Reducing Afterpulsing in InGaAs(P) Single-Photon Detectors with Hybrid Quenching

Junliang Liu, Yining Xu, Zheng Wang, Yongfu Li, Yi Gu, Zhaojun Liu, Xian Zhao2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "hybrid quenching" technique for InGaAs(P) single-photon detectors (SPDs) that combines fast active quenching with high-frequency gated-passive quenching. This approach significantly reduces afterpulsing, a major limitation for high-efficiency SPDs, enabling their use in demanding free-running applications like LiDAR and quantum key distribution.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Single-photon avalanche diodes (SPADs), particularly those made from InGaAs(P) for near-infrared detection, are crucial for applications like quantum key distribution (QKD) and LiDAR. However, a persistent challenge is the trade-off between high detection efficiency (PDE) and afterpulsing. Afterpulsing occurs when trapped carriers from a previous avalanche event trigger a new, spurious avalanche, leading to false counts. This problem becomes more severe at higher detection efficiencies. Traditional methods to mitigate afterpulsing, such as increasing the "hold-off time" (dead time) after an event, drastically reduce the detector's maximum count rate, making it less useful for real-time applications. Existing quenching techniques have limitations: gated-passive quenching can shorten avalanche pulses but may reduce overall efficiency in free-running modes, while active quenching can be complex to implement without introducing noise. This paper aims to overcome these limitations by developing a hybrid quenching method that simultaneously achieves high detection efficiency and low afterpulsing in free-running operation.

Methods

The core innovation is the "hybrid quenching" circuit, which integrates two techniques:

  • High-Frequency Gated-Passive Quenching: This method uses a periodic gating signal to briefly over-bias the SPAD, enabling avalanche detection. When the gate turns off, the SPAD is under-biased, effectively quenching the avalanche. This technique is known for producing short avalanche pulses, which helps suppress afterpulsing. The authors use a high-bandwidth RF transformer with a center tap and high-speed signal conditioning circuits, driven by an FPGA, to generate a precise gating signal.
  • Fast Active Quenching: This technique is added to the gated-passive approach. After an avalanche is detected, an active quenching signal is applied to rapidly pull the SPAD bias voltage below the breakdown threshold. This is crucial for stopping the avalanche very quickly, minimizing the number of trapped carriers available to cause afterpulses. The active quenching signal is generated by a D-type flip-flop register and amplified by an E-pHEMT transistor.

The combination aims to leverage the speed of active quenching to stop avalanches promptly and the short pulse generation of gated-passive quenching to minimize the generation of afterpulses, especially higher-order ones. The circuit also incorporates noise cancellation techniques, such as using the transformer's center tap and low-pass filters, to mitigate noise from the gating and quenching signals.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the characterization of commercially available InP-based SPADs (PGA-300 and PGA-384) using a pulsed laser source.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hybrid Quenching Synergy: The combination of gated-passive and active quenching is more effective than either method alone for reducing high-order afterpulsing. The active quenching component physically "closes" subsequent gates for a short period after an avalanche, preventing the release of trapped carriers.
  • Larger Detectors Suffer More: The PGA-384, with its larger active area, exhibits significantly higher afterpulsing probabilities compared to the PGA-300, highlighting the importance of effective quenching for larger-area SPADs.
  • Trade-off Still Exists, But Shifted: While the hybrid method improves the PDE-afterpulsing trade-off, achieving very high detection efficiencies still requires careful management of dead time, even with active quenching.
  • Free-Running Advantage: The proposed method is particularly beneficial for free-running applications where precise timing synchronization with the light source is not possible, as it maintains good performance without strict gating.
  • Improved Jitter: The hybrid quenching technique also offers a low and relatively fixed timing jitter, which is advantageous for applications like LiDAR where timing stability is critical.

Key Results

  • The hybrid quenching method achieved a 10% to 85% reduction in afterpulses compared to counter-based hold-off methods.
  • It enabled a gate-free detection efficiency of 4% to 10% at 1.06 µm with a 40 ns dead time.
  • For the PGA-384, the afterpulse probability was reduced to 6.2% and 3.7% at 40 ns and 100 ns dead times, respectively, representing up to an 85% reduction compared to counter-based dead time methods.
  • The timing jitter (FWHM) for the PGA-300 was found to be relatively stable, varying between 167 to 192 ps across a range of excess biases.
  • The dark count rate (DCR) was also improved, especially at higher excess biases, due to the reduced afterpulsing.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Effectiveness Varies with Detector: The hybrid quenching method was more impactful on the PGA-384, which inherently has higher afterpulsing. Its advantage was less pronounced on the PGA-300.
  • Dark Count Rate: While improved, the dark count rate for the gated detectors could be higher than free-running detectors due to the higher peak excess bias required by the hybrid method.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the hybrid quenching method can be applied to other high-frequency gated detectors for various applications, aiming for lower afterpulsing at high detection efficiencies or higher maximum detection efficiencies. They also note that for applications requiring even higher PDE in free-running mode, one might consider disabling the gating and relying solely on active quenching with a longer hold-off time.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{liu2020reducing,
  author = {Junliang Liu and Yining Xu and Zheng Wang and Yongfu Li and Yi Gu and Zhaojun Liu and Xian Zhao},
  title = {{Reducing Afterpulsing in InGaAs(P) Single-Photon Detectors with Hybrid Quenching}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/s20164384},
}

Loading related content...

Figure