TL;DR
This paper explores the effectiveness of a tele-audiology program in reducing the significant loss to follow-up for infants who don't pass their newborn hearing screenings. By leveraging remote diagnostic evaluations, the program successfully eliminated loss to follow-up and demonstrated high parent and provider satisfaction, proving tele-audiology to be a feasible and impactful solution for improving access to critical pediatric audiology services.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Early identification and intervention for hearing loss in infants are crucial for optimal speech, language, cognitive, and developmental outcomes. The Joint Committee on Infant Hearing recommends diagnostic hearing evaluations by 3 months of age for infants who fail newborn hearing screens, with intervention services initiated by 6 months. However, a substantial number of infants face significant barriers to accessing these timely evaluations. These barriers include long travel distances to specialized pediatric audiologists, especially in rural or underserved areas, coupled with challenges like transportation, childcare, and lost wages for families. This results in a high rate of "loss to follow-up," meaning infants don't receive the necessary diagnostic assessments, potentially delaying or preventing crucial early interventions. In California, for instance, 4.5% of infants were lost to follow-up in 2010, with one region experiencing an alarmingly high rate of nearly 22%. This paper tackles this critical access issue by investigating the feasibility and impact of a tele-audiology program designed to overcome these barriers.
Methods
The study employed an observational design to evaluate the California Tele-audiology Program (CTP). The CTP connects a pediatric audiologist at the University of California Davis Children's Hospital (UCDCH) with infants at an originating site hospital (Dignity Health Mercy Medical Center Redding - MMCR) located in a rural, underserved region with a high historical loss to follow-up rate.
The core of the methodology involved:
- Telemedicine Infrastructure: A telemedicine workstation at UCDCH facilitated live, interactive video consultations. A dedicated laptop at UCDCH remotely controlled audiology equipment located at MMCR via secure desktop software. This setup allowed the UCDCH audiologist to manage test parameters and interpret results in real-time.
- Tele-Audiology Evaluation: The diagnostic evaluation mirrored in-person assessments, including patient history, video otoscopy, immittance testing (including tympanometry and middle ear muscle reflexes), distortion product otoacoustic emissions, auditory brainstem response (ABR), and, when needed, auditory steady-state response.
- Telepresenter Role: A trained individual at the originating site (MMCR) acted as a telepresenter, preparing the infant, placing electrodes and probes, positioning the otoscope, and assisting the parent as guided by the remote audiologist.
- Data Collection: Data collected included infant age, hearing loss status (presence, severity, and type), and the number of encounters required for evaluation.
- Satisfaction Surveys: Both parents/guardians and the pediatric audiologist (provider) completed surveys to assess their perception of the telemedicine experience. These surveys covered aspects like the quality of visual and audio feeds, overall experience, satisfaction with discussions about hearing status, comfort discussing remotely, and the perceived importance of the tele-audiology service. Surveys used a 7-point Likert scale, with one question requiring a yes/no response.
Datasets
The study evaluated infants referred to the California Tele-audiology Program (CTP) between December 2011 and December 2013. These infants were identified by the Northern California Hearing Coordination Center (HCC) as having failed their newborn hearing screen. The dataset comprised 22 infants who underwent diagnostic evaluation through the CTP. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, the study focused on evaluating the existing loss to follow-up rates in the region prior to the program's implementation and comparing them to the CTP's outcomes.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Eliminating Loss to Follow-Up: The most striking insight is the program's complete success in eliminating loss to follow-up for referred infants. This directly addresses a critical bottleneck in early hearing intervention.
- High-Quality Remote Care: Despite the remote nature, both parents and providers reported high satisfaction with the quality of the visual and audio components of the tele-audiology consultations, suggesting that remote diagnostics can achieve a comparable level of care to in-person visits.
- Parental Engagement and Comfort: A significant finding is the high level of parental comfort and active engagement during remote history taking and counseling. This counters potential concerns about the impersonal nature of telemedicine for sensitive health discussions.
- Feasibility in Underserved Areas: The study demonstrates that tele-audiology is a viable solution for regions with limited access to specialized pediatric audiology services, effectively bringing expert care to families who would otherwise face significant hurdles.
- Timely Evaluations: The program facilitated diagnostic evaluations for a majority of infants within the recommended 3-month timeframe, crucial for timely intervention.
Key Results
- Zero Loss to Follow-Up: All 22 infants referred to the CTP completed their diagnostic evaluations, achieving a 0% loss to follow-up rate, a dramatic improvement from the pre-program regional rate of 22%.
- Hearing Loss Prevalence: 59.1% of the evaluated infants were diagnosed with some form of hearing loss. Of those with hearing loss, 61.5% had severe to profound hearing loss in at least one ear.
- Parent Satisfaction: Parents rated the quality of visual images (6.7/7), audio quality (6.7/7), and overall experience (6.8/7) highly. All parents rated the importance of tele-audiology as "extremely important" (7/7). 90.9% of parents were comfortable discussing their child's hearing status remotely.
- Provider Satisfaction: Providers scored the quality of visual images (5.9/7) and audio quality (6.7/7) favorably. The overall experience and importance of tele-audiology were rated at 5.9/7 and 6.4/7, respectively.
- Evaluation Efficiency: 60% of infants received their diagnosis during their first tele-audiology encounter. The average number of encounters needed was 1.9.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Limited Scope: The study only included infants referred by the HCC and did not assess the loss to follow-up rates for all infants who failed newborn screening in the region.
- Cost of Equipment: The initial cost of telemedicine equipment for both sites is a factor to consider, though it's a one-time capital expense.
Future research directions suggested include:
- Parental Interaction Nuances: Further investigation is needed to understand the parental interaction with providers during remote consultations and how this might impact the psychosocial aspects of receiving a hearing loss diagnosis when the provider is not physically present.
- Broader Impact: Expanding research to assess the long-term outcomes and psychosocial impacts of tele-audiology interventions would be valuable.
- Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: A comprehensive cost-effectiveness analysis comparing tele-audiology to traditional in-person evaluations could further support its widespread adoption.
Summary updated