Reducing measles risk in Turkey through social integration of Syrian refugees

Paolo Bosetti, Piero Poletti, Massimo Stella, Bruno Lepri, Stefano Merler, Manlio De DomenicoarXiv 2019 · arXiv

Introduction

Turkey currently hosts approximately 3.5 million Syrian refugees, representing one of the largest displaced populations in the world. While Turkey maintains a robust public health infrastructure with measles immunization coverage near 96%, the Syrian civil war caused a catastrophic collapse in vaccination rates within Syria—plummeting from over 80% to roughly 41% by 2015. This disparity creates a significant "susceptibility gap" within the refugee population.

Public health discourse and popular sentiment often lean toward social segregation—the formation of isolated communities or "ghettos"—under the assumption that keeping migrant populations separate will prevent the "spillover" of infectious diseases into the host population. However, this research challenges that intuition, using computational modeling to demonstrate that social integration is actually a more effective tool for preventing widespread measles outbreaks.

Methodology

To quantify the relationship between social mixing and disease spread, researchers developed a data-driven computational model based on the Susceptible-Infectious-Recovered (SIR) framework, enhanced by a multilayer network approach. The model treats Turkish citizens and Syrian refugees as two distinct but interacting layers.

Data Integration

The model was built using several high-resolution datasets:

  • Mobility Mapping: Call Detailed Records (CDRs) from the "Data for Refugees (D4R) Turkey" challenge (provided by Turk Telekom) were used to map movement patterns across 1,021 Turkish prefectures.
  • Immunization and Demographics: The researchers utilized WHO and UNICEF records to estimate pre-existing immunity and combined this with demographic data from the Turkish Ministry of the Interior.
  • Epidemiological Parameters: Case reports from 2016–2018 outbreaks in Syria provided the basis for estimating the susceptibility of the refugee population.

The Integration Parameter

A central feature of the model is a "tunable parameter" for social integration, ranging from 0% (total segregation) to 100% (full mixing). This allowed the researchers to calculate the "force of infection" by accounting for both endogenous transmission (within a group) and exogenous transmission (between groups), simulating thousands of epidemic trajectories across varying levels of integration and basic reproductive numbers ($R_0$).

Key Insights: The Shielding Effect

The study’s most profound finding is the "shielding effect" provided by a highly immunized host population. When refugees and citizens are socially integrated, the immune Turkish citizens act as biological firewalls, breaking the chains of transmission that would otherwise move rapidly through a susceptible refugee cluster.

Conversely, social segregation acts as a catalyst for epidemics. In segregated scenarios, the virus circulates with high velocity within susceptible refugee enclaves. Once the viral load in these clusters reaches a critical threshold, it eventually spills over into the host population with significantly higher momentum than it would have in an integrated setting.

Results and Discussion

The simulations yielded several critical metrics regarding the benefits of integration:

  • 50% Reduction in Transmission: Moving from a state of full segregation to full integration reduces the effective reproduction number ($R_e$)—the actual rate at which the disease spreads—by nearly 50%.
  • Geographic Containment: In a worst-case segregation scenario ($R_0=18$), a measles outbreak could potentially spread to over 300 prefectures. Under high integration (70%+ mixing), the same outbreak remains geographically bounded, typically affecting fewer than 10 prefectures.
  • Strategic Nodes: The model identified Istanbul, Ankara, and prefectures bordering Syria as "pivotal" nodes. Outbreaks originating in these high-mobility areas are significantly more likely to escalate into national emergencies if social segregation remains high.
  • The Virtuous Cycle: Integration creates a virtuous cycle where the host population’s high immunity provides indirect protection to the incoming population, ultimately reducing the total case count for both groups.

Limitations

While the model provides a compelling case for integration, it relies on several necessary assumptions. Immunity levels were inferred from vaccination coverage rather than direct serological surveys. Additionally, the model assumes homogeneous mixing within prefectures, whereas real-world mixing is often age-dependent (e.g., concentrated in schools). Finally, mobile phone data (CDRs) may not perfectly capture the movements of the very young or the elderly, who are often the most vulnerable to measles.

Conclusion

This research suggests that social inclusion is not only a humanitarian and socio-economic goal but a vital public health strategy. By fostering the social integration of Syrian refugees, Turkey can leverage its high domestic immunity to blunt the impact of potential measles outbreaks, protecting both its citizens and the refugee population more effectively than through segregation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Turkey hosts almost 3.5M refugees and has to face a humanitarian emergency of unprecedented levels. We use mobile phone data to map the mobility patterns of both Turkish and Syrian refugees, and use these patterns to build data-driven computational models for quantifying the risk of epidemics spreading for measles -- a disease having a satisfactory immunization coverage in Turkey but not in Syria, due to the recent civil war -- while accounting for hypothetical policies to integrate the refugees with the Turkish population. Our results provide quantitative evidence that policies to enhance social integration between refugees and the hosting population would reduce the transmission potential of measles by almost 50%, preventing the onset of widespread large epidemics in the country. Our results suggest that social segregation does not hamper but rather boosts potential outbreaks of measles to a greater extent in Syrian refugees but also in Turkish citizens, although to a lesser extent. This is due to the fact that the high immunization coverage of Turkish citizens can shield Syrian refugees from getting exposed to the infection and this in turn reduces potential sources of infection and spillover of cases among Turkish citizens as well, in a virtuous cycle reminiscent of herd immunity.
BibTeX
@misc{bosetti2019reducing,
  author = {Paolo Bosetti and Piero Poletti and Massimo Stella and Bruno Lepri and Stefano Merler and Manlio De Domenico},
  title = {{Reducing measles risk in Turkey through social integration of Syrian refugees}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1901.04214},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1901.04214},
}
Figure