural operations was not assessed.

The authors suggest that their findings provide a theoretical basis for selecting suitable nozzles and adjuvants for plant protection UAVs, implying that further optimization and field validation are warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Spray drift, as a practical issue during Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) spraying, has a negative impact on the environment, and the use of air-induction nozzles or anti-drift adjuvants are the most common recommendations for reducing drift. To screen the adjuvants for favourable atomization performance and anti-drift effect, we evaluated the spray atomization performance of different adjuvants by the droplet size measurement system. From the wind tunnel results, we commented on the relationship among the atomization performance, drift distance and drift deposition, and determined the drift percentage of different nozzles and the surface tension of liquids with different adjuvants. The results showed that the addition of adjuvants would modify the distribution span S, ΦVol&lt;150μm and the volume medium diameter D50; ΦVol&lt;150μm and D50 of the Maifei treatment decreased and increased the most of all the treatments. There were negative correlations between the drift distance, D50 and percentage of drift amount. The adjuvants Maifei and the nozzle IDK120-015 significantly decreased the drift deposition amount. And the anti-drift effect of nozzle IDK120-015 plus Maifei was significantly stronger than that of other nozzles or adjuvants. In addition, the addition of adjuvants could significantly decrease the surface tension, especially for Maifei. These results suggest that the addition of Maifei is an effective way to reduce the spray drift for all nozzle types and lessen the surface tension. These data help to provide a theoretical basis for selecting suitable nozzles and adjuvants for plant protection UAVs.
BibTeX
@article{cw2021reducing,
  author = {Gong CW and Ying Ma and Liu Yh and Wang XG and Zhan XX and Rui Hua Yang and Ruan YW and Shen LT and Bo Li and Zhan XX},
  title = {{Reducing Spray Drift and Increasing Spreading Effect of the Thifluzamide Through the Use of Adjuvants and Nozzles}},
  journal = {Annals},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.26420/annagriccropsci.2021.1071},
}
Figure