Reduced graphene oxide membrane as supporting film for high-resolution cryo-EM

Nan Liu, Liming Zheng, Jie Xu, Jia Wang, Cuixia Hu, Jun Lan, Xing Zhang, Jincan Zhang, Kui Xu, Hang Cheng, Zi Yang, Xin Gao, Xinquan Wang, Hailin Peng, Yanan Chen, Hongwei WangbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a new, robust method to create reduced graphene oxide (RGO) membranes for cryo-EM grids. These RGO membranes significantly improve the quality of cryo-EM specimens, particularly for smaller biomolecules, enabling near-atomic resolution reconstructions and overcoming common challenges like air-water interface adsorption.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) is a powerful technique for determining the 3D structures of biological molecules at near-atomic resolution. However, a major hurdle limiting its widespread application is the difficulty in preparing high-quality specimens. Specifically, the process of vitrifying samples often leads to biomolecules adsorbing to the air-water interface, causing denaturation and poor particle orientation. This results in low-quality data and hinders achieving high resolution. While graphene-based materials have shown promise as supporting films, challenges remain in their reproducible fabrication and contamination-free transfer onto EM grids. This paper addresses the need for a more reliable and efficient method to prepare cryo-EM specimens, focusing on developing an improved supporting film.

Methods

The core of this work is the development of a robust and scalable method for fabricating reduced graphene oxide (RGO) membranes on EM grids.

  • Graphene Oxide (GO) Preparation: GO was either purchased or prepared using an improved Hummers' method.
  • GO Membrane Fabrication: GO solution was dispersed and then transferred onto Quantifoil gold EM grids using a water bath method, forming a GO film.
  • Reduction to RGO: The GO-coated grids were then subjected to a high-temperature reduction process in a hydrogen/argon atmosphere to convert GO into RGO. This step is crucial for improving electrical conductivity and reducing functional groups.
  • Characterization Techniques:
    • X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS): Used to analyze the chemical composition and reduction efficiency of GO and RGO, specifically looking at the reduction of oxygen-containing functional groups.
  • Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM): Employed to measure the interlayer spacing of GO and RGO membranes.
  • Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM): Used to visualize the RGO membrane coverage and assess its crystallinity.
  • Water Contact Angle (WCA) Measurements: Evaluated the hydrophilicity/hydrophobicity of the RGO and GO surfaces after plasma treatment.
  • Sheet Resistance Measurement: Determined the electrical conductivity of the GO and RGO membranes.
  • Cryo-EM Imaging and Reconstruction: Standard cryo-EM protocols were used to collect data on various biomolecules (20S proteasome, ribosome, RBD-ACE2 complex) using the RGO grids, followed by data processing and 3D reconstruction.
  • Cryo-electron Tomography (Cryo-ET): Used to visualize particle distribution within the vitreous ice on RGO-supported specimens.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the preparation and application of RGO grids for cryo-EM, using biological samples as test cases.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • RGO as a Superior Support: Reduced graphene oxide (RGO) offers significant advantages over graphene oxide (GO) as a cryo-EM support film due to its decreased interlayer space and enhanced electrical conductivity.
  • Mitigating Air-Water Interface Issues: RGO membranes exhibit better particle absorption, effectively preventing biomolecules from adsorbing to the air-water interface, a major source of denaturation and orientation problems.
  • Improved Image Stability: The enhanced electrical conductivity of RGO helps reduce charging effects during electron irradiation, leading to more stable images and less beam-induced damage.
  • Scalable Fabrication: The developed method allows for the large-batch fabrication of RGO grids, making it a practical solution for cryo-EM labs.
  • Effectiveness for Small Biomolecules: RGO grids are particularly beneficial for reconstructing smaller biomolecules (sub-100 kDa) at near-atomic resolution, where achieving good contrast and particle distribution can be challenging.

Key Results

  • Reduced Interlayer Space: RGO membranes showed an interlayer space of 0.3-0.4 nm, approximately half that of GO (>0.7 nm), indicating a more compact structure similar to graphene.
  • Enhanced Electrical Conductivity: RGO exhibited significantly reduced sheet resistance (~10⁵ Ω/sq) compared to the electrically insulative GO.
  • Reduced Beam-Induced Footprints: RGO membranes showed no visible beam-induced footprints after electron irradiation, unlike GO membranes which displayed distinct "white" and "black" disks.
  • High-Resolution Reconstructions:
    • 20S proteasome was reconstructed to 4.4 Å on RGO and 4.7 Å on GO.
  • Ribosome reconstruction achieved 6.1 Å on RGO, compared to 8.0 Å on GO.
  • The SARS-CoV2 RBD-ACE2 complex was reconstructed to 2.8 Å resolution using RGO grids.
  • Improved Particle Distribution: Cryo-ET analysis showed that particles were predominantly absorbed onto the RGO surface, avoiding the air-water interface.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Preferred Orientation: While RGO improves particle distribution, the authors acknowledge that adsorption onto the graphene surface can still lead to preferred orientation or other unfavorable consequences, which may limit the achievable resolution in some cases.
  • Functionalization: The authors suggest that better reconstruction results might be obtained by using RGO with multiple bioactive functionalizations, implying a direction for future research to further tailor the RGO surface properties.
  • Specific Applications: The paper highlights the utility for sub-100 kDa biomolecules, suggesting further exploration of RGO's effectiveness across a broader range of sample types and sizes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Although single-particle cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM) has been applied extensively for elucidating many crucial biological mechanisms at the molecular level, this technique still faces critical challenges, the major one of which is to prepare the high-quality cryo-EM specimen. Aiming to achieve a more reproducible and efficient cryo-EM specimen preparation, novel supporting films including graphene-based two-dimensional materials have been explored in recent years. Here we report a robust and simple method to fabricate EM grids coated with single- or few-layer reduced graphene oxide (RGO) membrane in large batch for high-resolution cryo-EM structural determination. The RGO membrane has decreased interlayer space and enhanced electrical conductivity in comparison to regular graphene oxide (GO) membrane. Moreover, we found that the RGO supporting film exhibited nice particle-absorption ability, thus avoiding the air-water interface problem. More importantly, we found that the RGO supporting film is particularly useful in cryo-EM reconstruction of sub-100 kDa biomolecules at near-atomic resolution, as exemplified by the study of RBD-ACE2 complex and other small protein molecules. We envision that the RGO membranes can be used as a robust graphene-based supporting film in cryo-EM specimen preparation.
BibTeX
@misc{liu2021reduced,
  author = {Nan Liu and Liming Zheng and Jie Xu and Jia Wang and Cuixia Hu and Jun Lan and Xing Zhang and Jincan Zhang and Kui Xu and Hang Cheng and Zi Yang and Xin Gao and Xinquan Wang and Hailin Peng and Yanan Chen and Hongwei Wang},
  title = {{Reduced graphene oxide membrane as supporting film for high-resolution cryo-EM}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.04.15.439953},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure