Red Mud-Amended Soil as Highly Adsorptive Hybrid-Fill Materials for Controlling Heavy Metal Sewage Seepage in Industrial Zone

Haomin Lei, Xin Xu, Xiaofeng Liu, Junboum Park, Zhongyu Yu, Hao LiuInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study proposes using red mud-amended soil as a hybrid-fill material to control heavy metal contamination from industrial sewage. The research demonstrates that this material significantly enhances adsorption capacity for lead and zinc, while also meeting crucial engineering strength requirements, offering a sustainable solution for industrial waste management and environmental protection.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Industrial development, particularly urbanization, has led to a significant increase in environmental pollution, with heavy metals from industrial sewage posing a major threat to soil and groundwater. These contaminants can cause severe environmental damage, reduce food production, and pose serious health risks to humans through bioaccumulation. Current remediation methods for heavy metal contamination are often costly and labor-intensive, especially for large-scale industrial zones where seepage can lead to widespread contamination. This paper addresses the need for an effective, cost-efficient, and sustainable barrier material to prevent the diffusion of heavy metals from industrial sewage into the surrounding environment.

Methods

The researchers investigated the use of red mud-amended soil as a hybrid-fill material. They employed several experimental techniques:

  • Direct Shear Test: To evaluate the mechanical strength (internal friction angle and cohesive force) of the hybrid-fill material, ensuring it meets foundation engineering requirements.
  • Permeability Test (Variable Head): To measure the hydraulic conductivity, a critical factor for the material's effectiveness in controlling seepage.
  • Adsorption and Desorption Batch Tests: To quantify the adsorption capacity of the material for zinc (Zn) and lead (Pb) ions at various initial concentrations and to assess the stability of the adsorbed metals by measuring desorption rates in distilled water and acidic solutions.
  • Column Test: To simulate real-world conditions of contaminant transport in the soil column under continuous rainfall, evaluating breakthrough curves at different initial concentrations and layer thicknesses.
  • Adsorption Isotherm Modeling: Langmuir and Freundlich models were used to understand the adsorption mechanisms of Zn and Pb ions.

Two mixing methods were explored: full particle size displacement mixing and partial particle size displacement mixing.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized soil and red mud samples collected from specific locations (Changchun and Shanxi, China, respectively) and prepared heavy metal solutions using analytical grade chemicals.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Red Mud as a Game-Changer: Red mud, a significant industrial byproduct, proves to be a highly effective additive for soil, dramatically increasing its heavy metal adsorption capacity. This offers a dual benefit of waste utilization and environmental remediation.
  • Optimal Red Mud Content: The study identified 20% red mud as the optimal content for the hybrid-fill material, balancing adsorption capacity with engineering properties. Exceeding this threshold led to a rapid decrease in the internal friction angle.
  • Partial Displacement Superiority: The partial particle size displacement mixing method showed superior adsorption performance compared to full particle size mixing, suggesting a more efficient interaction between red mud and soil particles for heavy metal capture.
  • Strong Anti-Desorption: The hybrid-fill material exhibited excellent stability, with desorption rates of adsorbed heavy metals (Zn and Pb) below 3% in distilled water and acidic solutions, indicating a low risk of secondary contamination.
  • Differential Adsorption: The material demonstrated a stronger adsorption capacity for lead ions than for zinc ions, which is attributed to lead ions forming more complex double-layer adsorption on the adsorbent surface.
  • Predictive Modeling for Practical Application: The development of a predictive formula for the useful time of the soil column, based on layer thickness and initial concentration, is a significant step towards practical engineering applications.

Key Results

  • Adsorption Capacity Boost: The adsorption capacity of the hybrid-fill material for Zn and Pb ions increased by 5.07 and 6.56 times, respectively, compared to the original soil sample at 25% red mud content.
  • Engineering Strength Met: The hybrid-fill material with 20% red mud achieved an internal friction angle of 38.9° and a cohesive force of 30.3 kPa, meeting the requirements for foundation materials.
  • Low Hydraulic Conductivity: The hydraulic conductivity of the hybrid-fill material ranged from 6.0 × 10⁻⁴ cm/s to 1.3 × 10⁻⁵ cm/s, decreasing with increasing red mud content, which is beneficial for ensuring sufficient contact time for adsorption.
  • Desorption Rates Below 6%: Desorption rates for both Zn and Pb ions in distilled water and acidic solutions were generally below 6%, with lead ions showing slightly lower desorption rates (below 3%).
  • Earlier Breakthrough for Higher Concentrations: In column tests, higher initial heavy metal concentrations led to earlier breakthrough times, indicating faster saturation of the adsorption sites.
  • Thickness Extends Useful Time: Increasing the hybrid-fill material layer thickness significantly prolonged the useful time of the soil column for heavy metal adsorption.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simulated Conditions: The study primarily used laboratory-scale tests. While column tests simulated field conditions, a three-dimensional soil tank test is suggested for further research to investigate the in situ performance of the hybrid-fill material under more realistic field conditions.
  • Long-Term Performance: The paper acknowledges the need to evaluate the long-term adsorption and desorption capacity, as well as the sustained engineering characteristics, of the hybrid-fill material.
  • Other Heavy Metals: While the study focused on zinc and lead, future work could explore the material's effectiveness for a broader range of heavy metals.
  • Mixing Method Optimization: Further optimization of mixing methods, particularly for partial particle size displacement, could potentially yield even better results.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the rapid development of urbanization, the problem of environmental pollution is becoming more and more serious. As a major pollutant, heavy metals have caused serious contamination in soil and groundwater. In order to prevent the diffusion of heavy metals in the soil from industrial sewage, the concept of hybrid-fill layer construction improved by red mud was proposed in this study. This study examines the adsorption capacities of lead and zinc ions and engineering characteristics on red mud-amended soils by direct shear, permeability, adsorption, desorption batch and column tests. Two mixing methods, full particle size displacement mixing and partial particle size displacement mixing, were adopted. The results showed that red mud effectively increased the adsorption capacity of soil to heavy metal ions, and the desorption rate of ions after adsorption was less than 3%, which had good anti-desorption ability. The optimum content of red mud in hybrid-fill material can be determined as 20%. The direct shear test showed that the internal friction angle of hybrid-fill material was 38.9°, and the cohesive force was 30.3 kPa, which met the engineering strength requirements of foundation materials. Based on the test results, red mud can be used as a barrier material to prevent heavy metal contamination in industrial sewage from diffusion, which controls not only heavy metal contamination but also consumes industrial by-products.
BibTeX
@article{lei2022red,
  author = {Haomin Lei and Xin Xu and Xiaofeng Liu and Junboum Park and Zhongyu Yu and Hao Liu},
  title = {{Red Mud-Amended Soil as Highly Adsorptive Hybrid-Fill Materials for Controlling Heavy Metal Sewage Seepage in Industrial Zone}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph192215043},
}
Figure